Incommensurability, incomparability, and God's choice of a world

Kraay, Klaas
April 2011
International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Apr2011, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p91
Academic Journal
Anselmian theism holds that there necessarily exists a being, God, who is essentially unsurpassable in power, knowledge, goodness, and wisdom. This being is also understood to be the creator and sustainer of all that is. In contemporary analytic philosophy of religion, this role is generally understood as follows: God surveys the array of possible worlds, and in his wisdom selects exactly one for actualization, based on its axiological properties. In this paper, I discuss an under-appreciated challenge for this account of the Anselmian God's selection of a world. In particular, I urge that there are failures of comparability between various possible worlds, and I argue that, given certain assumptions, these failures threaten the rationality of God's choice of a world. To the extent that rationality is deemed necessary for unsurpassability, this result also challenges the core Anselmian notion that God is an unsurpassable being.


Related Articles

  • Perfection, near-perfection, maximality, and Anselmian Theism. Oppy, Graham // International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Apr2011, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p119 

    nselmian theists claim (a) that there is a being than which none greater can be conceived; and (b) that it is knowable on purely-solely, entirely- a priori grounds that there is a being than which none greater can be conceived. In this paper, I argue that Anselmian Theism gains traction by...

  • The non-Christian influence on Anselm's Proslogion argument. Kendrick, Nancy // International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Apr2011, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p73 

    This paper considers Anselm's Proslogion argument against a background of historical events that include philosophical disputes between Christian and Jewish polemicists. I argue that the Proslogion argument was addressed, in part, to non-Christian theists and that it offered a response to Jewish...

  • Is theism capable of accounting for any natural evil at all? Trakakis, Nick // International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Feb2005, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p35 

    Received wisdom has it that a plausible explanation or theodicy for God’s permission of at least some instances of natural evil is not beyond the reach of the theist. In this paper I challenge this assumption, arguing instead that theism fails to account for any instance, kind, quantity,...

  • Must All be Saved? A Kierkegaardian Response to Theological Universalism. Mulder, Jack // International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Feb2006, Vol. 59 Issue 1, p1 

    In this paper, I consider how a Kierkegaardian could respond critically to the question of strong theological universalism, i.e., the belief that all individuals must eventually be reconciled to God and experience everlasting happiness. A Kierkegaardian would likely reject what Thomas Talbott...

  • Disability and the Love of Wisdom: De-forming, Re-forming, and Per-forming Philosophy of Religion. Yong, Amos // Evangelical Review of Theology;Apr2011, Vol. 35 Issue 2, p160 

    The article examines the philosophy of religion as it tackles the nature of disability, both physical and intellectual. Four theistic views on disability is presented which are ontological responses, freewill theodicy, soul-making theodicy and Christological response. Issues discussed include...

  • Philosophical and Theological Approaches to the Problems of Religious Plurality: A Sino-Theological Perspective. Lai Pan-chiu // Sino-Christian Studies;Jun2009, Vol. 7, p165 

    Philosophy of Religion and Christian Theology of Religions are two different but related approaches to the issues concerning religious plurality. In the Chinese-speaking world, due to some historical factors, the theological approach has been relatively less developed. Clarifying the differences...

  • THE THEOLOGIAN'S TOOL KIT: JOHANNES MACCOVIUS (1588-1644) AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF REFORMED THEOLOGICAL DISTINCTIONS. Van Asselt, Willem J. // Westminster Theological Journal;Spring2006, Vol. 68 Issue 1, p23 

    The article examines the importance and influence of Polish aristocrat and theologian Jan Makowsky, who latinized his name as Johannes Maccovius. His positive use of philosophy within his theological system is analyzed. The influence Saint Augustine has had on his theological system is...

  • Polycentric Polytheism and the Philosophy of Religion. Butler, Edward P. // Pomegranate;Dec2008, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p207 

    The comparison drawn by the Neoplatonist Olympiodorus between the Stoic doctrine of the reciprocal implication of the virtues and the Neoplatonic doctrine of the presence of all the gods in each helps to elucidate the latter. In particular, the idea of primary and secondary "perspectives" in...

  • The application-conditions for design inferences: Why the design arguments need the help of other arguments for God’s existence. Himma, Kenneth // International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Feb2005, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p1 

    Attempts to infer the existence of God from various properties or features of design arguments and design inferences. Effort of inferring the existence of a divine designer from the improbable fact that living beings frequently instantiate what proponents call irreducible specified complexity;...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics