Commuting and health in Cambridge: a study of a `natural experiment in the provision of new transport infrastructure

Ogilvie, David; Griffin, Simon; Jones, Andy; Mackett, Roger; Guell, Cornelia; Panter, Jenna; Jones, Natalia; Cohn, Simon; Lin Yang; Chapman, Cheryl
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p703
Academic Journal
Background: Modifying transport infrastructure to support active travel (walking and cycling) could help to increase population levels of physical activity. However, there is limited evidence for the effects of interventions in this field, and to the best of our knowledge no study has convincingly demonstrated an increase in physical activity directly attributable to this type of intervention. We have therefore taken the opportunity presented by a 'natural experiment' in Cambridgeshire, UK to establish a quasi-experimental study of the effects of a major transport infrastructural intervention on travel behaviour, physical activity and related wider health impacts. Design and methods: The Commuting and Health in Cambridge study comprises three main elements: a cohort study of adults who travel to work in Cambridge, using repeated postal questionnaires and basic objective measurement of physical activity using accelerometers; in-depth quantitative studies of physical activity energy expenditure, travel and movement patterns and estimated carbon emissions using household travel diaries, combined heart rate and movement sensors and global positioning system (GPS) receivers; and a longitudinal qualitative interview study to elucidate participants' attitudes, experiences and practices and to understand how environmental and social factors interact to influence travel behaviour, for whom and in what circumstances. The impacts of a specific intervention - the opening of the Cambridgeshire Guided Busway - and of other changes in the physical environment will be examined using a controlled quasi-experimental design within the overall cohort dataset. Discussion: Addressing the unresolved research and policy questions in this area is not straightforward. The challenges include those of effectively combining different disciplinary perspectives on the research problems, developing common methodological ground in measurement and evaluation, implementing robust quantitative measurement of travel and physical activity behaviour in an unpredictable 'natural experiment' setting, defining exposure to the intervention, defining controls, and conceptualising an appropriate longitudinal analytical strategy.


Related Articles

  • Evaluation of a Walking School Bus for Promoting Physical Activity in Youth. Heelan, Kate A.; Abbey, Bryce M.; Donnelly, Joseph E.; Mayo, Matthew S.; Welk, Gregory J. // Journal of Physical Activity & Health;Sep2009, Vol. 6 Issue 5, p560 

    Background: Walking to and from school has potential to increase daily physical activity among children. Methods: A Walking School Bus (WSB) intervention was implemented for 2 years in 2 schools with a third school as a control. The primary aim evaluated school-wide prevalence of walking to...

  • Effect of a School Choice Policy Change on Active Commuting to Elementary School. Sirard, John R.; McDonald, Kelsey; Mustain, Patrick; Hogan, Whitney; Helm, Alison // American Journal of Health Promotion;Sep/Oct2015, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p28 

    Purpose. The purposes of this study were to assess the effect of restricting school choice on changes in travel distance to school and transportation mode for elementary school students. Design. Study design was pre-post (spring 2010-fall 2010) quasi-experimental. Setting. Study setting was all...

  • The Intern Speaks . . . Winterhalter, Bridget // Journal of Physical Activity & Health;Nov2013, Vol. 10 Issue 8, p1077 

    The author talks about her experience as an intern at "Journal of Physical Activity & Health." The author reveals that she chose an internship at the journal to expose herself further to the most current physical activity literature. She offers her views on the primary epidemic of physical...

  • Potential Health Impact of Switching From Car to Public Transportation When Commuting to Work. Morabia, Alfredo; Mirer, Franklin E.; Amstislavski, Tashia M.; Eisl, Holger M.; Werbe-Fuentes, Jordan; Gorczynski, John; Goranson, Chris; Wolff, Mary S.; Markowitz, Steven B. // American Journal of Public Health;Dec2010, Vol. 100 Issue 12, p2388 

    We assessed humidity-corrected particulate matter (PM2.5) exposure and physical activity (using global positioning system monitors and diaries) among 18 people who commuted by car to Queens College, New York, New York, for 5 days, and then switched to commuting for the next 5 days via public...

  • Cycling to School Is Associated With Lower BMI and Lower Odds of Being Overweight or Obese in a Large Population-Based Study of Danish Adolescents. Østergaard, Lars; Grøntved, Anders; Børrestad, Line Anita B.; Froberg, Karsten; Gravesen, Michael; Andersen, Lars B. // Journal of Physical Activity & Health;Jul2012, Vol. 9 Issue 5, p617 

    Background: Previous studies have been inconclusive concerning the effect of active transport on BMI. Our objective was to investigate the association between travel mode and BMI in a large community-based sample of Danish adolescents. Methods: A cross-sectional survey on health and lifestyle...

  • Commuting beats walking?  // Eastern Eye;11/13/2015, Issue 1328, p28 

    The article reports on a study released by the American Heart Association, which reveals the health benefits of bus or train commuting compared to walking, and also presents a comparison between the health benefits of walking and biking.

  • The Role of Distance in Examining the Association Between Active Commuting to School and Students' Weight Status. DeWeese, Robin; Ohri-Vachaspati, Punam // Journal of Physical Activity & Health;Sep2015, Vol. 12 Issue 9, p1280 

    Background: Active commuting to school (ACS) increases students' daily physical activity, but associations between student weight and ACS are inconsistent. Few studies examining ACS and weight account for distance commuted. This study examines the association between students' weight status and...

  • lifestyle. active TRANSPORTATION. Ekoko, Beatrice Ekwa // Alive: Canada's Natural Health & Wellness Magazine;Sep2014, Issue 383, p101 

    The article explains the essence of active transportation in health development of children. Topics discussed include the concept of active transportation revolves on physical activities like walking and wheeling, social health benefits of active transportation like improving social connections,...

  • Assessing the health-related outcomes and correlates of active transportation in children and youth. Larouche, Richard // Applied Physiology, Nutrition & Metabolism;Mar2014, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p403 

    Active school transport (AST; e.g., the use of nonmotorized modes such as walking and cycling to travel to/from school) is an inexpensive, accessible and environmentally friendly source of physical activity (PA). This dissertation addresses 2 overarching objectives: ( i) to measure the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics