Policy guidance on threats to legislative interventions in public health: a realist synthesis

Wong, Geoff; Pawson, Ray; Owen, Lesley
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p222
Academic Journal
Background: Legislation is one of the most powerful weapons for improving population health and is often used by policy and decision makers. Little research exists to guide them as to whether legislation is feasible and/or will succeed. We aimed to produce a coherent and transferable evidence based framework of threats to legislative interventions to assist the decision making process and to test this through the 'case study' of legislation to ban smoking in cars carrying children. Methods: We conceptualised legislative interventions as a complex social interventions and so used the realist synthesis method to systematically review the literature for evidence. 99 articles were found through searches on five electronic databases (MEDLINE, HMIC, EMBASE, PsychINFO, Social Policy and Practice) and iterative purposive searching. Our initial searches sought any studies that contained information on smoking in vehicles carrying children. Throughout the review we continued where needed to search for additional studies of any type that would conceptually contribute to helping build and/or test our framework. Results: Our framework identified a series of transferable threats to public health legislation. When applied to smoking bans in vehicles; problem misidentification; public support; opposition; and enforcement issues were particularly prominent threats. Our framework enabled us to understand and explain the nature of each threat and to infer the most likely outcome if such legislation were to be proposed in a jurisdiction where no such ban existed. Specifically, the micro-environment of a vehicle can contain highly hazardous levels of second hand smoke. Public support for such legislation is high amongst smokers and non-smokers and their underlying motivations were very similar - wanting to practice the Millian principle of protecting children from harm. Evidence indicated that the tobacco industry was not likely to oppose legislation and arguments that such a law would be 'unenforceable' were unfounded. Conclusion: It is possible to develop a coherent and transferable evidence based framework of the ideas and assumptions behind the threats to legislative intervention that may assist policy and decision makers to analyse and judge if legislation is feasible and/or likely to succeed.


Related Articles

  • Smoking prevalence in a north-west town following the introduction of Smoke-free England. P. J. Elton; P. Campbell // Journal of Public Health;Dec2008, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p415 

    : Background In July 2007, legislation banning smoking in public places was introduced in England. This study investigates the impact of this legislation on smoking in Bury. : Methods A postal survey was undertaken before the implementation of the legislation. The survey was repeated 3 months...

  • It's just the nicotine talking. Cooney, Darren // Xtra (Toronto);6/10/2004, Issue 512, p7 

    Relates the reaction of smokers to the implementation of the smoking by-law in Toronto, Ontario on June 1, 2004. Opinions of smokers on the issue; Creation of an in and out system for smokers in certain venues.

  • Türkiye'de Sigara Tüketimini Etkileyen Faktörlerin Analizi. Oğuztürk, Bekir Sami; Gülcü, Yunus // Journal of Alanya Faculty of Business / Alanya Isletme Fakültes;Dec2012, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p99 

    Turkey is one of the leading countries in cigarette consumption in the world. Cigarette consumption is not seen as a habit anymore in Turkey; it has almost become a traditional behavior. In the study, cigarette consumption in Turkey for the period 1980-2010 is investigated. Factors which effect...

  • Smoking ban will be good for us all. Kirwan, Nick // Mortgage Strategy;4/3/2006, p37 

    The article discusses issues concerning the implementation of smoking ban in public places in Scotland. The author believes that the smoking ban will be good for both smokers and non-smokers. The ban could result in the reduction in the number of social smokers and maybe even the number of...

  • The Brazil SimSmoke Policy Simulation Model: The Effect of Strong Tobacco Control Policies on Smoking Prevalence and Smoking-Attributable Deaths in a Middle Income Nation. Levy, David; de Almeida, Liz Maria; Szklo, Andre // PLoS Medicine;Nov2012, Vol. 9 Issue 11, p1 

    Background: Brazil has reduced its smoking rate by about 50% in the last 20 y. During that time period, strong tobacco control policies were implemented. This paper estimates the effect of these stricter policies on smoking prevalence and associated premature mortality, and the effect that...

  • Blunt Talk. Mangu-Ward, Katherine // Reason;Mar2009, Vol. 40 Issue 10, p8 

    The article reports that Prince George's County, Maryland, has banned the single sale of cheap cigars, which can now be purchased only in packs of five or more. According to the county council, single blunts are gateways to cigarette smoking and drug paraphernalia, since they can be hollowed out...

  • Butting out in Canada: five down, eight to go. Mackay, Bradford // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;9/14/2004, Vol. 171 Issue 6, p558 

    Reports on the implementation of the ban on smoking in public places in Canada in 2004. Provinces which implemented the ban; Significance of the ban to the public health initiative of the country; Factors that led former smokers to quit their tobacco habit.

  • Differences in risk‐taking propensity across inner‐city adolescent ever‐ and never‐smokers. Lejuez, C. W.; Aklin, Will M.; Bornovalova, Marina A.; Moolchan, Eric T. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Feb2005, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p71 

    Because adolescent smoking is a significant public health concern, potential value lies in understanding and identifying the psychological factors that distinguish ever- and never-smokers. To that end, we examined the relationship between risk-taking propensity as measured by the Balloon...

  • Changes in hospitality workers' exposure to secondhand smoke following the implementation of New York's smoke-free law. Farrelly, M. C.; Nonnemaker, J. M.; Chou, R.; Hyland, A.; Peterson, K. K.; Bauer, U. E. // Tobacco Control;Aug2005, Vol. 14 Issue 4, p236 

    Objective: To assess the impact on hospitality workers' exposure to secondhand smoke of New York's smoke-free law that prohibits smoking in all places of employment, including restaurants, bars, and bowling facilities. Design: Pre-post longitudinal follow up design. Settings: Restaurants, bars,...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics