Political Theory Put to the Test: Comparative Law and the Origins of Judicial Constitutional Review

Adams, Maurice; Van der Schyff, Gerhard
March 2010
Global Jurist;Mar2010, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p10
Academic Journal
In this article we try to answer the questions of why and when judicial constitutional review comes about as a matter of fact in some countries (as in Belgium and South Africa) but does not seem able to get off the ground in others (as in the Netherlands). More generally phrased: under what conditions is judicial constitutional review actually introduced in a particular jurisdiction? These are questions with a politico-sociological dimension, and what is striking is the extent to which these have remained underexposed in the wealth of research on the theme of judicial constitutional review. Here we will attempt to address these questions, and we will do so by outlining the political genesis and development of judicial constitutional review in Belgium and South Africa and also by checking these histories against a number of explanatory models or theories derived from political science. It turns out that the introduction of judicial constitutional review cannot simply be ascribed exclusively to the covert strategies of a particular societal class that wants to protect its value systems (as R. Hirschl argues), but might just as well be the result of a concrete systemic need of a tangible political system. Our main aim is to make suggestions for a reorientation of the theories concerned, especially by putting 'grand social theorizing' against legal dynamics, and to try to bring the two perspectives together.


Related Articles

  • Why Politics Is Insoluble. Hazlitt, Henry // Modern Age;Fall1984, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p394 

    Discusses the concept of political science. Types of political institutions or forms of government; Role of the establishment of the body of law and legal precedents in a civilized country; Characteristics of an ideal government and scientific political institutions.

  • SOCIOLOGICAL CONTROVERSIES IN PERSPECTIVE. Tschannen, Oliver // Review of Religious Research;Sep94, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p70 

    The historian of political science Quentin Skinner argues that it is not possible to understand correctly the meaning of a text if one ignores the intentions of its author. This approach is useful not only in the understanding of historical texts, but also for the interpretation of present...

  • PREREQUISITES FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE THEORY OF POLITICAL SYSTEM IN THE WESTERN POLITICAL SCIENCE. Yuryevna, Gaydt Anna // Theory & Practice of Social Development;2014, Issue 2, p1 

    The article deals with the process of establishment of the political systems theory in the western political science. Among the events contributing to development of the system ideas about politics the author studies not only those which occurred in the political science structure, but also...

  • What Did Our Forefathers Try to Accomplish? Cowling, Donald J. // Vital Speeches of the Day;7/15/52, Vol. 18 Issue 19, p589 

    Presents the text of a speech given by Donald J. Cowling, president emeritus of Carleton College in Northfield, Minnesota on February 22, 1952, which deals with the limitations on the powers of government.

  • O SUPREMO NA CONSTITUINTE E A CONSTITUINTE NO SUPREMO. Koerner, Andrei; de Freitas, L&#;gia Barros // Lua Nova;2013, Vol. 88, p141 

    This article analyzes the relations between ministers of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court (STF) and other political agents during the constituent process (1987-1988). Two perspectives are adopted. Firstly, the STF is analyzed as an object of constitutional deliberation. Such an analysis is...

  • The Rise and Rise of Commonwealth Constitutional Power. Zifcak, Spencer // Legaldate;Mar2003, Vol. 15 Issue 1, p1 

    Explains the expansion of the Commonwealth constitutional power in Australia.

  • LA COSTITUZIONE DI CADICE DEL 1812 NELLA CULTURA POLITICA EUROPEA DEL PRIMO OTTOCENTO. Di Rienzo, Eugenio // Nuova Rivista Storica;set-dic2011, Vol. 95 Issue 3, p971 

    The article discusses the Constitution of Cádiz, also known as Spanish Constitution of 1812, and its influence on the European political culture in the 1800s. This constitution, one of the most liberal of its time, was effectively Spain's first, given that the Bayonne Statute issued in 1808...

  • Good But Not Enough: Recent Developments of Political Science in Italy. Capano, Giliberto; Verzichelli, Luca // European Political Science;Mar2010, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p102 

    The article analyses the nature and prospects of political science in a country where a number of historical and cultural constraints have so far hampered a broad presence of the discipline. The article focuses in particular on the last twenty years, a period in which there has been a radical...


    The article discusses Israel's constitutional history. Its main focus is on the disagreements, controversies and disputes of Israel's constitution making that prevent it from progressing. Israel's choice of non-decision constitution-making tactic is itself a decision not to decide. The attempt...


Other Topics