Euthanasia: moral paradoxes

ten Have, H.
November 2001
Palliative Medicine;Nov2001, Vol. 15 Issue 6, p505
Academic Journal
Over the past 30 years, euthanasia has been under continuous debate in the Netherlands. This contribution aims to provide a moral assessment of this debate. It is argued that euthanasia should be understood within a historical context, as a protest against medical power and as a way to bring about good death. Within the euthanasia debate, two paradoxes are identified which make the issue inherently complex and hard to regulate. The first paradox results from the dialectical relation between individual autonomy and relief of suffering as the major justifications of euthanasia. Although euthanasia represents an ultimate effort to give the individual patient control over his dying, the result of the debate is an increase of medical power. The second paradox is that although euthanasia emerged from a commitment to good death, it is resulting in a reduced range of options to bring about good death.


Related Articles

  • Euthanasia across the North Sea. Rigter, Henk; Borst-Eilers, Els; Leenen, H.J.J. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);12/17/88, Vol. 297 Issue 6663, p1593 

    Examines the medical profession on euthanasia in Great Britain. Adequacy of good terminal care; Confusion in quality of care; Reflection of criminal act.

  • Report on the Royal Dutch Society of Medicine on `life-terminating actions with incompetent...  // Issues in Law & Medicine;Winter91, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p365 

    Presents the report of the Royal Dutch Society of Medicine (KNMG) on `life-terminating actions, with incompetent patients, part I: severely handicapped newborns.' How life-terminating actions occurred in neonatal intensive care practice; Reasons for terminating the life of severely handicapped...

  • Euthanasia: time for a royal commission. Smith, Richard // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/26/92, Vol. 305 Issue 6856, p728 

    Focuses on the issue related to euthanasia in Great Britain. Conviction of rheumatologist Nigel Cox for attempted murder after giving a terminally ill patient a lethal injection; Theological notions of euthanasia; Views of doctors regarding the issue.

  • How much is a hug? Fairhead, F.W. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/26/92, Vol. 305 Issue 6856, p780 

    Comments on the issue related to euthanasia in Europe. Acceptability of the practice; Role of doctors in the care of patients; Quality of life scale.

  • Let me eat cake…. Cameron, Amanda // New Zealand Doctor;7/28/2010, p3 

    The author discusses developments related to the field of general practice medicine in New Zealand including the debate over the issue of voluntary euthanasia, and the recognition received by the "New Zealand Doctor" periodical's front covers given by the Trade Association Business Publications...

  • Dutch doctors tighten euthanasia guidelines. Sheldon, Tony // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/16/95, Vol. 311 Issue 7007, p708 

    Reports on the updating of the Royal Dutch Medical Association's stand on euthanasia. Need to seek a second opinion; Emphasis on the need for doctors to discuss the subject with their patients.

  • Euthanasia: Can We Keep It a Special Case? Schneiderman, Lawrence J. // Humanist;May/Jun90, Vol. 50 Issue 3, p15 

    Discusses key aspects and policies pertaining to euthanasia. Theoretical and ethical aspects of the euthanasia; Ethics in medicine; Legal immunity for physicians who practice euthanasia.

  • LETTERS. Philipp, Robin; Pond, Kathy; Rees, Gareth; Smith, A.M.; Twycross, Robert; Gilbert, James; Madeley, Peter; Ventafridda, Vittorio; Thomson, Hugh J.; Ferguson, Andrew; Saunders, Peter J.; Finlay, Ilora G.; Norris, Peggy; Ward, Barney; Sim, Fiona; Sharp, J.C.M.; Hay, Ken // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);8/13/94, Vol. 309 Issue 6952, p471 

    Presents several letters related to medicine in the August 1994 issue of the 'British Medical Journal.' Reports on medical wastes found in coastlines of Great Britain; Issues on euthanasia; Information on depressive disorders.

  • CORRESPONDENCE. Davies, Jean; Griffiths, Richard W.; Godber, George; Slater, S.D.; McKillop, G.; Canning, G.; taylor, E.J.; Sulkava, Raimo; Erkinjuntti, Temo; Simenmwitz, Arnold; Bishop, Roy; Hower, Kenneth J.; Parker, D.J.P.; Remond, C.; Womersley, John; Gille, Charles; Hole, David J.; Jackson, John // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);7/9/88, Vol. 297 Issue 6641, p131 

    Presents several letters on medical practice. Views on euthanasia; Focus on the funding and patient care in Scotland; Occurrence of hyponatremia and uremia in the elderly.

  • NEWS.  // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/4/93, Vol. 307 Issue 6904, p581 

    Reports global developments related to medicine as of September 1993. Impact of electricity on epileptic seizures; Details on the decision of French mothers to support euthanasia of malformed babies; Accounts on the appointment of Lindsey Davies as head of the public health division.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics