Variability in school closure decisions in response to 2009 H1N1: a qualitative systems improvement analysis

Klaiman, Tamar; Kraemer, John D.; Stoto, Michael A.
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p73
Academic Journal
Background: School closure was employed as a non-pharmaceutical intervention against pandemic 2009 H1N1, particularly during the first wave. More than 700 schools in the United States were closed. However, closure decisions reflected significant variation in rationales, decision triggers, and authority for closure. This variability presents the opportunity for improved efficiency and decision-making. Methods: We identified media reports relating to school closure as a response to 2009 H1N1 by monitoring highprofile sources and searching Lexis-Nexis and Google news alerts, and reviewed reports for key themes. News stories were supplemented by observing conference calls and meetings with health department and school officials, and by discussions with decision-makers and community members. Results: There was significant variation in the stated goal of closure decision, including limiting community spread of the virus, protecting particularly vulnerable students, and responding to staff shortages or student absenteeism. Because the goal of closure is relevant to its timing, nature, and duration, unclear rationales for closure can challenge its effectiveness. There was also significant variation in the decision-making authority to close schools in different jurisdictions, which, in some instances, was reflected in open disagreement between school and public health officials. Finally, decision-makers did not appear to expect the level of scientific uncertainty encountered early in the pandemic, and they often expressed significant frustration over changing CDC guidance. Conclusions: The use of school closure as a public health response to epidemic disease can be improved by ensuring that officials clarify the goals of closure and tailor closure decisions to those goals. Additionally, authority to close schools should be clarified in advance, and decision-makers should expect to encounter uncertainty disease emergencies unfold and plan accordingly.


Related Articles

  • The 2009 H1N1 Influenza Pandemic and Minnesota's K-12 Schools. Como-Sabetti, Kathryn; Livingston, Franci; Gahr, Pamala; Nagle, Kayla; Martin, Karen; Morin, Craig; Parilla, Elizabeth // Minnesota Medicine;Sep2010, Vol. 93 Issue 9, p36 

    Prior to 2009, influenza pandemic planners had primarily planned for a virus that would originate in a location other than North America, giving public health officials in the United States time to determine its severity before widespread disease occurred here. Thus, response plans for schools...

  • School closures during the 2009 influenza pandemic: national and local experiences. Cauchemez, Simon; Van Kerkhove, Maria D.; Archer, Brett N.; Cetron, Martin; Cowling, Benjamin J.; Grove, Peter; Hunt, Darren; Kojouharova, Mira; Kon, Predrag; Ungchusak, Kumnuan; Oshitani, Hitoshi; Pugliese, Andrea; Rizzo, Caterina; Saour, Guillaume; Sunagawa, Tomimase; Uzicanin, Amra; Wachtel, Claude; Weisfuse, Isaac; Hongjie Yu; Nicoll, Angus // BMC Infectious Diseases;2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Background School closure is a non-pharmaceutical intervention that was considered in many national pandemic plans developed prior to the start of the influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 pandemic, and received considerable attention during the event. Here, we retrospectively review and compare national and...

  • Human infection with new influenza A (H1N1) virus: Mexico, update, March--May 2009.  // Weekly Epidemiological Record;6/5/2009, Vol. 84 Issue 23, p213 

    The article reports on the updates for human infection with new influenza A (H1N1) virus for March-May 2009 in Mexico. It states that there has been an outbreak of acte respiratory infections and there have been notification of a rapidly progressive severe pneumonia in the metropolitan of Mexico...

  • Respiratory Tract Infections Caused by New Influenza A (H1N1). Gad, Niveen M.; Abu-Zahab, Zakia; Zakzouk, Zeinab // Australian Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences;2010, Vol. 4 Issue 6, p1055 

    Novel influenza A (H1N1) virus is the pathogen of recent global outbreaks of febrile respiratory infection. Objective: was to describe baseline characteristics, treatment, and outcomes of the majority of patients with confirmed 2009 influenza A (H1N1). Subjects and methods: nasopharyngeal swab...

  • European flu toll reaches 107 confirmed cases. Watson, Rory // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;5/9/2009, Vol. 338 Issue 7703, p1097 

    The article reports on a May 2009 announcement from the Stockholm, Sweden based European Center for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC). In the announcement the center indicated that by the morning of May 5th, 107 confirmed and 10 probable cases of the H1N1 swine influenza virus had been...

  • Canadian national surveys on pandemic influenza preparations: pre-pandemic and peri-pandemic findings. Ritvo, Paul; Perez, Daniel F.; Wilson, Kumanan; Gibson, Jennifer L.; Guglietti, Crissa L.; Shawn Tracy, C.; Bensimon, Cecile M.; Upshur, Ross E. G. // BMC Public Health;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Prior to the 2009 H1N1 Influenza pandemic, public health authorities in Canada and elsewhere prepared for the future outbreak, partly guided by an ethical framework developed within the Canadian Program of Research on Ethics in a Pandemic (CanPREP). We developed a telephone-based...

  • National flu line. Aitkenhead, Susan // Primary Health Care;Jun2009, Vol. 19 Issue 5, p34 

    The article presents an overview of a an information call center which has been established by the British government in 2009 in response to a global outbreak of the H1N1 swine influenza virus. The center was established in an effort to support more than 7,000 call center agents and up to 1.5...

  • Mutations in H5N1 Influenza Virus Hemagglutinin that Confer Binding to Human Tracheal Airway Epithelium.  // PLoS ONE;2009, Vol. 4 Issue 11, p1 

    The article informs that the emergence of a swine-origin H1N1 influenza virus in 2009 as the first pandemic of the 21st Century appeared as an international public health concern. It has been stated that widespread distribution of H5N1 influenza virus in the avian population raised fear of...

  • Respiratory Infection in Institutions during Early Stages of Pandemic (H1N1) 2009, Canada. Marchand-Austin, Alex; Farrell, David J.; Jamieson, Frances B.; Lombardi, Nino; Lombos, Ernesto; Narang, Sunita; Akwar, Holy; Low, Donald E.; Gubbay, Jonathan B. // Emerging Infectious Diseases;Dec2009, Vol. 15 Issue 12, p2001 

    Outbreaks of respiratory infection in institutions in Ontario, Canada were studied from April 20 to June 12, 2009, during the early stages of the emergance of influenza A pandemic (H1N1) 2009. Despite widespread presence of influenza in the general population, only 2 of 83 outbreaks evaluated by...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics