Clinical Impression Versus Standardized Questionnaire: The Spinal Surgeon's Ability to Assess Psychological Distress

Daubs, Michael D.; Patel, Alpesh A.; Willick, Stuart E.; Kendall, Richard W.; Hansen, Pamela; Petron, David J.; Brodke, Darrel S.
December 2010
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;12/15/2010, Vol. 92-A Issue 18, p2878
Academic Journal
Background: Psychological distress can affect spine surgery outcomes. A majority of spinal surgeons do not use standardized questionnaires to assess for psychological distress and instead rely on their clinical impressions. The ability of spinal surgeons to properly assess patients with psychological distress has not been adequately evaluated. Our hypothesis was that the clinical impressions of spinal surgeons were not as accurate as a standardized questionnaire in assessing for psychological distress. Methods: A prospective study was performed with eight physicians, four spinal surgeons and four nonoperative spine specialists, who evaluated 400 patients. All patients completed the Distress and Risk Assessment Method (DRAM) questionnaire for the evaluation of psychological distress. The eight physician subjects, blinded to the results of this questionnaire, performed their routine clinical evaluation and categorized the patients' psychological distress level. The results of the Distress and Risk Assessment Method questionnaire and the surgeons' assessments were compared. Results: In the study population of 400 patients, 64% (254 of 400) were found to have some level of psychological distress. Twenty-two percent (eighty-seven of 400) of the patients were found to have high levels of distress. Overall, the physicians' rate of sensitivity when assessing patients with high levels of distress was 28.7% (95% confidence interval: 19.5%, 39.4%) with a positive predictive value of 47.2% (95% confidence interval: 33.3%, 61.4%). Nonoperative spine specialists had a significantly higher sensitivity rate when assessing highly distressed patients (41.7% [95% confidence interval: 25.5%, 59.2%]) than surgeons (19.6% [95% confidence interval: 9.8%, 33.1%]) (p = 0.03). The sensitivity rates between experienced (greater than ten years in practice) (14.7% [95% confidence interval: 5.0%, 31.1%]) and less experienced (less than two years in practice) (29.4% [95% confidence interval: 10.3%, 56.0%]) spinal surgeons was not significant (p = 0.27). Conclusions: A large percentage of patients (64%) presenting for spine evaluation have some level of psychological distress. When compared with a standardized questionnaire designed to screen for psychological distress, spinal surgeons had low sensitivity rates to detect this distress. The routine use of a standardized questionnaire to screen for psychological distress should be considered.


Related Articles

  • Women's health: do common symptoms in women mirror general distress or specific disease entities?: original article. Krantz, Gunilla; Östergren, Per-Olof // Scandinavian Journal of Public Health;12/31/99, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p311 

    The purpose of this study was to determine aspects of validity of a short self-report inventory, based on physical and psychological symptoms that, according to other studies, are most prevalent in women. It was hypothesized that such symptoms form a single entity, which would be consistent with...

  • Is that pre-op patient terrified? Hewitt, Donna // RN;Sep79, Vol. 42 Issue 9, p44 

    Offers tips on how to assess the anxiety level in patients before a surgical procedure. Formulation of a nursing care plan for the pre-operative phase of patient care; Physiological signs and symptoms related to the anxiety of patients; Coping mechanisms of patients to types of anxieties.

  • Antenatal psychosocial assessment: how accurate are we in determining ‘low-risk’ status? A pilot study. Karatas, Janan C.; Matthey, Stephen; Barnett, Bryanne // Archives of Women's Mental Health;2009, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p97 

    Routine Comprehensive Psychosocial Assessment was implemented antenatally at a public hospital in Sydney in 2000. The assessment, completed on all women, classifies them as (1) currently, or at high-risk of becoming, distressed, or, (2) not currently, or at low risk of becoming, distressed...

  • RESIDUAL LIMB PAIN AND DISTRESS IN AMPUTATED PATIENTS. A BRIEF REPORT. Sucală, Mădălina; Stefan, Simona; Macavei, Bianca; Dobrean, Anca; Bolno, Jaclyn; Mironiuc, Ion Aurel; Mironiuc, Clara; David, Daniel // Journal of Cognitive & Behavioral Psychotherapies;Sep2010, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p211 

    Pre- and post-surgical distress, as well as pre- and post-surgical pain, are amongst some of the psychologically relevant matters of medical intervention in patients with amputated limbs. Distress and pain represent clinical problems of great importance for amputees, as both have considerable...

  • Elusive to the end. Gessell, Paul // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;1/8/2013, Vol. 185 Issue 1, pE81 

    The article focuses on the artist Frida Kahlo and also discusses her psychological disease. It informs that Kahlo had an operation in the year 1946 to fuse four vertebrae with a metal rod and a piece of bone extracted from her pelvis. It also analyzes several art works done by Kahlo during her...

  • PSYCHOLOGICAL DISTRESS AND ASSOCIATED RISK FACTORS IN BRONCHIAL ASTHMA PATIENTS IN KUWAIT. Panicker, N. R.; Sharma, P. N.; Al-Duwaisan, A. R. // Indian Journal of Medical Sciences;Jan2008, Vol. 62 Issue 1, p1 

    CONTEXT: Recent literature shows a high prevalence of psychological distress in bronchial asthma. AIM: To find the extent of psychological distress and associated risk factors in bronchial asthma patients in Kuwait. DESIGN: Case-control study. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a study at Kuwait's...

  • More victims than meet the eye. Kenney, Linda K. // AAOS Now;Nov2011, Vol. 5 Issue 11, p35 

    The article presents the author's perspectives regarding the risk management approach to reduce impact of medical errors. The author cites the emotional impact of the adverse event of a total ankle replacement surgery she underwent, which also affect orthopaedic surgeon, anesthesiologists, and...

  • The Psychological Assessment of Risk for Crime and Violence. Hanson, R. Karl // Canadian Psychology;Aug2009, Vol. 50 Issue 3, p172 

    This article provides an overview of the current practices and challenges in psychological risk assessment for crime and violence. Risk assessments have improved considerably during the past 20 years. The dismal predictive accuracy of unstructured professional opinion has largely been replaced...

  • Assessing life stressors in relation to psychological problems among adolescents. Malhotra, Nalini; Himani // Indian Journal of Health & Wellbeing;2014, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p200 

    The purpose of the present research paper is to assess life stressors in relation to psychological problems among adolescents. Sample for the present research paper comprised 150 adolescents (75 Males / 75 Females) in the age range of 12 to 18 years from the various schools of Patiala district....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics