Turning around an ailing district hospital: a realist evaluation of strategic changes at Ho Municipal Hospital (Ghana)

Marchal, Bruno; Dedzo, McDamien; Kegels, Guy
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p787
Academic Journal
Background: There is a growing consensus that linear approaches to improving the performance of health workers and health care organisations may only obtain short-term results. An alternative approach premised on the principle of human resource management described as a form of 'High commitment management', builds upon a bundles of balanced practices. This has been shown to contribute to better organisational performance. This paper illustrates an intervention and outcome of high commitment management (HiCom) at an urban hospital in Ghana. Few studies have shown how HiCom management might contribute to better performance of health services and in particular of hospitals in low and middle-income settings. Methods: A realist case study design was used to analyse how specific management practices might contribute to improving the performance of an urban district hospital in Ho, Volta Region, in Ghana. Mixed methods were used to collect data, including document review, in-depth interviews, group discussions, observations and a review of routine health information. Results: At Ho Municipal Hospital, the management team dealt with the crisis engulfing the ailing urban district hospital by building an alliance between hospital staff to generate a sense of ownership with a focus around participative problem analysis. The creation of an alliance led to improving staff morale and attitude, and contributed also to improvements in the infrastructure and equipment. This in turn had a positive impact on the revenue generating capacity of the hospital. The quick turn around in the state of this hospital showed that change was indeed possible, a factor that greatly motivated the staff. In a second step, the management team initiated the development of a strategic plan for the hospital to maintain the dynamics of change. This was undertaken through participative methods and sustained earlier staff involvement, empowerment and feelings of reciprocity. We found that these factors acted as the core mechanisms underlying the changes taking place at Ho Municipal Hospital. Conclusions: This study shows how a hospital management team in Ghana succeeded in resuscitating an ailing hospital. Their high commitment management approach led to the active involvement and empowerment of staff. It also showed how a realist evaluation approach such as this, could be used in the research of the management of health care organisations to explain how management interventions may or may not work.


Related Articles

  • A RELATIONAL MODEL OF HIGH PERFORMANCE WORK SYSTEMS. GITTELL, JODY HOFFER; SEIDNER, ROB; WIMBUSH, JULIAN // Academy of Management Annual Meeting Proceedings;2008, Vol. 2008 Issue 1, p1 

    The article discusses research on a relational model of high performance work systems concerning patient care in hospitals. Surveys are used in the measurement of coordinated administration, quality of care, efficiency among care providers, and patient outcomes. A model of organizational...

  • AHRQ's New Prevention Quality Indicators Spot Diabetes, Inappropriate Hospitalizations.  // Insurance Advocate;12/1/2001, Vol. 112 Issue 45, p42 

    Focuses on the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Prevention Quality Indicators for detecting inappropriate hospital admissions in the United States. Results of a research conducted by the Department of Health and Human Services on hospital admissions; Conditions in which hospital...

  • RENEWAL OF HEALTH SYSTEM MANAGEMENT IN POLAND -- GROUP PURCHASING ORGANIZATIONS. Bartkowiak, Piotr; Bernat, Tomasz // Transformation in Business & Economics;2014, Vol. 13 Issue 2B, p581 

    The medical market in Poland constitutes 0.6% of the world health market considering value and only 7-8% of GDP is spent on health care. Meanwhile, in Germany it is 10.5% and in the US the sum reaches 16% (OECD, 2010). Such proportions demonstrate the necessity on higher expenditures for Polish...

  • MNA: A lifeline for Massachusetts nurses.  // Massachusetts Nurse;May2005, Vol. 76 Issue 4, p8 

    The article presents information according to which when a nursing student Beth Wilson began research for a masters thesis her primary objective was to discern if in the wake of health care and hospital restructuring, the MNA was a lifeline for Massachusetts nurses. Wilson, who presented her...

  • Governance Around Quality of Care at Hospitals that Disproportionately Care for Black Patients. Jha, Ashish; Epstein, Arnold // JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Mar2012, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p297 

    BACKGROUND: Hospital boards of directors can play a pivotal role in improving care, yet we know little about how the boards of hospitals that disproportionately serve minority patients engage in this issue. OBJECTIVES: To examine how boards of directors at black-serving hospitals are engaged in...

  • Falls and Incontinence: evaluation of a quality management project. Thompson, Janie // Australian & New Zealand Continence Journal;Autumn2007, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p18 

    Falls and incontinence are both significant and costly issues for health care. As research indicates a link between falls and incontinence, this Falls and Continence Audit project was undertaken as a quality management project with the aim of reducing the risk of repeat falls by assessing and...

  • Patient-safety efforts narrowed. DerGurahian, Jean // Modern Healthcare;12/8/2008, Vol. 38 Issue 49, p10 

    The article reports that a study which found little impact on hospital deaths through the use of rapid-response teams has called into question their use in patient-safety initiatives recommended by groups like the Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI). The study found that rapid-response...

  • HRET to study top health systems.  // AHA News;2/2/2009, Vol. 45 Issue 3, p8 

    The article focuses on a study on the best practices of multi-hospital health systems in the U.S., to be conducted by the Health Research & Educational Trust (HRET). The Commonwealth Fund issued a grant to HRET for the study. Such study, which will be conducted through interviews with health...

  • A HAPPY NURSE IS A RETAINED NURSE. Johnson, Rick // HealthLeaders Magazine;Jul2007, Vol. 10 Issue 7, p47 

    The article deals with the strategies adopted by Uvalde Texas (TX) Memorial Hospital for reliving stress among its nursing staff. They include developing a formal committee called the Staff Nurse Leadership Council, which investigates and designs methods of enhancing care at the bedside. The...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics