TITLE

The Relation Between Earnings Management Using Real Activities Manipulation and Future Performance: Evidence from Meeting Earnings Benchmarks

AUTHOR(S)

GUNNY, KATHERINE A.

PUB. DATE

September 2010

SOURCE

Contemporary Accounting Research;Fall2010, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p855

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

This paper examines the consequences of real activities manipulation (RM). Using financial statement data, I identify firms that appear to engage in any of the following RM: reducing research and development (R&D) to increase income; reducing selling, general, and administrative (SG&A) expenses to increase income; timing of income recognition from the disposal of long-lived assets and investments; and cutting prices to boost sales in the current period and/or overproducing to decrease cost of goods sold expense. I then examine whether RM is associated with firms just meeting two earnings benchmarks (zero and last year�s earnings). The results indicate that RM of R&D, SG&A, and production are positively associated with firms just meeting these earnings benchmarks. Next, I examine the extent to which RM affects subsequent performance. A negative association between just meeting earnings benchmarks by using RM and subsequent performance supports prior research suggesting managers opportunistically use earnings management to the detriment of shareholders (i.e., managerial opportunism). A positive association is consistent with managers using operational discretion to attain benefits that allow better future performance or to signal future firm value. I find that firm-years reflecting RM to just meet earnings benchmarks have higher subsequent firm performance (compared to firm-years that do not engage in RM and miss or just meet the earnings benchmarks). In this setting, using RM to influence the output of the accounting system is not opportunistic, but consistent with managers attaining benefits that allow better future performance or signaling.

ACCESSION #

57556572

Tags: EARNINGS management;  CORPORATIONS -- Finance;  FINANCIAL statements;  BENCHMARKING (Management);  EARNINGS forecasting;  PRICING

 

Related Articles

• Chapter 2: FINANCIAL RETURNS: ASSET STRUCTURE RATIOS.  // Morocco Economic Competitiveness;2006, p12 

  In this chapter we consider the asset structure of companies operating in Morocco benchmarked against global averages. The chapter begins by defining relevant terms. A common-size statement, or vertical analysis of assets is then presented for companies operating in Morocco and the average...

• CHAPTER 3: FINANCIAL RETURNS: LIABILITY STRUCTURE RATIOS.  // Micronesia Federation Economic Competitiveness;2006, p34 

  In this chapter we consider the liability structure of firms operating in Micronesia Federation benchmarked against global averages. The chapter begins by defining relevant terms. A common-size statement, or vertical analysis of liabilities and shareholder equity is then presented for the...

• CHAPTER 5: FINANCIAL RETURNS: PROFITABILITY RATIOS.  // Micronesia Federation Economic Competitiveness;2006, p75 

  In this chapter we consider additional financial ratios estimated for firms operating in Micronesia Federation benchmarked against global averages. The chapter begins by defining relevant terms. Estimates are then presented for the typical firm operating in Micronesia Federation compared to...

• MANAGING PENSION EXPENSE TO MEET ANALYSTS' EARNINGS FORECASTS: IMPLICATIONS FOR NEW FASB PENSION STANDARD. Parker, Paula Diane // Academy of Accounting & Financial Studies Journal;Jun2009 Supplement, Vol. 13, p103 

  This paper presents evidence that pension expense is used by firms to manage bottom-line reported earnings in order to meet their targeted analysts' earnings forecasts. Firms are predicted and shown to manipulate reported earnings in the direction that will move them closer to their targeted...

• When Do Analysts Adjust for Biases in Management Guidance? Effects of Guidance Track Record and Analysts' Incentives. TAN, HUN-TONG; Libby, ROBERT; HUNTON, JAMES E. // Contemporary Accounting Research;Spring2010, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p187 

  Prior research indicates that analysts do not fully adjust for the general downward bias in earnings guidance issued by management. We report the results of two experiments designed to investigate how guidance track record and analysts� incentives jointly explain the extent to which analysts...

• Bias in Quarterly Estimates of Annual Effective Tax Rates and Earnings Management. Comprix, Joseph; Mills, Lillian F.; Schmidt, Andrew P. // Journal of the American Taxation Association;Spring2012, Vol. 34 Issue 1, p31 

  We investigate whether quarterly annual effective tax rate (ETR) estimates are systematically biased in comparison to year-end actual ETRs. We find that estimated annual ETRs in the first, second, and third quarters are systematically higher than year end ETRs. We then investigate whether firms'...

• Wilmington Trust to Fall Short. Ackermann, Matt // American Banker;7/20/2009, Vol. 174 Issue 137, p5 

  This article discusses the predicted financial performance of the banking company Wilmington Trust Corp. of Delaware during the second quarter of 2009, to be announced on July 24, 2009. Wilmington Trust expects an 83.1 percent increase in its loan-loss provision as compared to the first quarter...

• CHAPTER 4: FINANCIAL RETURNS: INCOME STRUCTURE RATIOS.  // Jordan Economic Competitiveness;Feb2006, p53 

  In this chapter we consider the income structure of companies operating in Jordan benchmarked against global averages. The chapter begins by defining relevant terms. A common-size statement, or vertical analysis of income is then presented for the typical firm operating in Jordan and the average...

• CHAPTER 4: FINANCIAL RETURNS: INCOME STRUCTURE RATIOS.  // Micronesia Federation Economic Competitiveness;2006, p53 

  In this chapter we consider the income structure of companies operating in Micronesia Federation benchmarked against global averages. The chapter begins by defining relevant terms. A common-size statement, or vertical analysis of income is then presented for the typical firm operating in...

Read the Article