Magnetohydrodynamic stability comparison theorems revisited

Cerfon, Antoine J.; Freidberg, Jeffrey P.
January 2011
Physics of Plasmas;Jan2011, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p012505
Academic Journal
Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) stability comparison theorems are presented for several different plasma models, each one corresponding to a different level of collisionality: a collisional fluid model (ideal MHD), a collisionless kinetic model (kinetic MHD), and two intermediate collisionality hybrid models (Vlasov-fluid and kinetic MHD-fluid). Of particular interest is the re-examination of the often quoted statement that ideal MHD makes the most conservative predictions with respect to stability boundaries for ideal modes. Some of the models have already been investigated in the literature and we clarify and generalize these results. Other models are essentially new and for them we derive new comparison theorems. Three main conclusions can be drawn: (1) it is crucial to distinguish between ergodic and closed field line systems; (2) in the case of ergodic systems, ideal MHD does indeed make conservative predictions compared to the other models; (3) in closed line systems undergoing perturbations that maintain the closed line symmetry this is no longer true. Specifically, when the ions are collisionless and their gyroradius is finite, as in the Vlasov-fluid model, there is no compressibility stabilization. The Vlasov-fluid model is more unstable than ideal MHD. The reason for this is related to the wave-particle resonance associated with the perpendicular precession drift motion of the particles (i.e., the E×B drift and magnetic drifts), combined with the absence of any truly toroidally trapped particles. The overall conclusion is that to determine macroscopic stability boundaries for ideal modes for any magnetic geometry using a simple conservative approach, one should analyze the ideal MHD energy principle for incompressible displacements.


Related Articles

  • A Maxwell formulation for the equations of a plasma. Thompson, Richard J.; Moeller, Trevor M. // Physics of Plasmas;Jan2012, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p010702 

    In light of the analogy between the structure of electrodynamics and fluid dynamics, the fluid equations of motion may be reformulated as a set of Maxwell equations. This analogy has been explored in the literature for incompressible turbulent flow and compressible flow but has not been widely...

  • Ideal and resistive edge stability calculations with M3D-C1. Ferraro, N. M.; Jardin, S. C.; Snyder, P. B. // Physics of Plasmas;Oct2010, Vol. 17 Issue 10, p102508 

    Growth rates of edge localized modes for various benchmark equilibria, including a diverted equilibrium, are calculated using the nonideal fluid code M3D-C1. Growth rates calculated by M3D-C1 in the ideal limit are found to agree with those calculated by ideal magnetohydrodynamics codes. The...

  • A stability criterion for energetic particle-Alfvén modes. Betti, R.; Freidberg, J. P. // Physics of Fluids B: Plasma Physics;Mar91, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p538 

    A stability criterion is derived for energetic particle-Alfvén modes. The criterion is valid for arbitrary aspect ratio, arbitrary β, noncircular, axisymmetric tori. The plasma is modeled by a magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) core plus a fully kinetic Vlasov species of hot particles. Electron...

  • Magnetohydrodynamic stability in a levitated dipole. Garnier, D.T.; Kesner, J.; Mauel, M.E. // Physics of Plasmas;Sep99, Vol. 6 Issue 9, p3431 

    Examines the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) stability in a levitated dipole. Beta limits imposed by ideal MHD in a dipole configuration; Numerical solution to the finite-beta equilibrium; Use of the equilibrium solution to evaluate interchange and ballooning stability.

  • The role of edge current density on kink mode stability and its implication for magnetohydrodynamic activity associated with edge localized modes. Manickam, Janardhan // Physics of Fluids B: Plasma Physics;Jul92, Vol. 4 Issue 7, p1901 

    The stability of a plasma equilibrium to the external kink mode is shown to be dependent on the details of the current density near the plasma edge and the value of the safety factor, q, at the edge. The buildup of the current density near the plasma edge is shown to decrease the shear in the...

  • Small Larmor radius limit for a warm relativistic electron fluid. Anile, A. M.; Muscato, O. // Physics of Fluids B: Plasma Physics;May89, Vol. 1 Issue 5, p996 

    A fluid model is considered for a relativistic warm plasma, obtained with a closure approach that allows for a nonvanishing heat tensor. A small Larmor radius limit is assumed and a simplified magneto-fluid model that generalizes the relativistic Chew-Goldberg-Low model [Proc. R. Soc. London...

  • Magnetohydrodynamic stability of plasmas with aligned mass flow. Tataronis, J. A.; Mond, M. // Physics of Fluids (00319171);Jan87, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p84 

    The linear magnetohydrodynamic stability of plasmas with sub-Alfvénic flows aligned parallel to the equilibrium magnetic field is treated. Subject to the constraints that the fluid is incompressible, inviscid, and perfectly conducting, it is demonstrated that stabilizing effects appear as the...

  • Stability of high-beta plasmas with helical magnetic axis. Mond, Michael // Physics of Fluids (00319171);Jan86, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p252 

    The stability of high-beta plasmas with helical magnetic axis is studied by investigating the linearized magnetohydrodynamic equations. It is shown that the stability of shearless configurations is determined by an ordinary differential equation that describes modes with large variations across...

  • Effects of line-tying on magnetohydrodynamic instabilities and current sheet formation. Yi-Min Huang; Bhattacharjee, A.; Zweibel, Ellen G. // Physics of Plasmas;May2010, Vol. 17 Issue 5, p055707 

    An overview of some recent progress on magnetohydrodynamic stability and current sheet formation in a line-tied system is given. Key results on the linear stability of the ideal internal kink mode and resistive tearing mode are summarized. For nonlinear problems, a counterexample to the recent...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics