The association between a journal's source of revenue and the drug recommendations made in the articles it publishes

Becker, Annette; Dörter, Fatma; Eckhardt, Kirsten; Viniol, Annika; Baum, Erika; Kochen, Michael M.; Lexchin, Joel; Wegscheider, Karl; Donner-Banzhoff, Norbert
March 2011
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;3/22/2011, Vol. 183 Issue 5, p544
Academic Journal
Background: There is evidence to suggest that pharmaceutical companies influence the publication and content of research papers. Most German physicians rely on journals for their continuing medical education. We studied the influence of pharmaceutical advertising on the drug recommendations made in articles published in 11 German journals that focus on continuing medical education. Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional study of all of the issues of 11 journals published in 2007. Only journals frequently read by general practitioners were chosen. Issues were screened for pharmaceutical advertisements and recommendations made in the editorial content for a specified selection of drugs. Each journal was rated on a five-point scale according to the strength with which it either recommended or discouraged the use of these drugs. We looked for differences in these ratings between free journals (i.e., those financed entirely by pharmaceutical advertising), journals with mixed sources of revenue and journals financed solely by subscription fees. The journals were also screened for the simultaneous appearance of advertisements and recommendations for the same drug within a certain period, which was adjusted for both journal and class of drug. Results: We identified 313 issues containing at least one advertisement for the selected drugs and 412 articles in which drug recommendations were made. Free journals were more likely to recommend the specified drugs than journals with sources of revenue that were mixed or based solely on subscriptions. The simultaneous appearance of advertisements and recommendations for the same drug in the same issue of a journal showed an inconsistent association. Interpretation: Free journals almost exclusively recommended the use of the specified drugs, whereas journals financed entirely with subscription fees tended to recommend against the use of the same drugs. Doctors should be aware of this bias in their use of material published in medical journals that focus on continuing medical education.


Related Articles

  • Journals continue slide. Israel, Benjamin; Venhaus, Lynn // St. Louis Journalism Review;May/Jun2009, Vol. 39 Issue 313, p4 

    The article presents an update on the changes and on the circulation status of the Suburban Journals, owned by publisher Lee Enterprises, as of May 2009. It notes that two reporters for the "North County Journal" work out of its office located in Town & Country in Missouri. The Journals used to...

  • Dear Readers. Gavin, William T. // Review (00149187);Jul/Aug2012, Vol. 94 Issue 4, preceding p243 

    The article offers information on the changes related to periodical subscriptions in the U.S. It mentions the changes in the distribution the free periodical "Review" effective March and April 2013. Moreover, it features the reasons for stopping the distribution of its international and domestic...

  • Free weeklies buoy the sector.  // MediaWeek;8/19/2008, Vol. 18 Issue 29, special section p7 

    This article reports that sales of monthly men's magazines have decreased throughout 2008, while the circulation of free weekly men's magazines have increased. A chart is included that lists details on the sales of the ten most circulated monthly men's magazines and two free weekly men's...

  • FREE TRIALS OF CRAIN'S ONLINE NEWSLETTERS.  // Crain's New York Business;10/27/2008, Vol. 24 Issue 43, p15 

    The article reports that the periodical is offering readers free two-week trial subscriptions to its online newsletters. The newsletters include "Crain's Health Plus" and "The Crain's Insider." The annual subscription to "Crain's Health Plus" costs $319, whereas subscription to "The Crain's...

  • Subcription.  // Political Analysis;Jan2011, Vol. 19 Issue 1, pNP 

    The article provides subscription information for the journal “Political Analysis.”

  • Subscriptions.  // Publius: The Journal of Federalism;Oct2011, Vol. 41 Issue 4, pi2 

    The article provides subscription information for the journal.

  • Subscription Page.  // Community Development Journal;Apr2011, Vol. 46 Issue 2, pNP 

    The article presents information on subscriptions to the journal.

  • Subscriptions.  // Public Opinion Quarterly;Dec2012, Vol. 76 Issue 4, pNP 

    The article presents front matter for the December 2012 issue, listing subscription information, contact addresses, and explanations of copyright and digital availability.

  • Subscription Page.  // IMRN: International Mathematics Research Notices;Apr2011, Vol. 2011 Issue 8, pNP 

    The article presents subscription information for the "International Mathematics Research Notices."


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics