Public, private and personal: Qualitative research on policymakers' opinions on smokefree interventions to protect children in private spaces

Rouch, Gareth; Thomson, George; Wilson, Nick; Hudson, Sheena; Edwards, Richard; Gifford, Heather; Lanumata, Tolotea
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p797
Academic Journal
Background: Governments use law to constrain aspects of private activities for purposes of protecting health and social wellbeing. Policymakers have a range of perceptions and beliefs about what is public or private. An understanding of the possible drivers of policymaker decisions about where government can or should intervene for health is important, as one way to better guide appropriate policy formation. Our aim was to identify obstacles to, and opportunities for, government smokefree regulation of private and public spaces to protect children. In particular, to seek policymaker opinions on the regulation of smoking in homes, cars and public parks and playgrounds in a country with incomplete smokefree laws (New Zealand). Methods: Case study, using structured interviews to ask policymakers (62 politicians and senior officials) about their opinions on new smokefree legislation for public and private places. Supplementary data was obtained from the Factiva media database, on the views of New Zealand local authority councillors about policies for smokefree outdoor public places. Results: Overall, interviewees thought that government regulation of smoking in private places was impractical and unwise. However, there were some differences on what was defined as 'private', particularly for cars. Even in public parks, smoking was seen by some as a 'personal' decision, and unlikely to be amenable to regulation. Most participants believed that educative, supportive and community-based measures were better and more practical means of reducing smoking in private places, compared to regulation. Conclusions: The constrained view of the role of regulation of smoking in public and private domains may be in keeping with current political discourse in New Zealand and similar Anglo-American countries. Policy and advocacy options to promote additional smokefree measures include providing a better voice for childrens' views, increasing information to policymakers about the harms to children from secondhand smoke and the example of adult smoking, and changing the culture for smoking around children.


Related Articles

  • Perceived benefits of smoke-free homes, the process of establishing them, and enforcement challenges in Shanghai, China: a qualitative study. Berg, Carla J.; Pinpin Zheng; Kegler, Michelle C. // BMC Public Health;2015, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: We examined reasons for establishing smoke-free home policies, interpersonal processes by which they are established, and challenges in enforcing them in Shanghai, China. Methods: In 2013, we conducted 30 in-person semi-structured interviews among 13 male smokers and 17 female...

  • Should smoking in outside public spaces be banned? YES. Thomson, George; Wilson, Nick; Edwards, Richard; Woodward, Alistair // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;1/10/2009, p76 

    In this article the authors react to the question of whether smoking should be banned in outdoor public spaces. They suggests that it should because such a ban would prevent children from becoming smokers. They argue that while it is not clear whether outdoor smoke free areas reduce smoking...

  • Modelling the effectiveness of financing policies to address underutilization of children's health services in Nepal. Pokhrel, Subhash; Hidayat, Budi; Flessa, Steffen; Sauerborn, Rainer // Bulletin of the World Health Organization;May2005, Vol. 83 Issue 5, p338 

    Objective To estimate the price responsiveness of utilization of formal children's health-care services in Nepal and to use this information to model the impact on utilization of subsidies or increases in user fees. Methods A total of 8112 individual observations (of children aged ⩽ 15...

  • IN THIS ISSUE.  // Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health;Jan2005, Vol. 59 Issue 1, p1 

    This article presents information on various topics published in the January 1, 2005 issue of the "Journal of Epidemiol Community Health." A paper from Montreal, with a linked Editorial, explores the dimensions of socioeconomic status that influence toddlers' health, and concludes that a serious...

  • HEALTH CARE FOR CHILDREN IN SCHOOL AGE AND THE QUALITY OF MEDICAL CARE. Moysés, M.; Collores, C. // Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health;Aug2004 Supplement 1, Vol. 58, pA105 

    This article aims at studying the attention given to children in school age health to investigate what medical consultation is performed within the health institutions, and what quality of medical care do lower class children get at public institutions. The results point to a necessity of...

  • Comprehensive smoke-free legislation and displacement of smoking into the homes of young children in Hong Kong.  // Tobacco Control;Apr2010, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p129 

    The article studies the effects of a 2007 comprehensive smoke-free legislation on children's exposure to secondhand smoke (SHS) in Hong Kong, China. According to the study, exposure to SHS at home and outside the home increased among primary school students post-legislation. The study also found...

  • Protecting Children From Smoke Exposure in Disadvantaged Homes. Rowa-Dewar, Neneh; Lumsdaine, Colin; Amos, Amanda // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;Apr2015, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p496 

    Introduction: Smokefree legislation and shifting norms in many countries have reduced secondhand smoke (SHS) exposure, but many children, particularly from disadvantaged homes, have high levels of exposure in homes and cars. We explored the particular challenges mothers who smoke face when...

  • Understanding Neighborhood Environment Related to Hong Kong Children’s Physical Activity: A Qualitative Study Using Nominal Group Technique. He, Gang; Cerin, Ester; Huang, Wendy Y.; Wong, Stephen H. // PLoS ONE;Sep2014, Vol. 9 Issue 9, p1 

    Background: Relationships between the neighborhood environment and children’s physical activity have been well documented in Western countries but are less investigated in ultra-dense Asian cities. The aim of this study was to identify the environmental facilitators and barriers of...

  • CITIZENS' NEEDS AND PARTICIPATION IN HEALTH AND MENTAL HEALTH: Understanding the Interconnections Between Ethnicity, Gender, Social Class and Health: Experiences of Minority Ethnic Women in Britain. Barn, Ravinder; Sidhu, Kalwant; Metteri, Anna; Kröger, Teppo; Pohjola, Anneli; Rauhala, Pirkko-Liisa // Social Work Visions from Around the Globe: Citizens, Methods & A;2004, Vol. 39 Issue 1/2, p11 

    This paper presents the findings of a qualitative study about the impact of ethnicity, gender, and socio-economic status upon health, and use and access to appropriate service provision. A total of 54 interviews were carried out with women who identified themselves as Muslim and Bangladeshi....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics