TITLE

International Contracts between Common Law and Civil Law: Is Non-state Law to Be Preferred? The Difficulty of Interpreting Legal Standards Such as Good Faith

AUTHOR(S)
Moss, Giuditta Cordero
PUB. DATE
January 2007
SOURCE
Global Jurist;Jan2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p2
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Most commercial contracts are nowadays written on the basis of English or American contract models, irrespective of whether the legal relationship that the contracts regulate is governed by a law belonging to a Common Law system or not. These contract models are drafted on the basis of the requirements and structure of the respective Common Law system in which they were originally meant to operate. These models may therefore be in part ineffective or parts thereof may redundant, if the governing law belongs to a Civilian system. To overcome this tension between Common and Civil Law, it is sometimes recommended to subject international contracts to non-state sources of law (also referred to as transnational law, lex mercatoria, soft law). This article analyses the tension between the Common and the Civil Law of contracts, and to what extent non-state sources may represent a satisfactory solution to such tension. This is made by analyzing the role that good faith and fair dealing play in contracts according to the respective systems: English law as an illustration of Common Law systems, Norwegian, German and Italian law as illustrations of Civil Law Systems, the UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts and the Principles of European Contract Law as illustration of non-state sources.
ACCESSION #
57524406

 

Related Articles

  • SĄŽININGUMO PRINCIPAS PRIEVOLINIUOSE TEISINIUOSE SANTYKIUOSE. Arlauskas, Saulius; Jokubauskas, Remigijus // Jurisprudencija;2013, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p1368 

    The authors pay attention to the principle of good faith, which has an exclusive place in the private law in foreign states and Lithuania. his principle takes its beginning in the Roman law and has paramount value in contemporaneous civil law. Obviously, a significant role in defining the...

  • UNELE OBSERVAÅ¢II PRIVIND CORELAÅ¢IA ÃŽNTRE BUNA-CREDINÅ¢A ÃŽN CONTRACTE, OBLIGAÅ¢IA DE COERENŢĂ ÅžI PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL-UL. FLOARE, Marius-Ioan // Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai, Iurisprudentia;iul-sep2014, Issue 3, p5 

    In using the functional method in comparative law, one frequently stumbles on the Common Law notion of promissory estoppel as an equivalent in contracts to the good faith principle of continental civil law. Others "translate" promissory estoppel as an expression of the duty of coherence, which...

  • Beware of the Name. Gold, Lessing E. // SDM: Security Distributing & Marketing;Jan2008, Vol. 38 Issue 1, p46 

    The article reports on the lawsuit involving the issue of whether the name of the company sold, "Old Company," can be used by anyone other than the buyer in Nebraska. The alarm company that purchased the Old Company filed a lawsuit against the "New Corporation" and its shareholder who were using...

  • Principios jurídicos del seguro. Núñez del Prado S., Alonso // Revista Ibero-Latinoamericana de Seguros;jul2011, Vol. 20 Issue 35, p49 

    This is a paper published by the author several years ago, which he has written again, amplifying and updating. It is an expanded and corrected version in which there is also a new part. The paper deal with what the author call 'The Legal Insurance Principles', among he has considered:...

  • GOOD MORALS WITHIN THE REGULATION OF THE NEW CIVIL LAW. Florian, Radu-Gheorghe // AGORA International Journal of Juridical Sciences;2012, Vol. 1, p23 

    The hereby survey sets its goal to analyze the way in which the issue of good morals is mirrored within the new civil law of Romania, considered as an element limiting the principle of civil judicial deeds as well as the identification of circumstances where the law giver has understood to rule...

  • PRÍSTUPY K RESENÍ OBOUSTRANNÉHO OMYLU PRI UZAVÍRÁNÍ SMLOUVY. Vicek, Karel // Pravnik;2013, Vol. 152 Issue 11, p1113 

    The article describes the problem of the common mistake during the negotiation process. Firstly, the author looks for a solution in the foreign civil codes. These findings are applied on the Czech civil law, especially on the valid civil code and the new civil code. There are two solutions types...

  • PAUTAS PARA LA FUTURA PUBLICACION DE ARTICULOS EN LA REVISTA IBERO-LATINOAMERICANA DE SEGUROS. Jurídicas, Facultad de Ciencias // Revista Ibero-Latinoamericana de Seguros;2014, Issue 40, p1 

    The study that is presented for consideration of the reader tries to go into depth in the Good Faith Principle, in its most general aspects to later derive the analysis to which has been named "contractual good faith", due to the particular field in which it acts. In relation to the latter,...

  • IMPREVIZIUNEA ÅžI INCIDENÅ¢A ACESTEIA ASUPRA CONTRACTULUI, CU REFERIRE SPECIALÄ‚ PRIVITOARE LA CONTRACTUL DE CESIUNE A UNEI OPERE LITERARE, ARTISTICE SAU ÅžTIINÅ¢IFICE. FLOREA, BUJOREL // Dreptul;2012, Vol. 141 Issue 11, p118 

    The relatively recently legal notion of imprevision brought under Romanian regulation by the new Civil code that came into force October 1st, 2011, is expected to be subject of numerous specialized analyses in order to clarify the various aspects that make up its identity, characteristics and...

  • REASONABLENESS AND JUSTICE AS A PRINCIPLES OF THE CIVIL LAW AND THE BEGINNING OF FUNCTIONING OF THE SYSTEM OF CIVIL CIRCULATION. Vinichenko, Yu. V. // Perm University Herald. Yuridical Sciences / Vestnik Permskogo U;2014, Issue 3, p98 

    Introduction: through the prism of the question of the principles of civil law and the doctrine of the civil circulation in the article examines the category of «reasonableness» and «justice». Purpose: Based on the provisions of Russian and foreign civil law, civil doctrine and...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics