Care during labor and birth for the prevention of intrapartum-related neonatal deaths: a systematic review and Delphi estimation of mortality effect

Lee, Anne C. C.; Cousens, Simon; Darmstadt, Gary L.; Blencowe, Hannah; Pattinson, Robert; Moran, Neil F.; Hofmeyr, G. Justus; Haws, Rachel A.; Bhutta, Shereen Zulfiqar; Lawn, Joy E.
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011 Supplement 3, Vol. 11 Issue Suppl 3, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Our objective was to estimate the effect of various childbirth care packages on neonatal mortality due to intrapartum-related events ("birth asphyxia") in term babies for use in the Lives Saved Tool (LiST). Methods: We conducted a systematic literature review to identify studies or reviews of childbirth care packages as defined by United Nations norms (basic and comprehensive emergency obstetric care, skilled care at birth). We also reviewed Traditional Birth Attendant (TBA) training. Data were abstracted into standard tables and quality assessed by adapted GRADE criteria. For interventions with low quality evidence, but strong GRADE recommendation for implementation, an expert Delphi consensus process was conducted to estimate causespecific mortality effects. Results: We identified evidence for the effect on perinatal/neonatal mortality of emergency obstetric care packages: 9 studies (8 observational, 1 quasi-experimental), and for skilled childbirth care: 10 studies (8 observational, 2 quasi-experimental). Studies were of low quality, but the GRADE recommendation for implementation is strong. Our Delphi process included 21 experts representing all WHO regions and achieved consensus on the reduction of intrapartum-related neonatal deaths by comprehensive emergency obstetric care (85%), basic emergency obstetric care (40%), and skilled birth care (25%). For TBA training we identified 2 metaanalyses and 9 studies reporting mortality effects (3 cRCT, 1 quasi-experimental, 5 observational). There was substantial between-study heterogeneity and the overall quality of evidence was low. Because the GRADE recommendation for TBA training is conditional on the context and region, the effect was not estimated through a Delphi or included in the LiST tool. Conclusion: Evidence quality is rated low, partly because of challenges in undertaking RCTs for obstetric interventions, which are considered standard of care. Additional challenges for evidence interpretation include varying definitions of obstetric packages and inconsistent measurement of mortality outcomes. Thus, the LiST effect estimates for skilled birth and emergency obstetric care were based on expert opinion. Using LiST modelling, universal coverage of comprehensive obstetric care could avert 591,000 intrapartum-related neonatal deaths each year. Investment in childbirth care packages should be a priority and accompanied by implementation research and further evaluation of intervention impact and cost. Funding: This work was supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation through a grant to the US Fund for UNICEF, and to Saving Newborn Lives Save the Children, through Save the Children US.


Related Articles

  • Incidence of Birth Asphyxia as Seen in Central Hospital and GN Children's Clinic both in Warri Niger Delta of Nigeria: An Eight Year Retrospective Review. Mcgil Ugwu, G. I.; Abedi, H. O.; Ugwu, E. N. // Global Journal of Health Science;Sep2012, Vol. 4 Issue 5, p140 

    Background: Birth asphyxia is one of the commonest causes of neonatal morbidity and mortality in developing countries. Together with prematurity and neonatal sepsis, they account for over 80% of neonatal deaths.Aim: To determine the incidence and mortality rate of birth asphyxia in Warri Niger...

  • Early neonatal mortality, asphyxia related deaths, and timing of low risk births in Hesse, Germany, 1990-8: observational study. Heller, Gunther; Misselwitz, Bjorn; Schmidt, Stephan // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);07/29/2000, Vol. 321 Issue 7256, p274 

    Discusses an investigation of the impact of the time of birth on neonatal mortality or deaths related to asphyxia in low-risk births. Use of data from the perinatal birth register of Hesse, Germany; Assessment of the effects of night and day on death rates; Results that confirm a higher early...

  • Neonatal Outcomes and Quality of Care in Level II Perinatal Centers Supported by a Children's Hospital-Medical School Level III Program. Hall, Robert T; Santos, Susan R; Teasley, Susan L; Brown, Mary Jean // Journal of Perinatology;Jun2003, Vol. 23 Issue 4, p323 

    OBJECTIVE: Eight Level II perinatal centers developed contracts with the children's hospital to provide consultative neonatal patient care, education, and administrative support. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate infant outcomes and quality of care during a 3-year period of the...

  • Home birth safe for low risk women in UK.  // Midwifery Matters;Summer2009, Issue 121, p31 

    This article reports on home childbirth in Great Britain for low-risk pregnant women. The article discusses research on the safety of home births for mothers and infants. Information is also provided on the lack of conclusive evidence indicating an increased risk of infant mortality in home...

  • Neonatal outcome associated with singleton birth at 34–41 weeks of gestation. Gouyon, Jean-Bernard; Vintejoux, Amélie; Sagot, Paul; Burguet, Antoine; Quantin, Catherine; Ferdynus, Cyril // International Journal of Epidemiology;Jun2010, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p769 

    Background Approximately 75% of preterm births are late-preterm (340/7 to 366/7 weeks gestation). This group has usually been considered as a whole in studies assessing the outcome of these preterm infants by comparison with term infants. However, the respective contribution to prognosis of each...

  • Maternal and Neonatal Mortality in South-West Ethiopia: Estimates and Socio-Economic Inequality. Yaya, Yaliso; Eide, Kristiane Tislevoll; Norheim, Ole Frithjof; Lindtjørn, Bernt // PLoS ONE;Apr2014, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p1 

    Introduction: Ethiopia has achieved the fourth Millennium Development Goal by reducing under 5 mortality. Nevertheless, there are challenges in reducing maternal and neonatal mortality. The aim of this study was to estimate maternal and neonatal mortality and the socio-economic inequalities of...

  • Evidence of selection bias in preterm survival studies: a systematic review. Evans, D. J.; Levene, M. I. // Archives of Disease in Childhood -- Fetal & Neonatal Edition;Mar2001, Vol. 84 Issue 2, pF79 

    Objective-To determine by how much selection bias in preterm infant cohort studies results in an overestimate of survival. Design-Systematic review of studies reporting survival in infants less than 28 weeks of gestation published 1978-1998. Studies were graded according to cohort definition: A,...

  • Planned home births are linked with higher rates of neonatal mortality, study shows. Mayor, Susan // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;7/10/2010, Vol. 341 Issue 7763, p69 

    The article reports on higher rates of neonatal mortality in planned home births compared to hospital deliveries in developed countries, which is associated to the difference of medical intervention and access to neonatal resuscitation.

  • Study shows IVF baby risk.  // Australian Nursing Journal;Apr2001, Vol. 8 Issue 9, p7 

    Focuses on a study which showed that babies born as a result of in vitro fertilization (IVF) have an increased risk of premature delivery and need longer intensive care treatment. Significance of the findings; Deaths of Aboriginal infants in Townsville.


Other Topics