A precautionary public health protection strategy for the possible risk of childhood leukaemia from exposure to power frequency magnetic fields

Maslanyj, Myron; Lightfoot, Tracy; Schüz, Joachim; Sienkiewicz, Zenon; McKinlay, Alastair
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p673
Academic Journal
Background: Epidemiological evidence showing a consistent association between the risk of childhood leukaemia and exposure to power frequency magnetic fields has been accumulating. This debate considers the additional precautionary intervention needed to manage this risk, when it exceeds the protection afforded by the exposure guidelines as recommended by the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection. Methods: The Bradford-Hill Criteria are guidelines for evaluating the scientific evidence that low frequency magnetic fields cause childhood leukaemia. The criteria are used for assessing the strength of scientific evidence and here have been applied to considering the strength of evidence that exposures to extremely low frequency magnetic fields may increase the risk of childhood leukaemia. The applicability of precaution is considered using the risk management framework outlined in a European Commission (EC) communication on the Precautionary Principle. That communication advises that measures should be proportionate, non-discriminatory, consistent with similar measures already taken, based on an examination of the benefits and costs of action and inaction, and subject to review in the light of new scientific findings. Results: The main evidence for a risk is an epidemiological association observed in several studies and metaanalyses; however, the number of highly exposed children is small and the association could be due to a combination of selection bias, confounding and chance. Corroborating experimental evidence is limited insofar as there is no clear indication of harm at the field levels implicated; however, the aetiology of childhood leukaemia is poorly understood. Taking a precautionary approach suggests that low-cost intervention to reduce exposure is appropriate. This assumes that if the risk is real, its impact is likely to be small. It also recognises the consequential cost of any major intervention. The recommendation is controversial in that other interpretations of the data are possible, and low-cost intervention may not fully alleviate the risk. Conclusions: The debate shows how the EC risk management framework can be used to apply the Precautionary Principle to small and uncertain public health risks. However, despite the need for evidence-based policy making, many of the decisions remain value driven and therefore subjective.


Related Articles


    The issue of the biological effect of electromagnetic fields (EMF) has been the subject of interest over one hundred years. Experts in this field agree that exposure to EMF at high levels induce adverse health effects, but their opinions vary on the point whether EMF at levels usually present in...

  • RIM SHOT TOPICS.  // National Underwriter / P&C;5/16/2011, Vol. 115 Issue 18, p12 

    The article offers news briefs related to property and casualty risk management such as Marshall Gilinski of Anderson Kill & Olick's statement regarding the minimal remediation costs involved in bedbug cases and Dan Glaser of Marsh & McLennan Cos.' view that supply-chain, cyber, and reputational...

  • RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE PROCUREMENT OF INNOVATION.  // Government News;Apr/May2012, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p41 

    The article defines risk management and discusses the five types of risks involved which includes technological risks, organizational and societal risks and market risks.

  • Risk management takes center stage. Wojcik, Joanne // Business Insurance;5/9/2011, Vol. 45 Issue 19, p6 

    The article reports on the increasing importance of risk management to companies in the U.S. in 2011.

  • Road manslaughter - or just the cost of progress? Mooren, Lori; Grzebieta, Raphael // Emerging Health Threats;2010, Vol. 3, p2 

    Much to the frustration of road safety researchers, practitioners and advocates, road deaths and injuries have not been widely accepted as a major public health threat. Currently, road trauma is one of the biggest killers and causes of serious and disabling injuries in the world. While there has...

  • Assessing Capacity. Easop, Edward // Canadian Underwriter;Dec2007, Vol. 74 Issue 12, p38 

    The author argues that principles-based solvency frameworks used in insurance must progress from a vision to actionable, detailed guidelines that provide a platform for solvency assessment in Canada. The Minimum Continuing Capital and Surplus Requirements (MCCSR) Advisory Committee (MAC)...

  • WHAT'S THE BIG IDEA? RISK APPETITE.  // Management Today;Jul/Aug2011, p14 

    The article discusses the aspects of risk management that a businessperson must consider including an observation and adjust risk assessments.

  • The hidden costs of risk. Cabot, Carollee // Fairfield County Business Journal;9/13/2004, Vol. 43 Issue 37, p42 

    Discusses the risks related to personal assets. Need to review the personal exposures one is facing; Importance of selecting the right risk management specialist; Concern on liability loss.

  • The Benefits of Investing in a Stronger ERM Program. Macpherson, Alistair // National Underwriter / P&C;4/16/2012, Vol. 116 Issue 12, p40 

    The article looks at the benefits of investing in an effective enterprise risk management (ERM) program and explains the coverage of ERM for the whole organization's sources of risk.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics