Analyzing the Relationship Between Organic and Sponsored Search Advertising: Positive, Negative, or Zero Interdependence?

Sha Yang; Ghose, Anindya
July 2010
Marketing Science;Jul/Aug2010, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p602
Academic Journal
The phenomenon of paid search advertising has now become the most predominant form of online advertising in the marketing world. However, we have little understanding of the impact of search engine advertising on consumers' responses in the presence of organic listings of the same firms. In this paper, we model and estimate the interrelationship between organic search listings and paid search advertisements. We use a unique panel data set based on aggregate consumer response to several hundred keywords over a three-month period collected from a major nationwide retailer store chain that advertises on Google. In particular, we focus on understanding whether the presence of organic listings on a search engine is associated with a positive, a negative, or no effect on the click-through rates of paid search advertisements, and vice versa for a given firm. We first build an integrated model to estimate the relationship between different metrics such as search volume, click-through rates, conversion rates, cost per click, and keyword ranks. A hierarchical Bayesian modeling framework is used and the model is estimated using Markov chain Monte Carlo methods. Our empirical findings suggest that click-throughs on organic listings have a positive interdependence with click-throughs on paid listings, and vice versa. We also find that this positive interdependence is asymmetric such that the impact of organic clicks on increases in utility from paid clicks is 3.5 times stronger than the impact of paid clicks on increases in utility from organic clicks. Using counterfactual experiments, we show that on an average this positive interdependence leads to an increase in expected profits for the firm ranging from 4.2% to 6.15% when compared to profits in the absence of this interdependence. To further validate our empirical results, we also conduct and present the results from a controlled field experiment. This experiment shows that total click-through rates, conversions rates, and revenues in the presence of both paid and organic search listings are significantly higher than those in the absence of paid search advertisements. The results predicted by the econometric model are also corroborated in this field experiment, which suggests a causal interpretation to the positive interdependence between paid and organic search listings. Given the increased spending on search engine-based advertising, our analysis provides critical insights to managers in both traditional and Internet firms.


Related Articles

  • Tribune site offering pay-per-click ads. Mullman, Jeremy // Crain's Chicago Business;2/27/2006, Vol. 29 Issue 9, p15 

    The article reports that the newspaper "Chicago Tribune," has started offering pay-per-click advertising on its Web site, Chicagotribune.com. Basically, the model is essentially the same as the one that helped morph Google Inc. into a $109-billion market cap colossus. The text-only...

  • Chasing Online Conversions.  // Folio: The Magazine for Magazine Management;May2005, Vol. 34 Issue 5, p25 

    Deals with pay-per-click advertising as a cost-effective way to drive online traffic. Percentage of the pay-per-click advertising market shared by the AdWords of Google and Overture.com of Yahoo!; Mechanism of pay-per-click as a marketing technique; Tips on benefiting from pay-per-click...

  • Offline impact. Hosford, Christopher // B to B;12/8/2008, Vol. 93 Issue 18, p16 

    The article focuses on econometric modeling, an emerging marketing discipline for measuring the interplay between analog and digital marketing. The concept is an analysis of past offline marketing campaigns, including such variables as messages, simultaneous campaigns, promotions and offers, and...

  • A Dashboard for Online Pricing. Baye, Michael R.; Gatti, J. Rupert J.; Kattuman, Paul; Morgan, John // California Management Review;Fall2007, Vol. 50 Issue 1, p202 

    The article discusses strategies for pricing products in the online marketplace. Although many theorists predicted that competition due to the Internet would force prices to level off to marginal cost, known as the law of one price, the experience of Internet retailers has shown that competitive...

  • Choice Words. Evans, David // Plastic Surgery Practice;Feb2012, Vol. 22 Issue 2, p10 

    The article discusses the pay-perclick (PPC) ads which are the most common types of paid advertisements on search engines in the U.S. It notes that ads are displayed when a keyword that can be purchased in a variety of ways matches the keyword list. It mentions the exact match which signifies...

  • Balancing pay-per-click and SEO efforts. SPENCER, STEPHAN // Multichannel Merchant (Penton Media, Inc.);Nov2011, Vol. 7 Issue 9, p10 

    The article describes instances in which cannibalization can occur between pay-per-click (PPC) and search engine optimization (SEO). One is the presence of only one or maybe no advertisement in the top premium position making organic listings more visible. Another is the prevalence of...

  • Fears over Google trademark bidding unfounded, say SEMs.  // New Media Age;5/15/2008, p04 

    The article reports that fears that Google's decision to allow trademark bidding would cost brands millions appear to be fading almost two weeks after the restrictions were lifted. British search engine marketing (SEM) specialists report that after an initia spike in costs per click (CPC) in the...

  • Tech Savers Online and Offline.  // Money Today;Aug2011, p17 

    The article features several online business tools that can be used by businesses to promote their products and services for free or at minimal cost. In the field of advertising, the most common model of online advertisement is the pay per click (PPC) model. The other models include the Google...

  • AFFILIATE MARKETING: Credit where it's due.  // Design Week (Online Edition);10/7/2011, p30 

    The article discusses the role of affiliates in promoting sales. Web analytics companies are now analyzing their contributions by comparing the proportion of online orders by an affiliate to the same figure for other marketing channels like Pay per click (PPC) and Search engine optimization...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics