TITLE

SHOULD THE U.S. WITHDRAW FROM ASIA?

AUTHOR(S)
Harries, Owen
PUB. DATE
October 1968
SOURCE
Foreign Affairs;Oct68, Vol. 47 Issue 1, p15
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
This article examines the views of those who advocate ending the American military commitment on the Southeast Asian mainland as of October 1968. It is possible to discern, at least for purposes of analysis, three distinct viewpoints. There are those, like Lippmann, who accept that withdrawal will mean the domination of the mainland by China, or possibly by China and North Vietnam. How this conclusion will affect one's attitude to withdrawal is likely to depend on how persuasive one finds the arguments that the fate of the region is of no great importance in terms of international politics, and that in any case Chinese influence must prevail in the long run as a kind of geopolitical necessity. The first of these has already been examined. As to the second, it is open to the same decisive objection as the rigid, deterministic version of the domino theory: it asserts the inevitability of one particular outcome in a situation where there are too many variables to justify doing so. The more optimistic, who maintain that the independent states of Southeast Asia could survive an American withdrawal, may be divided into those who lay stress on maintaining an international balance of power and those who stress other factors. There are two versions of the balance-of-power thesis. In the first it is maintained that the offshore presence of the U.S. either in the form of the Seventh Fleet or of an island base or of some combination of the two could maintain a balance. In the second it is maintained that a purely Asian balance of power is possible.
ACCESSION #
5803142

 

Related Articles

  • What Blocks World Peace ?  // New Republic;10/21/46, Vol. 115 Issue 16, p501 

    The article comments on the perceived ineffectiveness of the 1946 Paris, France, peace conference. It is suggested that world peace can only work if the four world powers act together in concert. The article also asserts that the four world powers have to listen to, and incorporate, other...

  • Room for Law: Realism, Evolutionary Biology, and the Promise(s) of International Law. Setear, John K. // Berkeley Journal of International Law;2005, Vol. 23 Issue 1, p1 

    Discusses various paradigms in international relations theory. Discussion of the theoretical perspective of realism in international politics; Possibility of widespread international cooperation during peacetime; Views of realists on the factors which affect balance of power between independent...

  • LOOKING BACK...  // MEED: Middle East Economic Digest;10/3/2003, Vol. 47 Issue 40, p2 

    Deals with issues concerning the Middle East between 1963 and 1998. Historical significance of the informal talks between Kuwait and Baghdad on October 4, 1963; Aim of a peace agreement among Afghanistan, the U.S. and Russia.

  • Is Russia Winning the Cold Peace? Kyriakidis, Kleanthis // Kennedy School Review;2011, Vol. 11, p152 

    The article examines the capability of Russia in winning the peace with the Western countries, a peace in which Russia scores far more victories than its relative power on the world stage would suggest. It discusses the things gained and not gained by the West in its bargains with Russia. It...

  • OZ. Pfaff, William // New Yorker;9/15/86, Vol. 62 Issue 30, p102 

    Reflects on the foreign policy of the United States in 1986. American commitment to Europe as the Cold War developed; Policy towards Libya; Invasion of Grenada; Contrast between the enthusiasm shown for Grenada and Libya; Arms race with the Soviet Union.

  • Toward World Order. Hoffmann, Stanley // New Republic;3/19/77, Vol. 176 Issue 12, p10 

    Presents information on world politics and the tricks in maintaining cordial international relations. Need for maintaining balance of power and formation of alliances for establishing peace; Comments on the foreign policy of the U.S.; Note on the diplomatic relations between the U.S. and the...

  • THE FOREIGN POLICY OF THE DUCE. Grandi, Dino // Foreign Affairs;Jul1934, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p553 

    This article presents information on international relations. It is informed that Benito Mussolini, Prime Minister of Italy, after coming into power in 1922 faced two exigencies of foreign policy: the need to rouse the European Powers to a sense of Italian realities, to a recognition of the new...

  • THE NEXT-TO-LAST ACT IN AFRICA. Huxley, Elspeth // Foreign Affairs;Jul61, Vol. 39 Issue 4, p655 

    This article discusses world politics. A useful starting-point is the conspicuous difference between the progress towards independence made in Tanganyika on the one hand and in Kenya on the other. These two East African neighbors have much in common. Although Tanganyika was a German colony from...

  • INDIA'S FOREIGN POLICY. Pandit, Vijaya Lakshmi // Foreign Affairs;Apr1956, Vol. 34 Issue 3, p432 

    The article focuses on India's foreign policy as of 1956. After eight years of independence India's foreign policy still gives rise to grave doubts in the Western mind. The reason for this is the acceptance of old definitions rather than an appreciation of the country's background and its human...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sign out of this library

Other Topics