Reliability of Routinely Collected Hospital Data for Child Maltreatment Surveillance

McKenzie, Kirsten; Scott, Debbie A.; Waller, Garry S.; Campbell, Margaret
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Internationally, research on child maltreatment-related injuries has been hampered by a lack of available routinely collected health data to identify cases, examine causes, identify risk factors and explore health outcomes. Routinely collected hospital separation data coded using the International Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD) system provide an internationally standardised data source for classifying and aggregating diseases, injuries, causes of injuries and related health conditions for statistical purposes. However, there has been limited research to examine the reliability of these data for child maltreatment surveillance purposes. This study examined the reliability of coding of child maltreatment in Queensland, Australia. Methods: A retrospective medical record review and recoding methodology was used to assess the reliability of coding of child maltreatment. A stratified sample of hospitals across Queensland was selected for this study, and a stratified random sample of cases was selected from within those hospitals. Results: In 3.6% of cases the coders disagreed on whether any maltreatment code could be assigned (definite or possible) versus no maltreatment being assigned (unintentional injury), giving a sensitivity of 0.982 and specificity of 0.948. The review of these cases where discrepancies existed revealed that all cases had some indications of risk documented in the records. 15.5% of cases originally assigned a definite or possible maltreatment code, were recoded to a more or less definite strata. In terms of the number and type of maltreatment codes assigned, the auditor assigned a greater number of maltreatment types based on the medical documentation than the original coder assigned (22% of the auditor coded cases had more than one maltreatment type assigned compared to only 6% of the original coded data). The maltreatment types which were the most 'under-coded' by the original coder were psychological abuse and neglect. Cases coded with a sexual abuse code showed the highest level of reliability. Conclusion: Given the increasing international attention being given to improving the uniformity of reporting of child-maltreatment related injuries and the emphasis on the better utilisation of routinely collected health data, this study provides an estimate of the reliability of maltreatment-specific ICD-10-AM codes assigned in an inpatient setting.


Related Articles

  • Using Routinely Collected Hospital Data for Child Maltreatment Surveillance: Issues, Methods and Patterns. McKenzie, Kirsten; Scott, Debbie A. // BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: International data on child maltreatment are largely derived from child protection agencies, and predominantly report only substantiated cases of child maltreatment. This approach underestimates the incidence of maltreatment and makes inter-jurisdictional comparisons difficult. There...

  • Evaluating Child Sexual Abuse: Observations Regarding Ano-genital Injury. Claytor, Risa N.; Barth, Kristen L.; Shubin, Charles I. // Clinical Pediatrics;Sep1989, Vol. 28 Issue 9, p419 

    The records of 944 children who had been examined by one pediatrician for alleged sexual abuse were analyzed. Sixty-four percent of the females and 34 percent of the males had positive findings suggestive of ano-genital injury. The data indicated that in girls with no evidence of injury, the...

  • SEXUAL MOLESTATIONS IN HOSPITALS. Cohen, Robert // Clinical Pediatrics;Dec1964, Vol. 3 Issue 12, p689 

    Comments on personal experiences with two children who were molested while patients in community hospitals in the United States. Lessons of physicians from handling the cases; Molestation of a girl following the tonsillectomy while still hospitalized; Precautions for the prevention of recurrence.

  • Guide to diagnosing sexual abuse of children is published by royal college. Dyer, Clare // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);4/5/2008, Vol. 336 Issue 7647, p738 

    The article reports on a comprehensive guide on the physical signs of the sexual abuse of children which was published in April of 2008 by Great Britain's Royal College of Pediatrics and Child Health. The guide, which was the result of five years' work, was created to help British child...

  • Child sexual abuse: Raising awareness and empathy is essential to promote new public health responses. Mathews, Ben; Collin-Vézina, Delphine; Collin-Vézina, Delphine // Journal of Public Health Policy;Aug2016, Vol. 37 Issue 3, p304 

    Child sexual abuse is a major global public health concern, affecting one in eight children and causing massive costs including depression, unwanted pregnancy, and HIV. The gravity of this global issue is reflected by the United Nations' new effort to respond to sexual abuse in the 2015...

  • The Slaughter of Innocents: Child Sacrifice Ancient and Modern. ROUSSELLE, ROBERT // Journal of Psychohistory;Winter2009, Vol. 36 Issue 3, p224 

    The article focuses on child sacrifice which refers to any prescribed regimen or treatment of children that restrains their ability to grow and develop into adults with a full life expectancy or which is inimical to their health or survival. It says that the most important distinguishing...

  • Abuso Sexual InfantoJuvenil: ações municipais da Saúde para a garantia do atendimento. da Paixão, Ana Cristina Wanderley; Deslandes, Suely Ferreira // Revista Ciência & Saúde Coletiva;2011, Vol. 16 Issue 10, p4189 

    The article analyzes the activities of the Municipal Department of Health and Civil Defense of Rio de Janeiro in ensuring specialized care for the population of children and adolescents who are the victims of sexual violence. This is a case study that used the method of analysis of content of...

  • A Simulated "Acquired" Imperforate Hymen Following the Genital Trauma of Sexual Abuse. Berkowitz, Carol D.; Elvik, Sandra L.; Logan, Mary // Clinical Pediatrics;Jun1987, Vol. 26 Issue 6, p307 

    Imperforate hymen. a condition in which the hymen has no aperture, usually occurs congenitally, secondary to failure of development of a lumen. A case of a documented simulated "acquired" imperforate hymen is presented in this article The patient, a 5-year-old girl, was the victim of sexual...

  • Birinci basamakta çocuk istismarı ve ihmaline yaklaşım. Yarar, Fulya; Yarış, Füsun // Turkish Journal of Family Practice / Türkiye Aile Hekimligi Der;eki-ara2011, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p178 

    Child abuse is the physical and/or emotional maltreatment including sexual abuse, neglect and using the child for commercial benefits which may cause harm to the general conditions related with responsibility, security, health, life, development or self esteem. It may be seen in both gender in...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics