Trial protocol and preliminary results for a cluster randomised trial of behavioural support versus brief advice for smoking cessation in adolescents

Markham, Wolfgang A.; Bridle, Christopher; Grimshaw, Gillian; Stanton, Alan; Aveyard, Paul
January 2010
BMC Research Notes;2010, Vol. 3, p336
Academic Journal
Background: Many young people report they want to stop smoking and have tried to do so, but most of their quit attempts fail. For adult smokers, there is strong evidence that group behavioural support enhances quit rates. However, it is uncertain whether group behavioural support enhances abstinence in young smokers trying to quit. Findings: A cluster randomised trial for young people trying to stop smoking to compare the efficacy of a school-based 9 week intensive group behavioural support course versus a school-based 7 week brief advice only course. Participants were assessed for evidence of tobacco addiction and nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) was used if it was deemed appropriate by the therapist. Both types of course aimed to recruit approximately one hundred participants from approximately ten schools. The primary outcome was successful quitting at 4 weeks after quit day judged according to the Russell standard. Had the trial been completed, abstinence at 6 months after quit day and the relationships between successful quit attempts and 1) psychological assessments of dependence prior to quitting 2) salivary cotinine concentration prior to quitting and 3) sociodemographic characteristics would also have been assessed. The proportion of participants who stopped smoking in each arm of the trial were compared using Chi square tests. The trial was stopped shortly after it had started because funding to support the therapists running the stop smoking group behavioural support programme was withdrawn. Only three stop smoking courses were completed (two group support courses and one brief advice pharmacotherapy course). Seventeen participants in total entered the trial. At the end of the courses, one participant (10%) attending the group support programme had stopped smoking and no participant attending the brief advice programme had stopped smoking. Discussion: The trial was stopped so we were unable to determine whether group support helped more young people to stop smoking than brief advice. Engagement and recruitment of participants proved much more difficult than had been anticipated. Fifteen of the seventeen participants reported that quitting smoking was either pretty important or very important to them. Thus, the stop smoking success rate could, nevertheless, be considered disappointing. Trial registration: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN25181936


Related Articles

  • The Quitting Rollercoaster: How Recent Quitting History Affects Future Cessation Outcomes (Data From the International Tobacco Control 4-Country Cohort Study). Partos, Timea R.; Borland, Ron; Yong, Hua-Hie; Hyland, Andrew; Cummings, K. Michael // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1578 

    Introduction: Most smokers have a history of unsuccessful quit attempts. This study used data from 7 waves (2002–2009) of the International Tobacco Control 4-country cohort study to examine the role of smokers’ quitting history (e.g., recency, length, and number of previous quit...

  • Time-Varying Processes Involved in Smoking Lapse in a Randomized Trial of Smoking Cessation Therapies. Vasilenko, Sara A.; Piper, Megan E.; Lanza, Stephanie T.; Liu, Xiaoyu; Yang, Jingyun; Li, Runze // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;May2014, Vol. 16 Issue Suppl_2, pS135 

    Introduction: Researchers have increasingly begun to gather ecological momentary assessment (EMA) data on smoking, but new statistical methods are necessary to fully unlock information from such data. In this paper, we use a new technique, the logistic time-varying effect model (logistic TVEM),...

  • Characterization of Long-Term Users of Nicotine Replacement Therapy: Evidence From a National Survey. Silla, Kabay; Beard, Emma; Shahab, Lion // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Aug2014, Vol. 16 Issue 8, p1050 

    Introduction: Harm reduction involving partial or complete substitution of cigarettes with nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) is likely to benefit smokers by reducing exposure to carcinogens and by increasing the likelihood of permanent cessation. This article aimed to assess the determinants of...

  • Nicotine Replacement Therapy Distribution to Light Daily Smokers Calling a Quitline. Krupski, Laurie; Cummings, K. Michael; Hyland, Andrew; Carlin-Menter, Shannon; Toll, Benjamin A.; Mahoney, Martin C. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1572 

    Background: With an increasing prevalence of lighter smokers presenting for cessation assistance, outcome-based recommendations are needed to inform nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) distribution protocols by quitlines. Methods: A quasi-experimental design was utilized to compare quit rates...

  • Smoking Cessation and Desire to Stop Smoking in Nine Countries of the Former Soviet Union. Footman, Katharine; Roberts, Bayard; Stickley, Andrew; Kizilova, Kseniya; Rotman, David; McKee, Martin // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1628 

    Introduction: Smoking rates and corresponding levels of premature mortality from smoking-related diseases in the former Soviet Union (fSU) are among the highest in the world. To reduce this health burden, greater focus on smoking cessation is needed, but little is currently known about rates and...

  • Comparison of the Cost-Effectiveness of a High- and a Low-Intensity Smoking Cessation Intervention in Sweden: A Randomized Trial. Nohlert, Eva; Helgason, Ásgeir R.; Tillgren, Per; Tegelberg, Åke; Johansson, Pia // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Sep2013, Vol. 15 Issue 9, p1519 

    Objective: To assess the relative cost-effectiveness of a high-intensity treatment (HIT) and a low-intensity treatment (LIT) for smoking cessation. Methods: The societal and health care perspective economic evaluation was based on the reported number of quitters at 12-month follow-up (point...

  • Stage-Based Interventions for Smoking Cessation. FOGLEMAN, COREY D. // American Family Physician;3/1/2011, Vol. 83 Issue 5, p524 

    The article discusses research being done on staged-based smoking cessation interventions. It references the study "Staged-Based Interventions for Smoking Cessation," by J. Cahill, T. Lancaster and N. Green in the 2010 issue of "Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews." Evidence has failed to...

  • Can it be Ethical to Apply Limited Resources in Low-income Countries to Ineffective, Low-reach Smoking Cessation Strategies? A Reply to Bitton and Eyal. Chapman, Simon; Mackenzie, Ross // Public Health Ethics;Apr2012, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p29 

    Bitton and Eyal's lengthy critique of our article on unassisted cessation was premised on several straw-man arguments. These are corrected in our reply. It also confused the key concepts of efficacy and effectiveness in assessing the impact of cessation interventions and policies in real-world...

  • Epidemiology of menthol cigarette use in the United States. Caraballo, Ralph S.; Asman, Katherine // Tobacco Induced Diseases;2011 Supplement 1, Vol. 9 Issue Suppl 1, p1 

    Background: Approximately one-fourth of all cigarettes sold in the United States have the descriptor “menthol” on the cigarette pack. It is important to determine what socio-demographic factors are associated with smoking menthol cigarettes if indeed these types of cigarettes are...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics