Do obese but metabolically normal women differ in intra-abdominal fat and physical activity levels from those with the expected metabolic abnormalities? A cross-sectional study

Hayes, Louise; Pearce, Mark S.; Firbank, Michael J.; Walker, Mark; Taylor, Roy; Unwin, Nigel C.
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p723
Academic Journal
Background: Obesity remains a major public health problem, associated with a cluster of metabolic abnormalities. However, individuals exist who are very obese but have normal metabolic parameters. The aim of this study was to determine to what extent differences in metabolic health in very obese women are explained by differences in body fat distribution, insulin resistance and level of physical activity. Methods: This was a cross-sectional pilot study of 39 obese women (age: 28-64 yrs, BMI: 31-67 kg/m²) recruited from community settings. Women were defined as 'metabolically normal' on the basis of blood glucose, lipids and blood pressure. Magnetic Resonance Imaging was used to determine body fat distribution. Detailed lifestyle and metabolic profiles of participants were obtained. Results: Women with a healthy metabolic profile had lower intra-abdominal fat volume (geometric mean 4.78 l [95% CIs 3.99-5.73] vs 6.96 l [5.82-8.32]) and less insulin resistance (HOMA 3.41 [2.62-4.44] vs 6.67 [5.02-8.86]) than those with an abnormality. The groups did not differ in abdominal subcutaneous fat volume (19.6 l [16.9-22.7] vs 20.6 [17.6-23.9]). A higher proportion of those with a healthy compared to a less healthy metabolic profile met current physical activity guidelines (70% [95% CIs 55.8-84.2] vs 25% [11.6-38.4]). Intra-abdominal fat, insulin resistance and physical activity make independent contributions to metabolic status in very obese women, but explain only around a third of the variance. Conclusion: A sub-group of women exists who are metabolically normal despite being very obese. Differences in fat distribution, insulin resistance, and physical activity level are associated with metabolic differences in these women, but account only partially for these differences. Future work should focus on strategies to identify those obese individuals most at risk of the negative metabolic consequences of obesity and on identifying other factors that contribute to metabolic status in obese individuals.


Related Articles

  • Diurnal metabolic profiles after 14 d of an ad libitum high-starch, high-sucrose, or high-fat diet in normal-weight never-obese and postobese women. Raben, Anne; Holst, Jens J.; Madsen, Joop; Astrup, Arne // American Journal of Clinical Nutrition;Feb2001, Vol. 73 Issue 2, p177 

    Background: The influence of the amount and type of carbohydrates in the diet on risk factors for obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease remains unclear. Objective: We investigated the effects of 2 low-fat diets (high-sucrose and high-starch) and a high-fat diet on glycemia, lipidemia,...

  • Correlation Between Insulin Suppression Test and Quantitative Insulin Sensitivity Check Index in Hypertensive and Normotensive Obese Patients. Gonzalez-Albarran, Olga; Garcia-Robles, Rafael // Diabetes Care;Nov2001, Vol. 24 Issue 11, p1998 

    Deals with a study which determined the accuracy of the Insulin Suppression Test, Quantitative Insulin-Sensitivity Check Index and the homeostasis model assessment among normotensive and hypertensive obese subjects. Information on insulin resistance; Details on the subjects; Analyses of results.

  • Visceral Fat and Adiponectin: Associations with Insulin Resistance Are Tissue-Specific in Women. Robert H. Coker; Rick H. Williams; Sophie E. Yeo; Patrick M. Kortebein; Don L. Bodenner; Philip A. Kern; William J. Evans // Metabolic Syndrome & Related Disorders;Feb2009, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p61 

    AbstractBody fatness and its distribution are strongly and independently associated with peripheral insulin action. However, these associations are limited in their ability to predict the independent nature of hepatic and peripheral insulin resistance, especially in obese women. To define the...

  • Effect of the Frequency of Visits for Exercise Therapy on Improvement of Insulin Resistance in Overweight Patients with Lifestyle-related Diseases. MAKOTO IGAKI; KATSUSHIGE TANIGUCHI; HIROTO HONDA; MOTOAKI KOMATSU; MOTOYOSHI SAKAUE // Rigakuryoho Kagaku;2014, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p301 

    [Purpose] The purpose of this study was to evaluate the frequency of visits for exercise therapy on insulin resistance. [Subjects] The study subjects were 44 overweight outpatients with lifestyle-related diseases. [Methods] They were classified into 2 groups according to the number of exercise...


    Presents an abstract of the study 'Prevalence of Components of the Insulin Resistance Syndrome (IRS) in a Multi-Racial Sample of Obese Children and Adolescents,' by R.M. Viner, T.Y. Segal and P. Hindmarsh, presented at the 7th Spring Meeting of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health.

  • Scaling up community-based obesity prevention in Australia: Background and evaluation design of the Health Promoting Communities: Being Active Eating Well initiative. de Silva-Sanigorski, Andrea M.; Bolton, Kristy; Haby, Michelle; Kremer, Peter; Gibbs, Lisa; Waters, Elizabeth; Swinburn, Boyd // BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p65 

    Background: There is only limited evidence available on how best to prevent childhood obesity and communitybased interventions hold promise, as several successful interventions have now been published. The Victorian Government has recently funded six disadvantaged communities across Victoria,...

  • Fat Distribution and Glucose Metabolism in Older, Obese Men and Women. Yeo, Sophie E.; Hays, Nicholas P.; Dennis, Richard A.; Kortebein, Patrick M.; Sullivan, Dennis H.; Evans, William J.; Coker, Robert H. // Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences & Medical ;Dec2007, Vol. 62 Issue 12, p1393 

    Background. Previous studies have identified relationships between subcutaneous abdominal fat (SAF), visceral fat (VF), and insulin resistance. In addition, lower muscle attenuation and decreased adiponectin have also been associated with insulin resistance. Methods. In order to define these...

  • Physical Activity, Obesity, and Diabetes in Pregnancy. Dye, Timothy D.; Knox, Kerry L.; Artal, Raul; Aubry, Richard H.; Wojtowycz, Martha A. // American Journal of Epidemiology;1997, Vol. 146 Issue 11, p961 

    Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) is the most common medical complication of pregnancy. Women with GDM are at elevated risk for numerous matemal health complications, and their infants are at elevated risk for death and morbidity. Management of GDM has traditionally been through diet and close...

  • More is More. Fetto, John // American Demographics;Jun2001, Vol. 23 Issue 6, p8 

    Comments on the spendings of overweight women on their clothing needs in the United States. Status of obesity in the country; Information on the National Health and Nutritional Examination Survey on obesity; Statistics provided by Marketdata Enterprises Inc. about obese women; Growth of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics