Are self-report of disability pension and long-term sickness absence accurate? Comparisons of self-reported interview data with national register data in a Swedish twin cohort

Svedberg, Pia; Ropponen, Annina; Lichtenstein, Paul; Alexanderson, Kristina
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p763
Academic Journal
Background: Self-reported disability pension (DP) and sickness absence are commonly used in epidemiological and other studies as a measure of exposure or even as an outcome. The aims were (1) to compare such selfreports with national register information in order to evaluate the validity of self-reported DP and sickness absence, and (2) to estimate the concordance of reporting behaviour in different twin zygosity groups, also by sex. Methods: All Swedish twins born 1933-1958 who participated in the Screening Across the Lifespan Twin study (SALT) 1998-2003, were included (31,122 individuals). The self-reported DP and long-term sickness absence (LTSA) at the time of interview was compared to the corresponding register information retrieved from the National Social Insurance Agency by calculating the proportions of agreements, kappa, sensitivity, specificity, concordance rates, and chi-square test, to evaluate construct validity. Results: The proportions of overall agreement were 96% and specificity 99% for both DP and LTSA, while the sensitivity was 70% for DP and 45% for LTSA. Kappa estimates were 0.76 for DP, and 0.58 for LTSA. The proportions of positive agreement were 64% for DP and 42% for LTSA. No difference in response style was found between zygosity groups among complete twin pairs for DP and LTSA. Results were similar for women and men and across age. Kappa estimates for DP differed somewhat depending on years of education, 0.68 (college/university) vs. 0.77 (less than 13 years in school) but not for LTSA. Conclusions: Self-reported DP data may be very useful in studies when register information is not available, however, register data is preferred especially for LTSA. The same degree of twin similarity was found for truthful self-report of DP and LTSA in both monozygotic and dizygotic twin pairs. Thus, the response style was not influenced by genetic factors. One consequence of this would be that when estimating the relative importance of genetic and environmental effects from twin models, heritability estimates would not be biased.


Related Articles

  • Sick-leave track record and other potential predictors of a disability pension. A population based study of 8,218 men and women followed for 16 years. Wallman, Thorne; Wedel, Hans; Palmer, Edward; Rosengren, Annika; Johansson, Saga; Eriksson, Henry; Svärdsudd, Kurt // BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: A number of previous studies have investigated various predictors for being granted a disability pension. The aim of this study was to test the efficacy of sick-leave track record as a predictor of being granted a disability pension in a large dataset based on subjects sampled from...

  • Short sickness absence and subsequent sickness absence due to mental disorders - a follow-up study among municipal employees. Sumanen, Hilla; Pietiläinen,, Olli; Lahelma, Eero; Rahkonen, Ossi // BMC Public Health;1/5/2017, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Mental disorders are common diagnostic causes for longer sickness absence and disability retirement in OECD-countries. Short sickness absence spells are also common, and neither trivial for health and work ability. We studied how prior short sickness absence spells and...

  • Using administrative sickness absence data as a marker of future disability pension: the prospective DREAM study of Danish private sector employees. Lund, Thomas; Kivimäki, Mika; Labriola, Merete; Villadsen, Ebbe; Christensen, Karl Bang // Occupational & Environmental Medicine;Jan2008, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p28 

    Objectives: The aim of this study was to examine duration of sickness absence as a risk marker for future disability pension among all private sector employees in Denmark 1998-2004. Methods: All private sector employees receiving sickness absence compensation from the municipality in 1998, a...

  • `Unfair pressure' on sick staff.  // People Management;6/25/1998, Vol. 4 Issue 13, p16 

    Unveils a report on the unfair pressure on employees who take sickness leave in Great Britain, conducted by Unison, the public-sector employees' union. Measures used by corporations to control absenteeism; Comments from Sarah Copsey of Unison on absenteeism policies.

  • NHS staff rack up twice as much sick leave as private sector workers. Snow, Tamsin // Nursing Standard;6/7/2006, Vol. 20 Issue 39, p5 

    The article reports on the high rate of sick leaves accumulated by National Health Service (NHS) staffs in Great Britain. In a survey of all NHS trusts, employees incurred an average of 12 days sick leave a year, which is higher than the six days leave per employee in private institutions. To...

  • Comparisons of self-reported and register data on sickness absence among public employees in Sweden. Voss, M.; Stark, S.; Alfredsson, L.; Vingård, E.; Josephson, M. // Occupational & Environmental Medicine;Jan2008, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p61 

    Aim: Self-reported assessments of sickness absence are often performed in epidemiological studies. The objective of this study was to compare the number of sick-leave days according to self-reported data over 12 months with data from the employer's register for the same period. An additional aim...

  • Living Beyond Our “Means”: New Methods for Comparing Distributions. Jones, Camera Phyllis // American Journal of Epidemiology;1997, Vol. 146 Issue 12, p1056 

    This paper introduces the projection methods for describing and testing the differences between pairs of continuous distributions. These methods include the projection plot, the projection spline, and the iter-1 test. The projection plot displays the difference between corresponding quantiles...

  • Poly-helminth Infection in East Guatemalan School Children. Sorensen, William C.; Cappello, Michael; Bell, Deborah; DiFedele, Lisa M.; Brown, Mary Ann // Journal of Global Infectious Diseases;Jan2011, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p25 

    Background: Soil transmitted helminths (STH) remain a global public health concern in spite of occasional dosing campaigns. Aims: To determine baseline prevalence and intensity of STH infection in east Guatemalan school children, and describe the associated epidemiology of anemia, stunting, and...

  • Socio-economic differences in participation of households in a Belgian national health survey. Demarest, Stefaan; Van der Heyden, Johan; Charafeddine, Rana; Tafforeau, Jean; Van Oyen, Herman; Van Hal, Guido // European Journal of Public Health;Dec2013, Vol. 23 Issue 6, p981 

    Background: Socio-economic inequalities in health survey participation can jeopardize the extrapolation of the survey findings to the total population. Earlier research, based on aggregated data, showed that in Belgium less-educated people with poor health were less likely to participate in a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics