An evaluation of the effectiveness of a community mentoring service for socially isolated older people: a controlled trial

Dickens, Andy P.; Richards, Suzanne H.; Hawton, Annie; Taylor, Rod S.; Greaves, Colin J.; Green, Colin; Edwards, Rachel; Campbell, John L.
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p218
Academic Journal
Background: Social isolation affects a significant proportion of older people and is associated with poor health outcomes. The current evidence base regarding the effectiveness of interventions targeting social isolation is poor, and the potential utility of mentoring for this purpose has not previously been rigorously evaluated. The purpose of this study was to examine the effectiveness of a community-based mentoring service for improving mental health, social engagement and physical health for socially isolated older people. Methods: This prospective controlled trial compared a sample of mentoring service clients (intervention group) with a matched control group recruited through general practice. One hundred and ninety five participants from each group were matched on mental wellbeing and social activity scores. Assessments were conducted at baseline and at six month follow-up. The primary outcome was the Short Form Health Survey v2 (SF-12) mental health component score (MCS). Secondary outcomes included the SF-12 physical health component score (PCS), EuroQol EQ-5D, Geriatric Depression Score (GDS-10), social activity, social support and morbidities. Results: We found no evidence that mentoring was beneficial across a wide range of participant outcomes measuring health status, social activity and depression. No statistically significant between-group differences were observed at follow-up in the primary outcome (p = 0.48) and in most secondary outcomes. Identifying suitable matched pairs of intervention and control group participants proved challenging. Conclusions: The results of this trial provide no substantial evidence supporting the use of community mentoring as an effective means of alleviating social isolation in older people. Further evidence is needed on the effectiveness of community-based interventions targeting social isolation. When using non-randomised designs, there are considerable challenges in the recruitment of suitable matches from a community sample. Trial registration: SCIE Research Register for Social Care 105923


Related Articles

  • Healthy Community; Healthy People. Hall, Burl // Communities;Spring2011, Issue 150, p42 

    The article presents the author's views on the effect of community support on mental health. He says that the true measure of mental health is the ability of the community to recognize the needs of its members and not to isolate people. He mentions that a community that is designed to empower...

  • The Relationship of Home Smoking Bans to the Physical and Mental Health of Smokers. Asbridge, Mark; Cartwright, Jenny // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Feb2011, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p70 

    Introduction: The aim of this study is to examine whether the adoption of home smoking bans is associated with the physical and mental health of smokers. Two potential pathways that link home smoking bans to smoker's health are analyzed. The first argues that home smoking bans are positively...

  • Bridgend suicides point to social dislocation. Williamson, Howard // Children & Young People Now (Haymarket Business Publications Ltd;3/5/2008, p18 

    The author reflects on the relationship between social dislocation and suicides in Bridgend, Wales. He says that after the Welsh Assembly's publication of the mental health strategy called "Everybody's Business," the 17 suicides in Bridgend aroused controversies from the people. He says that...

  • In This Issue: Generalist Care Around the World. Frey III, John J. // Annals of Family Medicine;Sep/Oct2015, Vol. 13 Issue 5, p406 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including social isolation, mental health problems, and congestive heart failure.

  • Toward a national consumer survey: evaluation of the CABHS and MHSIP instruments. Eisen, Susan V.; Shaul, James A.; Left, H. Stephen; Stringfellow, Vickie; Clarridge, Brian R.; Cleary, Paul D.; Eisen, S V; Shaul, J A; Leff, H S; Stringfellow, V; Clarridge, B R; Cleary, P D // Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research;Aug2001, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p347 

    This article describes a study evaluating the Consumer Assessment of Behavioral Health Survey (CABHS) and the Mental Health Statistics Improvement Program (MHSIP) surveys. The purpose of the study was to provide data that could be used to develop recommendations for an improved instrument....

  • Physical health remains poor.  // Mental Health Nursing;Apr2011, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p5 

    The article reports on the result of a new study which revealed that physical ill-health is dominant among the severely mentally-ill people in Great Britain.

  • Mental Health in Older People: A Mixed Case Part I: Psychiatry in the Elderly (Book). Dening, Tom; Barapatre, Charul // Age & Ageing;Mar2004, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p213 

    Reviews the book "Mental Health in Older People: A Mixed Case Part I," edited by Robin Jacoby and Catherine Oppenheimer.

  • EVENTS.  // Australian Nursing Journal;Aug2011, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p27 

    A 2011 calendar of events related to nursing in Australia is presented which includes the fourth Indigenous Mental Health conference titled Our Mob, Our Minds, Our Spirit, the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies National Indigenous Studies Conference and a...

  • THE YIN AND YANG OF COMMUNITIES. Brown, Julie // Alive: Canada's Natural Health & Wellness Magazine;Sep2010, Issue 335, p17 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Social connections" in the July 2010 issue.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics