A framework for resolving disagreement during end of life care in the critical care unit

Karen Choong; Cupido, Cynthia; Nelson, Erin; Arnold, Donald M.; Burns, Karen; Cook, Deborah; Meade^3,5, Maureen
August 2010
Clinical & Investigative Medicine;Aug2010, Vol. 33 Issue 4, pE240
Academic Journal
Background: End-of-life decisions regarding the administration, withdrawal or withholding of life-sustaining therapy in the critical care setting can be challenging. Disagreements between health care providers and family members occur, especially when families believe strongly in preserving life, and physicians are resistant to providing medically "futile" care. Such disagreements can cause tension and moral distress among families and clinicians. Purpose: To outline the roles and responsibilities of physicians, substitute decision makers, and the judicial system when decisions must be made on behalf of incapable persons, and to provide a framework for conflict resolution during end-of-life decision-making for physicians practicing in Canada. Source: We used a case-based example to illustrate our objectives. We employed a comprehensive approach to understanding end-of-life decision making that included: 1) a search for relevant literature; 2) a review of provincial college policies; 3) a review of provincial legislation on consent; 4) a consultation with two bioethicists and 5) a consultation with two legal experts in health law. Principal Findings: In Canada, laws about substitute decision-making for health care are primarily provincial or territorial. Thus, laws and policies from professional regulatory bodies on end-of-life care vary across the country. We tabulated the provincial college policies on end-of-life care and the provincial legislation on consent and advance directives, and constructed a 10-step approach to conflict resolution. Conclusion: Knowledge of underlying ethical principles, understanding of professional duties, and adoption of a process for mediation and conflict resolution are essential to ensuring that physicians and institutions act responsibly in maintaining a patients' best interests in the context of family-centred care.


Related Articles

  • Care of an Unresponsive Patient with a Poor Prognosis. Dubler, Nancy N. // New England Journal of Medicine;1/29/2009, Vol. 360 Issue 5, p527 

    In this article the author discusses her suggestions for the best treatment for a 56 year old man with subarachnoid hemorrhage and acute hydrocephalus who is unresponsive and has been given a poor prognosis. A discussion of the moral, legal and medical ethics issues that are raised in this case...

  • Multi-Professional Recommendations for Access and Utilization of Critical Care Services: Towards Consistency in Practice and Ethical Decision-Making Processes. Hawryluck, Laura; Bouali, Redouane; Meth, Nathalie Danjoux // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Summer2011, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p254 

    Multiprofessional guidelines for fair access to and use of adult critical care services are desperately needed to define a consistent transparent standard of care: when such therapies have the potential to benefit and help a patient as they journey with illness and when they cannot.

  • The luck of the draw: physician-related variability in end-of-life decision-making in intensive care. Wilkinson, Dominic; Truog, Robert // Intensive Care Medicine;Jun2013, Vol. 39 Issue 6, p1128 

    Purpose: To critically analyze physician-related variability in end-of-life decision-making in intensive care. Methods: An ethical analysis of factors contributing to physician-related variability in end-of-life decision-making. Results: There is variability in decision-making about life...

  • I Don't Want to Be the One Saying 'We Should Just Let Him Die': Intrapersonal Tensions Experienced by Surrogate Decision Makers in the ICU. Schenker, Yael; Crowley-Matoka, Megan; Dohan, Daniel; Tiver, Greer; Arnold, Robert; White, Douglas // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Dec2012, Vol. 27 Issue 12, p1657 

    BACKGROUND: Although numerous studies have addressed external factors associated with difficulty in surrogate decision making, intrapersonal sources of tension are an important element of decision making that have received little attention. OBJECTIVE: To characterize key intrapersonal tensions...

  • Supporting medical ward rounds through mobile task and process management. Pryss, RĂ¼diger; Mundbrod, Nicolas; Langer, David; Reichert, Manfred // Information Systems & e-Business Management;Feb2015, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p107 

    In a hospital, ward rounds are crucial for task coordination and decision-making. In the course of knowledge-intensive patient treatment processes, it should be possible to quickly define tasks and to assign them to clinicians in a flexible manner. In current practice, however, task management...

  • Improving Palliative Care For Patients In The Intensive Care Unit. Curtis, J. Randall; Rubenfeld, Gordon D. // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Aug2005, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p840 

    Presents a study which focused on the improvement of palliative care for patients in the intensive care unit (ICU). Challenge of identifying the patients who should be targeted for routine palliative care interventions; Complications in the relations between physicians, nurses and other...

  • Opinion Piece: Honouring the wishes of a dying patient: From intensive care to home with palliative care. Campbell, Lynette // Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profess;Oct2013, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p269 

    Due to the severity of illness, death is not uncommon in intensive care units (ICU). Unfortunately, a major percentage of deaths in ICU are patients diagnosed with a terminal disease. Initiating discussions on the transition from curative care to palliative care can be stressful for doctors,...

  • The Healing Power of Listening in the ICU. Lilly, Craig M.; Daly, Barbara J. // New England Journal of Medicine;2/1/2007, Vol. 356 Issue 5, p513 

    The authors mention that recommendations to improve care for patients dying in intensive care units (ICUs) are rooted in both observational and interventional studies. They propose that the time clinicians working in adult ICUs spend supporting family members in shared decision making should...

  • Caregiver perceptions on intensive care: A qualitative study from southern India. KUMAR, SHUBA; CHRISTINA, JONY; JAGADISH, ANNA REVATHI; PETER, JOHN VICTOR; THOMAS, KURIEN; SUDARSANAM, THAMBU DAVID // National Medical Journal of India;May/Jun2017, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p131 

    Background. Admission of a patient to an intensive care unit (ICU) can result in tremendous stress to family caregivers not only because of the need to provide physical and emotional support to the sick relative, but also due to the burden of decision-making on behalf of the critically ill...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics