An overview of ethical frameworks in public health: can they be supportive in the evaluation of programs to prevent overweight?

ten Have, Marieke; de Beaufort, Inez D.; Mackenbach, Johan P.; van der Heide, Agnes
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p638
Academic Journal
Background: The prevention of overweight sometimes raises complex ethical questions. Ethical public health frameworks may be helpful in evaluating programs or policy for overweight prevention. We give an overview of the purpose, form and contents of such public health frameworks and investigate to which extent they are useful for evaluating programs to prevent overweight and/or obesity. Methods: Our search for frameworks consisted of three steps. Firstly, we asked experts in the field of ethics and public health for the frameworks they were aware of. Secondly, we performed a search in Pubmed. Thirdly, we checked literature references in the articles on frameworks we found. In total, we thus found six ethical frameworks. We assessed the area on which the available ethical frameworks focus, the users they target at, the type of policy or intervention they propose to address, and their aim. Further, we looked at their structure and content, that is, tools for guiding the analytic process, the main ethical principles or values, possible criteria for dealing with ethical conflicts, and the concrete policy issues they are applied to. Results: All frameworks aim to support public health professionals or policymakers. Most of them provide a set of values or principles that serve as a standard for evaluating policy. Most frameworks articulate both the positive ethical foundations for public health and ethical constraints or concerns. Some frameworks offer analytic tools for guiding the evaluative process. Procedural guidelines and concrete criteria for solving important ethical conflicts in the particular area of the prevention of overweight or obesity are mostly lacking. Conclusions: Public health ethical frameworks may be supportive in the evaluation of overweight prevention programs or policy, but seem to lack practical guidance to address ethical conflicts in this particular area.


Related Articles

  • Obesity, Health at Every Size, and Public Health Policy. Bombak, Andrea // American Journal of Public Health;Feb2014, Vol. 104 Issue 2, pe60 

    Obesity is associated with chronic diseases that may negatively affect individuals' health and the sustainability of the health care system. Despite increasing emphasis on obesity as a major health care issue, little progress has been made in its treatment or prevention. Individual approaches to...

  • Ethical decision-making in pharmacy. Bliss, Susan J. // Drug Topics;7/14/2008, Vol. 152 Issue 8, p46 

    The article discusses the professional ethics involved in practicing pharmacy in the U.S. It aims to provide pharmacists with a useful framework for making their own ethical decisions when faced with conflicts in patient care. It recommends pharmacists to be able to distinguish between ethics...

  • United States wins more time to lobby against WHO diet plan. Dyer, Owen // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);1/31/2004, Vol. 328 Issue 7434, p245 

    Reports on the disagreement between the United States and the World Health Organization (WHO) over the Organization's proposed "Global Strategy on Diet, Physical Activity, and Health." United States objection to the proposal on the grounds that it links high sugar intake to obesity; Letter from...

  • Ministers launch new battle of the bulge. Ward, Seamus // Public Finance;1/25/2008, p8 

    The article reports that British ministers have launched a new initiative against obesity. The government describes the strategy as a first step in its attempt to address the problem that could result in almost 60 percent of British adults being obese by 2050. Money or other financial rewards...

  • Cutting obstacles to healthy living is not nannying, says BMA. Ward, Seamus // Public Finance;7/16/2004, p10 

    Reports on the responsibility of the government to remove the barriers to healthier lifestyle according to the British Medical Association in Great Britain. Effectiveness of the laws on drink-driving safety belts; Need for government leadership on obesity and sexual health; Moral duty to ban...

  • ETHICAL ISSUES IN CLINICAL AND CULTURAL CONTEXT. AGHEORGHIESEI, DANIELA-TATIANA; PÂRVU, ANDRADA // Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai, Philosophia;Mar2013 Special Issue, Vol. 58, p5 

    An introduction to the journal is presented in which the editors discuss the broad spectrum of the theoretical and empirical research on the role of ethical issues and moral values in the realm of public health and health care policies in Romania.

  • PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN NATIONAL PREPAREDNESS AND RESPONSE PLANS FOR PANDEMIC INFLUENZA: TOWARDS AN ETHICAL CONTRIBUTION TO PUBLIC HEALTH POLICIES. Farmer, Yanick; Bouthillier, Marie-Ève; Dion-Labrie, Marianne; Durand, Céline; Doucet, Hubert // Ramon Llull Journal of Applied Ethics;2010, Issue 1, p9 

    Faced with the threat of pandemic influenza, several countries have made the decision to put a number of measures in place which have been incorporated into national plans. In view of the magnitude of the powers and responsibilities that States assume in the event of a pandemic, a review of the...

  • Medicine, Morality, and Mortality: The Challenges of Moral Diversity. CHERRY, MARK J. // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Oct2015, Vol. 40 Issue 5, p473 

    This issue of The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy assesses the deep and abiding tensions that exist among the competing epistemic perspectives that bear on medicine and morality. Concepts of health and disease, as well as the theoretical framing of medical ethics and health care policy,...

  • The Expressive Function of Public Health Policy: The Case of Pandemic Planning. Pierce, Robin // Public Health Ethics;Apr2011, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p53 

    Many legal scholars well recognize that, in some instances, support for a law or policy may be primarily because of its expressive function, i.e. the statements it makes about underlying values. In these cases, the expressive content of a law or policy may actually overshadow its central...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics