Human Health and the Biological Effects of Tritium in Drinking Water: Prudent Policy Through Science - Addressing the ODWAC New Recommendation

Dingwall, S.; Mills, C. E.; Phan, N.; Taylor, K.; Boreham, D. R.
January 2011
Dose-Response;2011, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p6
Academic Journal
Tritium is a radioactive form of hydrogen and is a by-product of energy production in Canadian Deuterium Uranium (CANDU) reactors. The release of this radioisotope into the environment is carefully managed at CANDU facilities in order to minimize radiation exposure to the public. However, under some circumstances, small accidental releases to the environment can occur. The radiation doses to humans and non-human biota from these releases are low and orders of magnitude less than doses received from naturally occurring radioisotopes or from manmade activities, such as medical imaging and air travel. There is however a renewed interest in the biological consequences of low dose tritium exposures and a new limit for tritium levels in Ontario drinking water has been proposed. The Ontario Drinking Water Advisory Council (ODWAC) issued a formal report in May 2009 in response to a request by the Minister of the Environment, concluding that the Ontario Drinking Water Quality Standard for tritium should be revised from the current 7,000 Bq/L level to a new, lower 20 Bq/L level. In response to this recommendation, an international scientific symposium was held at McMaster University to address the issues surrounding this change in direction and the validity of a new policy. Scientists, regulators, government officials, and industrial stakeholders were present to discuss the potential health risks associated with low level radiation exposure from tritium. The regulatory, economic, and social implications of the new proposed limit were also considered.The new recommendation assumed a linear-no-threshold model to calculate carcinogenic risk associated with tritium exposure, and considered tritium as a non-threshold chemical carcinogen. Both of these assumptions are highly controversial given that recent research suggests that low dose exposures have thresholds below which there are no observable detrimental effects. Furthermore, mutagenic and carcinogenic risk calculated from tritium exposure at 20 Bq/L would be orders of magnitude less than that from exposure to natural background sources of radiation. The new proposed standard would set the radiation dose limit for drinking water to 0.0003 mSv/year, which is equivalent to approximately three times the dose from naturally occurring tritium in drinking water. This new standard is incongruent with national and international standards for safe levels of radiation exposure, currently set at 1 mSv/year for the general public. Scientific research from leading authorities on the carcinogenic health effects of tritium exposure supports the notion that the current standard of 7,000 Bq/L (annual dose of 0.1 mSv) is a safe standard for human health.Policy-making for the purpose of regulating tritium levels in drinking water is a dynamic multi-stage process that is influenced by more than science alone. Ethics, economics, and public perception also play important roles in policy development; however, these factors sometimes undermine the scientific evidence that should form the basis of informed decision making. Consequently, implementing a new standard without a scientific basis may lead the public to perceive that risks from tritium have been historically underestimated. It was concluded that the new recommendation is not supported by any new scientific insight regarding negative consequences of low dose effects, and may be contrary to new data on the potential benefits of low dose effects. Given the lack of cost versus benefit analysis, this type of dramatic policy change could have detrimental effects to society from an ethical, economical, and public perception perspective.


Related Articles

  • Biological and Physiochemical Techniques for the Removal of Zinc from Drinking Water: A Review. Zahra, Naseem; Butt, Yasha Nazir; Alim-Un-Nisa // Pakistan Journal of Analytical & Environmental Chemistry;12/31/2015, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p1 

    Presence of Zinc (II) in drinking water beyond permissible limits is considered unsafe for human health. Many different anthropogenic activities including mining, burning of petroleum, industrialization, and urbanization cause a release of considerably higher amounts of zinc into the...

  • Nonlinearity of Radiation Health Effects. Pollycove, Myron; Calabrese, Edward J. // Environmental Health Perspectives Supplements;Feb98 Supplement 1, Vol. 106, p363 

    Presents a study in which observations of fundamental biologic cellular functions contradict the theoretical presumption based on biophysical concepts about the health consequences of radiation exposure and exclude a linear nonthreshold hypothesis dose-response relationship.

  • Assessment of the chemical quality of drinking water in Cambodia. Feldman, Peter R.; Rosenboom, Jan-Willem; Saray, Mao; Navuth, Peng; Samnang, Chea; Iddings, Steven // Journal of Water & Health;Mar2007, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p101 

    Most water supply programmes in Cambodia have focused on providing access to bacteriologically safe water, an approach which has led to an increasing reliance on ground water, especially in rural areas. However, there have been very few data collected on the chemical quality of the nation's...

  • Estimation of geographical variation of cancer risks in drinking water in Japan. Ohno, K.; Kadota, E.; Kondo, Y.; Kamel, T.; Magara, Y. // Water Science & Technology: Water Supply;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p31 

    The cancer risks posed by ten substances in raw and purified water were estimated for each municipality in Japan to compare risks between raw and purified water, and inter-municipality. Water concentrations were estimated by use of statistical data. Assigning cancer unit risks to each substance...

  • Semi-volatile organic compounds and trace elements in the Yangtze River source of drinking water. Bing Wu; Xuxiang Zhang; Xiaolin Zhang; Aishangjiang Yasun; Yan Zhang; Dayong Zhao; Ford, Tim; Shupei Cheng // Ecotoxicology;Aug2009, Vol. 18 Issue 6, p707 

    Determination of 24 semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) and 24 trace elements in water samples was conducted in order to investigate the quality of the Nanjing source of drinking water taken from Yangtze River. The total concentrations of SVOCs and trace elements were in the range of...

  • The main hazards of health technology. Legault, Timothy // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;2/8/2011, Vol. 183 Issue 2, pE95 

    The article focuses on the report "Top 10 Health Technology Hazards for 2011," by ECRI Institute, a nonprofit organization based in Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania. It mentions several technology hazards that topped the list including radiation overdoses and dosing errors during therapy. It...

  • Radiation Dose From Cardiac Computed Tomography Before and After Implementation of Radiation Dose-Reduction Techniques. Raff, Gilbert L.; Chinnaiyan, Kavitha M.; Share, David A.; Goraya, Tauqir Y.; Kazerooni, Ella A.; Moscucci, Mauro; Gentry, Ralph E.; Abidov, Aiden // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;6/10/2009, Vol. 301 Issue 22, p2340 

    The article focuses on a study which investigated if a collaborative radiation dose-reduction program will be linked with reduced radiation dose in patients who are undergoing cardiac computed tomography angiography (CCTA). The study was conducted among 4,995 patients from 15 hospital imaging...

  • Response to the Comment on “A proposal for in vitro/GFR molecular erythema action spectrum”. de Souza, J. A. V.; Lorenzini, F.; Rizzatti, M. R. // Journal of Applied Physics;Jun2009, Vol. 105 Issue 11, p116104 

    The article is the authors' response to "Comment on 'A proposal for in vitro/GFR molecular erythema action spectrum'" which is in this issue. The authors say that the conjugation process that produced a red shift, the selection of the acronym TSD for the tissue simulator of skin, the effect of...

  • Radiation-Induced Neoplastic Transformation in Vitro, Hormesis and Risk Assessment. Redpath, J. Leslie; Elmore, Eugene // Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p123 

    Dose-response curves for various low-LET radiation sources have consistently been demonstrated to be J-shaped for the cancer-relevant endpoint of neoplastic transformation in vitro. Most of these studies have been performed where the radiation has been delivered at intermediate to high...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics