Comparison of CT and MRI for Diagnosis of Suspected Scaphoid Fractures

Mallee, Wouter; Doornberg, Job N.; Ring, David; van Dijk, C. Niek; Maas, Mario; Goslings, J. Carel
January 2011
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;1/5/2011, Vol. 93-A Issue 1, p20
Academic Journal
Background: There is no consensus on the optimum imaging method to use to confirm the diagnosis of true scaphoid fractures among patients with suspected scaphoid fractures. This study tested the null hypothesis that computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) have the same diagnostic performance characteristics for the diagnosis of scaphoid fractures. Methods: Thirty-four consecutive patients with a suspected scaphoid fracture (tenderness of the scaphoid and normal radiographic findings after a fall on the outstretched hand) underwent CT and MRI within ten days after a wrist injury. The reference standard for a true fracture of the scaphoid was six-week follow-up radiographs in four views. A panel including surgeons and radiologists came to a consensus diagnosis for each type of imaging. The images were considered in a randomly ordered, blinded fashion, independent of the other types of imaging. We calculated sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy as well as positive and negative predictive values. Results: The reference standard revealed six true fractures of the scaphoid (prevalence, 18%). CT demonstrated a fracture in five patients (15%), with one false-positive, two false-negative, and fourtrue-positive results. MRI demonstrated a fracture in seven patients (21%), with three false-positive, two false-negative, and four true-positive results. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were 67%, 96%, and 91%, respectively, for CT and 67%, 89%, and 85%, respectively, for MRI. According to the McNemar test for paired binary data, these differences were not significant. The positive predictive value with use of the Bayes formula was 0.76 for CT and 0.54 for MRI. The negative predictive value was 0.94 for CT and 0.93 for MRI. Conclusions: CT and MRI had comparable diagnostic characteristics. Both were better at excluding scaphoid fractures than they were at confirming them, and both were subject to false-positive and false-negative interpretations. The best reference standard is debatable, but it is now unclear whether or not bone edema on MRI and small unicortical lines on CT represent a true fracture. Level of Evidence: Diagnostic LevelI. See Instructions to Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.


Related Articles

  • Diagnosis of scaphoid fracture: optimal imaging techniques. Geijer, Mats // Reports in Medical Imaging;2013, Vol. 6, p57 

    This review aims to provide an overview of modern imaging techniques for evaluation of scaphoid fracture, with emphasis on occult fractures and an outlook on the possible evolution of imaging; it also gives an overview of the pathologic and anatomic basis for selection of techniques. Displaced...

  • Two-Dimensional Image Fusion of Planar Bone Scintigraphy and Radiographs in Patients with Clinical Scaphoid Fracture: An Imaging Study. Henriksen, O. M.; Lonsdale, M. N.; Jensen, T. D.; Weikop, K. L.; Holm, O.; Duus, B.; Friberg, L. // Acta Radiologica;Feb2009, Vol. 50 Issue 1, p71 

    Background: Although magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is now considered the gold standard in second-line imaging of patients with suspected scaphoid fracture and negative radiographs, bone scintigraphy can be used in patients with pacemakers, metallic implants, or other contraindications to MRI....

  • Observer variation in MRI for suspected scaphoid fractures. Beeres, F. J. P.; Hogervorst, M.; Kingma, L. M.; Le Cessie, S.; Coerkamp, E. G.; Rhemrev, S. J. // British Journal of Radiology;Dec2008, Vol. 81 Issue 972, p950 

    The aim of this study was to evaluate prospectively the observer variation in the detection of pathology on MRI for suspected acute scaphoid fracture. 79 consecutive MR scans were included to calculate the inter-observer variation. All patients were suspected of having a scaphoid fracture but...

  • The occasional scaphoid cast. Brock, Gordon; Tarambikos, Alex // Canadian Journal of Rural Medicine;Fall2003, Vol. 8 Issue 4, p263 

    The common cause of a scaphoid fracture is a fall onto the outstretched hand, involving a forced dorsiflexion and radial deviation. A scaphoid fracture is usually treated with a carefully molded, shortarm cast that includes the proximal phalanx of the thumb, worn for six to twelve weeks. As is...

  • MDCT and MRI for the diagnosis of complex fractures of the tibial plateau: A case control study. YUNQIN XU; QIANG LI; PEIHUA SU; TUGANG SHEN; YAZHONG ZHU // Experimental & Therapeutic Medicine;2014, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p199 

    The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical value of multidetector-row computed tomography (MDCT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the diagnosis and treatment of complex fractures of the tibial plateau. A total of 71 patients with complex fractures of the tibial plateau (estimated...

  • Citations and Clinicians' Notes: Musculoskeletal Imaging.  // Current Medical Literature: Medical Imaging;2003, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p102 

    Presents a clinicians' notes on musculoskeletal imaging. Early magnetic resonance imaging in the management of clinical scaphoid fracture; Injury of the tibiofibular syndesmosis: value of MR imaging for diagnosis; Jumpers and fallers: a comparison of the distribution of skeletal injury.

  • Is dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI useful for assessing proximal fragment vascularity in scaphoid fracture delayed and non-union? Ng, Alex; Griffith, James; Taljanovic, Mihra; Li, Alvin; Tse, W.; Ho, P. // Skeletal Radiology;Jul2013, Vol. 42 Issue 7, p983 

    Objective: To assess dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE MRI) as a measure of vascularity in scaphoid delayed-union or non-union. Materials and methods: Thirty-five patients (34 male, one female; mean age, 27.4 ± 9.4 years; range, 16-51 years) with scaphoid delayed-union...

  • Journal scan. Lumsden, Karen // Emergency Nurse;May2010, Vol. 18 Issue 2, p11 

    This section offers news briefs on the findings of emergency nursing studies as of May 2010. The role of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the diagnosis of clinically suspected scaphoid fracture was examined by M. Khalid et al. Another study reviewed 25 papers and one case study relating to...

  • Diagnosing Suspected Scaphoid Fractures: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Zhong-Gang Yin; Jian-Bing Zhang; Shi-Lian Kan; Xiao-Gang Wang // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Mar2010, Vol. 468 Issue 3, p723 

    Imaging protocols for suspected scaphoid fractures among investigators and hospitals are markedly inconsistent. We performed a systematic review and metaanalysis to assess and compare the diagnostic performance of bone scintigraphy, MRI, and CT for diagnosing suspected scaphoid fractures....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics