TITLE

From Maimonides to Napoleon: the True and the Normative

AUTHOR(S)
Taieb, Julien
PUB. DATE
January 2007
SOURCE
Global Jurist;Jan2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p8
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
In this paper I will pursue a reflection on the question of the conflicts of laws between religious and civil law in France. After having introduced and criticized the process of normative decline of Jewish law -- the Halakha -- I will propose therapies for such a process, both from a normative and non-normative perspective. My inspiration derives from the Talmudic idea of separation between truth and normativity. Indeed, Hillel often prevailed when he and Shammaï would disagree on the meaning of the Torah but both their interpretations were nonetheless "the words of the living God" says the Talmud. A normative therapy: to defend a casuistic approach to resolve conflicts of laws between religious and civil law rather than the systematic approach set up by the 2004 statute. A non-normative therapy: to promote an epistemological understanding of the confluence between Halakha and French law through the theme of codification. A comparison between Maimonides' Mishne Torah and the Napoleonic Civil Code reveals several converging features such as the incapacity of the codes to put an end to controversy. Such commonality could help Jews exiled in France to overcome conflicts of laws between French and Jewish laws and to live an appeased conflict. Because the experience of Galut (exile) is too complex to be reduced to the sole words of the judge, it appears sound to separate the true from the normative. Only on the basis of this predicate, will Jews exiled in France be able to avoid a hierarchization of Jewish and French law in case of conflict and the resulting ontological conflicts between their inner selves.
ACCESSION #
57524412

 

Related Articles

  • REGIMUL JURIDIC ACTUAL AL CIRCULAÅ¢IEI TERENURILOR PROPRIETATE PRIVATÄ‚. CHELARU, EUGEN // Dreptul;2013, Issue 4, p40 

    In this study, the author makes a thorough analysis of the current regime of private land movement in Romania in the light of the regulations contained in the new Romanian Civil Code (entered into force on 1 October 2011), as well as in other normative acts in force, but adopted earlier (the...

  • CONSIDERATIONS REGARDING SYSTEMIC INTERACTION OF LAW WITH OTHER SOCIAL NORMATIVE SUBSYSTEMS. Butculescu, C. R. D.; Florea, S. M. // AGORA International Journal of Juridical Sciences;2014, Vol. 4, p27 

    This article tackles the issue of systemic interaction between various normative systems. As such, it addresses and analyses the system of law from the perspective the general systems theory. More than that, the paper analyses the links and interactions between various normative systems, called...

  • ¿LA LEY RELIGIOSA ES LA ÚNICA POSIBLE PARA UN ESTADO DE MAYORÍA MUSULMANA? Abumalham, Montserrat // Bandue: Revista de la Sociedad Española de Ciencias de las Reli;2010, Vol. 4, p7 

    This paper analyzes the differences between religious Law and civil Law in Islam; its historical development and its present political reality. The three main questions discussed are the definition of Shari'a, the diversity of Islams and the characterization of political Islam today.

  • India: What Minority Women Want? Debating The Uniform Civil Code. Vijay, Hema // Women's Feature Service;7/21/2014, p1 

    The article discusses a debate surrounding the Uniform Civil Code, a set of rules that may provide the basis for the creation of laws regardless of religion in India. Topics discussed include the Muslim religious law Sharia, the concerns of the minorities in India about the imposition of Hindu...

  • Normative Conflict in International Law. Pavel, Carmen // San Diego Law Review;Fall2009, Vol. 46 Issue 4, p883 

    The article explores the skepticism about the legal conflict in international law. It examines the institutional implications of normative tensions for international law. The author implies that the international law system does not have a centralized institutional structure for legislating the...

  • SOLUÅ¢II LA CONFLICTUL LEGILOR ÃŽN TIMP. ÃŽN CÄ‚UTAREA FORMULEI IDEALE: DE LA TEORIA DREPTURILOR CÂŞTIGATE LA TEORIA NORMATIVISTÄ‚ (III)2) - TEORIA APLICÄ‚RII IMEDIATE A LEGII NOI -. Nicolae, Marian // Romanian Review of Private Law / Revista Romana de Drept Privat;2013, Issue 2, p23 

    In case of laws' succession in time, if the new law amends or suppresses the prior law and, under the influence of the latter, legal situations were born or, where appropriate, legal situations are pending to be set up, amended or dissolute, an intertemporal conflict arises between the old law...

  • Constitutionalism, Public Policy and Discriminatory Testamentary Bequests--A Good Fit Between Common Law and Civil Law in South Africa's Mixed Jurisdiction? du Toit, François // Tulane European & Civil Law Forum;2012, Vol. 27, p97 

    This Article investigates South African courts' treatment of discriminatory testamentary bequests in the pre- and post-constitutional eras. It shows a change in judicial attitude towards such bequests from an accommodating, tolerant stance, purportedly founded on South Africa's Roman- Dutch...

  • The Normativity of Private Law. Smith, Stephen A. // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies;Summer2011, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p215 

    Private law presents itself in normative language—in the language of rights, duties, obligations and so on. This language presumes that private law tells citizens how they ought to behave. It is striking, therefore, that contemporary legal theorists often explain and evaluate private law...

  • Rolul dreptului comparat în construcÅ£ia dreptului Uniunii Europene. GUŢAN, Manuel // Revista Româna de Drept European;2013, Issue 4, p90 

    The considerable development of the European law determined an enforced debate as regards the proper legislative mechanisms to be used for this kind of normativity to be born. In this context, comparative law proved to be an excellent scientific instrument for obtaining legal solutions...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics