Assembling the evidence jigsaw: insights from a systematic review of UK studies of individualfocused return to work initiatives for disabled and long-term ill people

Clayton, Stephen; Bambra, Clare; Gosling, Rachael; Povall, Sue; Misso, Kate; Whitehead, Margaret
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p170
Academic Journal
Background: Employment rates of long-term ill and disabled people in the UK are low and 2.63 million are on disability-related state benefits. Since the mid-1990 s, UK governments have experimented with a range of active labour market policies aimed to move disabled people off benefits and into work to reduce the risk of poverty and social exclusion. This systematic review asks what employment impact have these interventions had and how might they work better? Methods: A systematic review of observational and qualitative empirical studies and systematic reviews published between 2002 and mid-2008 reporting employment effects and/or process evaluations of national UK government interventions focused on helping long-term sick or disabled people (aged 16-64) into the open labour market. This built on our previous systematic review which covered the years 1970 to 2001. Results: Searches identified 42 studies, 31 of which evaluated initiatives with an individual focus (improving an individual's employability or providing financial support in returning to work) while 11 evaluated initiatives with an environmental focus (directed at the employment environment or changing the behaviour of employers). This paper synthesises evidence from the 31 studies with an individual focus. The use of personal advisors and individual case management in these schemes helped some participants back to work. Qualitative studies, however, revealed that time pressures and job outcome targets influenced advisors to select 'easier-to-place' claimants into programmes and also inhibited the development of mutual trust, which was needed for individual case management to work effectively. Financial incentives can help with lasting transitions into work, but the incentives were often set too low or were too short-term to have an effect. Many of the studies suffered from selection bias into these programmes of more work-ready claimants. Even though these were national programmes, they had very low awareness and take-up rates, making it unlikely that a population-level impact would be achieved even if effective for participants. Conclusions: The evidence reveals barriers and facilitators for the effective implementation of these types of interventions that could inform the continuing welfare reforms. The evidence points towards the need for more long-term, sustained and staged support for those furthest from the labour market.


Related Articles

  • GÉNERO Y BIENESTAR. Aznar, María Pilar Matud // Avances en Psicología;2009, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p23 

    Studies of gender and welfare show the relevance of social factors in women and men welfare. Those worldwide studies indicate that inequality is a threat for women health and welfare. Such inequality is based on violence of which they are victims of, as well as poverty that affects thousands of...

  • Policy Barriers for People with Disabilities Who Want to Work. O'Day, Bonnie // American Rehabilitation;Spring/Summer99, Vol. 25 Issue 1/2, p8 

    Explores the barriers, presented by government programs in the United States, to the employment of people with disabilities. Goals that should govern Social Security programs; Evaluation on various federal reform proposals; Responses of the states to the problem of unemployment.

  • FROM WELFARE RECIPIENT TO CHILDCARE WORKER: BALANCING WORK AND FAMILY UNDER TANF. Hooton, Angela // Texas Journal of Women & the Law;Fall2002, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p121 

    Focuses on the concept of Temporary Aid to Needy Families, a federal welfare program that promotes work and marriage as the solutions to the poverty crisis among single-parent households in the U.S. Legality of mothers to work in the labor market; Sponsorship of the childcare worker program;...

  • Grass-roots issue.  // Crain's Cleveland Business;2/21/94, Vol. 15 Issue 8, p10 

    Editorial. Focuses on the preparation of Cleveland, Ohio's business community to lend a hand to grass-roots efforts aimed at freeing urban dwellers from poverty and welfare. Description of NationsBank's Atlanta Project; Use of a neighborhood approach; Issue on reforms.

  • More poverty, more abortions.  // Dollars & Sense;Sep/Oct98, Issue 219, p5 

    Presents information on the Family Development Program which is a child capping, welfare reform policy in New Jersey, with reference to findings from a study by researchers at Rutgers University on the effect of the policy. Effect of the policy on women on welfare; Suggestion that the policy...

  • Tarrant leaders reveal action plan for local welfare reform. Gardner, Natalie // Business Press;01/09/98, Vol. 10 Issue 37, p3 

    Details a strategic plan devised by the Tarrant County Together Task Force on Poverty and Self-Sufficiency, in an effort to promote welfare reform. Assessment of a report compiled by the Task Force; Comments by Janie McGuigan, human resources planner for Tarrant County; Outline of the Task...

  • Poverty still makes you ill.  // Public Finance;7/29/94, p5 

    Reports on the United Kingdom welfare system as suffering more as a result of long waiting lists than welfare systems in other comparable countries. Links between the economy and health to poverty; NHS's provision of value for money and containing growth in aggregate health spending.

  • Basic income will be fairer and cheaper. Pereira, Richard // Inroads;Winter/Spring2015, Issue 36, p15 

    A review of the article "A Dubious Antipoverty Strategy" by Jonathan Rhys Kesselman, which appeared in the periodical "Inroad" in the Winter/Spring 2014 issue is presented.

  • Reform's ignored goal: marriage promotion. Malcolm, Teresa // National Catholic Reporter;3/1/2002, Vol. 38 Issue 17, p5 

    Focuses on the public welfare program in the United States. Goals of the welfare programs; Causes of child poverty and welfare dependence; Decline in the rate of non-marital births in the United States; Programs to improve rate of marriages in the country.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics