The paradox of screening: Rural womens views on screening for postnatal depression

Armstrong, Susan J.; Small, Rhonda E.
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p744
Academic Journal
Background: Universal screening for postnatal depression is currently being promoted in Australia to assist detection and treatment of affected women, yet debate continues internationally about the effectiveness of screening. One rural shire in Victoria has been screening all women for postnatal depression at maternal and child health checks for many years. This paper explores the views of women affected by this intervention. Methods: A postal survey was sent to an entire one year cohort of women resident in the shire and eligible for this program [n = 230]. Women were asked whether they recalled having been screened for postnatal depression and what their experience had been, including any referrals made as a result of screening. Women interested in providing additional information were invited to give a phone number for further contact. Twenty women were interviewed in-depth about their experiences. The interview sample was selected to include both depressed and non-depressed women living in town and on rural properties, who represented the range of circumstances of women living in the shire. Results: The return rate for the postal survey was 62% [n = 147/230]. Eighty-seven women indicated that they were interested in further contact, 80 of whom were able to be reached by telephone and 20 were interviewed indepth. Women had diverse views and experiences of screening. The EPDS proved to be a barrier for some women, and a facilitator for others, in accessing support and referrals. The mediating factor appeared to be a trusting relationship with the nurse able to communicate her concern for the woman and offer support and referrals if required. Conclusions: Detection of maternal depression requires more than administration of a screening tool at a single time point. While this approach did work for some women, for others it actually made appropriate care and support more difficult. Rather, trained and empathic healthcare providers working in a coordinated primary care service should provide multiple and flexible opportunities for women to disclose and discuss their emotional health issues.


Related Articles

  • Perinatal Psychiatric Disorders. Frank, Julia B. // Psychiatric Annals;Jul2012, Vol. 42 Issue 7, p250 

    The article discusses various reports in this issue, including those about melancholia in pregnancy, postpartum depression as a psychiatric disorder and bipolar II disorder.

  • Mental health of parents caring for infants. Murray, L.; Cooper, P.; Hipwell, A. // Archives of Women's Mental Health;2003 Supplement 2, Vol. 6, ps71 

    Summary ¶The postpartum period is a sensitive time due to the presence and demands of the developing infant. The care provided by a mother to her infant during this period may be compromised if she is suffering from postnatal depression or postpartum psychosis. Evidence has been emerging...

  • The prevention and psychotherapeutic treatment of postpartum depression. Stuart, S.; O’Hara, M. W.; Gorman, L. L. // Archives of Women's Mental Health;2003 Supplement 2, Vol. 6, ps57 

    Summary ¶The efficacy of psychotherapeutic interventions for the acute treatment of postpartum depression is strongly supported by empirical data, which suggest that counseling is of benefit as a stand-alone treatment for postpartum depression. Given the paucity of treatment trials using...

  • A systematic review of home-based interventions to prevent and treat postpartum depression. Leis, Julie A.; Mendelson, Tamar; Tandon, Darius; Perry, Deborah F. // Archives of Women's Mental Health;2009, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p3 

    This systematic review evaluated randomized controlled trials assessing home-based psychological interventions to prevent and treat postpartum depression (PPD). Six studies meeting inclusion criteria were identified, five assessing treatments for PPD and one assessing a preventive intervention...

  • The Psychosocial Work Environment and Maternal Postpartum Depression. Dagher, Rada K.; McGovern, Patricia M.; Alexander, Bruce H.; Dowd, Bryan E.; Ukestad, Laurie K.; McCaffrey, David J. // International Journal of Behavioral Medicine;Dec2009, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p339 

    Postpartum depression is a debilitating mental disorder affecting women after childbirth. This study examined the correlates of postpartum depression at 11 weeks after childbirth, focusing on work-related stressors and applying the job demand–control–support model. Investigators...

  • Postnatal depression. Chew-Graham, Carolyn // GP: General Practitioner;10/17/2008, p30 

    The article offers information on the implication of postnatal depression among women in Great Britain. It affects 8-15 percent of women, which can result in long-term adverse consequences for maternal mood and infant development. It is disadvantageous because it can affect relationships and...

  • Global and relationship-specific perceptions of support and the development of postpartum depressive symptomatology. Dennis, Cindy-Lee; Letourneau, Nicole // Social Psychiatry & Psychiatric Epidemiology;May2007, Vol. 42 Issue 5, p389 

    Background: A lack of social support has consistently been demonstrated to be an important modifiable risk factor for postpartum depression. As such, a greater understanding of specific support variables may assist health professionals in the development of effective preventive...

  • Postpartum Depression. Wisner, Katherine L.; Parry, Barbara L.; Piontek, Catherine M. // New England Journal of Medicine;7/18/2002, Vol. 347 Issue 3, p194 

    Discusses medical treatment of postpartum depression. Presentation of patient; Clinical problem; Definitions; Causes; Screening; Evaluation and differential diagnosis; Antidepressant treatment; Breast-feeding; Prophylactic treatment; Psychotherapy; Hormonal therapy; Areas of uncertainty;...

  • The Baby Blues AND BEYOND. Greenberg, Susan H.; Springen, Karen; Underwood, Anne; Figueroa, Ana; Westreich, Joan; Pepper, Tara // Newsweek;7/2/2001, Vol. 138 Issue 1, p26 

    Focuses on the condition, postpartum depression (PPD), which is characterized by feelings of anxiety, hopelessness, and guilt, insomnia, and lack of motivation. Percentage of women who suffer from the disorder; Possible causes of PPD, including hormonal changes; Treatments for the condition;...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics