Costs and effects of a 'healthy living' approach to community development in two deprived communities: findings from a mixed methods study

Snooks, Helen A.; Evans, Bridie Angela; Cohen, David; Nugent, Michael; Rapport, Frances; Skone, Jon; Meredith, Angie; Davies, Tricia; O'Sullivan, Diana
January 2011
BMC Public Health;2011, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Inequalities in health have proved resistant to 'top down' approaches. It is increasingly recognised that health promotion initiatives are unlikely to succeed without strong local involvement at all stages of the process and many programmes now use grass roots approaches. A healthy living approach to community development (HLA) was developed as an innovative response to local concerns about a lack of appropriate services in two deprived communities in Pembrokeshire, West Wales. We sought to assess feasibility, costs, benefits and working relationships of this HLA. Methods: The HLA intervention operated through existing community forums and focused on the whole community and its relationship with statutory and voluntary sectors. Local people were trained as community researchers and gathered views about local needs though resident interviews. Forums used interview results to write action plans, disseminated to commissioning organisations. The process was supported throughout through the project. The evaluation used a multi-method before and after study design including process and outcome formative and summative evaluation; data gathered through documentary evidence, diaries and reflective accounts, semi-structured interviews, focus groups and costing proformas. Main outcome measures were processes and timelines of implementation of HLA; self reported impact on communities and participants; community-agency processes of liaison; costs. Results: Communities were able to produce and disseminate action plans based on locally-identified needs. The process was slower than anticipated: few community changes had occurred but expectations were high. Community participants gained skills and confidence. Cross-sector partnership working developed. The process had credibility within service provider organisations but mechanisms for refocusing commissioning were patchy. Intervention costs averaged £58,304 per community per annum. Conclusions: The intervention was feasible and inexpensive, with indications of potential impact at individual, community and policy planning levels. However, it is a long term process which requires sustained investment and must be embedded in planning and service delivery processes.


Related Articles

  • St. Joseph's development moving into phase two. Robinson, Ruthann // Crain's Cleveland Business;12/2/2002, Vol. 23 Issue 48, p17 

    Reports on the community development plans of Saint Joseph Community Center to provide health care clinics, nonprofit organizations and college classrooms around its compound in Lorain County, Ohio. Federal grants received by the facility; Total area occupied by the health facility.

  • Care, Community, Capacity: Rethinking Mental Health Services in Remote Indigenous Settings. Santhanain, Radhika; Hunter, Ernest; Wilkinson, Yvonne; Whiteford, Harvey; McEwan, Alexandra // Australian Journal of Primary Health;Aug2006, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p51 

    In 2002 a project was initiated to evaluate and restructure the Child and Youth Mental Health (CYMH) services in three Health Service Districts: Cape York, the Tomes Strait and Northern Peninsula Area and remote Cairns. The objective was to develop, establish and evaluate models of best practice...

  • India: Meet The Trio That Guides Women To Better Health. Achanta, Pushpa // Women's Feature Service;6/30/2014, p1 

    The article features the three Indian women who guide the expectant and lactating mothers for a better health in India which include Suzanna, Ashalatha and Yogita. It states that the three Indian women are community resource persons (CRPs) that works on the different welfare schemes of the...

  • HEALTH CARE: Connecticut Health Seeks to Address Disparities.  // Community Health Funding Week;5/15/2009, p26 

    The article reports that the Connecticut Health Foundation is seeking prospective grantees with demonstrated success in community development, content development, strategic and technical savvy to engage online social networks. The project will selected that grantee with past experience of...

  • (GRANTS) Amgen Foundation Focuses on Healthcare Quality, Patient Access.  // Aging News Alert;1/8/2010, p6 

    The article presents information about the funding program of Amgen Foundation. It mentions that the foundation grants 20 million dollar annually for improvement in healthcare facilities and development of communities. In the field of medical care it provides, funds to patients, caregivers and...

  • Rural community and health care interdependence: an historical, geographical study. Grafton, Denise; Troughton, Michael; Rourke, James // Canadian Journal of Rural Medicine;Summer2004, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p156 

    The relationships between rural health care and community development were examined over time, for the case-study area of Huron and Perth counties in Southwestern Ontario. The underlying premises were that an historical-geographic study could provide both a perspective on the development of...

  • The community development potential of large health services organizations. Beaufort B. Longest // Community Development Journal;Jan2006, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p89 

    Large health services organizations routinely support communities through provision of services. However, as these organizations have also become important economic entities, they are increasingly viewed as having significant potential to make additional contributions to community development in...

  • Celebrating women's health nurses. Wilmore, Helen // Australian Nursing Journal;Sep2007, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p35 

    The article focuses on the creation of the women's health nurse (WHN) role to complement existing health services. Women's health nurses provide well women's clinics, community education, staff training and education, and participate in community development. The women's health nurse title is...

  • Influence network linkages across implementation strategy conditions in a randomized controlled trial of two strategies for scaling up evidence-based practices in public youth-serving systems. Palinkas, Lawrence A.; Holloway, Ian W.; Rice, Eric; Hendricks Brown, C.; Valente, Thomas W.; Chamberlain, Patricia; Brown, C Hendricks // Implementation Science;2013, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Given the importance of influence networks in the implementation of evidence-based practices and interventions, it is unclear whether such networks continue to operate as sources of information and advice when they are segmented and disrupted by randomization to...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics