Low coverage but few inclusion errors in Burkina Faso: a community-based targeting approach to exempt the indigent from user fees

Ridde, Valéry; Haddad, Slim; Nikiema, Béatrice; Ouedraogo, Moctar; Kafando, Yamba; Bicaba, Abel
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p631
Academic Journal
Background: User fees were generalized in Burkina Faso in the 1990 s. At the time of their implementation, it was envisioned that measures would be instituted to exempt the poor from paying these fees. However, in practice, the identification of indigents is ineffective, and so they do not have access to care. Thus, a community-based process for selecting indigents for user fees exemption was tested in a district. In each of the 124 villages in the catchment areas of ten health centres, village committees proposed lists of indigents that were then validated by the health centres' management committees. The objective of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of this community-based selection. Methods: An indigent-selection process is judged effective if it minimizes inclusion biases and exclusion biases. The study compares the levels of poverty and of vulnerability of indigents selected by the management committees (n = 184) with: 1) indigents selected in the villages but not retained by these committees (n = 48); ii) indigents selected by the health centre nurses (n = 82); and iii) a sample of the rural population (n = 5,900). Results: The households in which the three groups of indigents lived appeared to be more vulnerable and poorer than the reference rural households. Indigents selected by the management committees and the nurses were very comparable in terms of levels of vulnerability, but the former were more vulnerable socially. The majority of indigents proposed by the village committees who lived in extremely poor households were retained by the management committees. Only 0.36% of the population living below the poverty threshold and less than 1% of the extremely poor population were selected. Conclusions: The community-based process minimized inclusion biases, as the people selected were poorer and more vulnerable than the rest of the population. However, there were significant exclusion biases; the selection was very restrictive because the exemption had to be endogenously funded.


Related Articles

  • Free clinic breaks barriers for poor kids in Hamilton. de Montalk, Jen // New Zealand Doctor;6/5/2013, p21 

    The article reports on the opening of the Parentline Family Health Centre which will provide free healthcare to vulnerable families in Hamilton, New Zealand on May 13, 2013.

  • A Place to Heal. Kiser, Kim // Minnesota Medicine;Feb2010, Vol. 93 Issue 2, p9 

    The article focuses on the development and establishment of medical respite center in Minnesota. It mentions that the development of these center is an initiative of Cathy ten Broeke, head at the End Homelessness office in Henneoin County, Minnesota. Broeke took this initiative after she found...

  • Non profit groups open health center.  // South Florida Times;11/26/2015, Vol. 25 Issue 48, p1B 

    The article reports that nonprofit groups Genesis Community Health and Boca Helping Hands, in a partnership are set to open a new medical center in downtown Boca Raton, Florida in order to serve the city's low income population.

  • Prevention and Solidarity. Jardim, Claudia // Monthly Review: An Independent Socialist Magazine;Jan2005, Vol. 56 Issue 8, p35 

    Discusses the democratization of public health in Venezuela. Impact of privatization and decentralization on public health facilities; Criticism of Venezuelan physicians for not attending to the needs of people in barrios; Justification of the rejection by the great majority of Venezuelan...

  • Tennessee's state funded health care faces crisis. Charatan, Fred // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);05/15/99, Vol. 318 Issue 7194, p1307 

    Reveals the severe budget crisis of faced by Tenncare, healthcare program for low income people in Tennessee. Reason the state withdrew from the federal Medicaid programme of feed for service payments; Proposal made by Governor Don Sundquist (R-Tenn.); Financial data of the program.

  • Community R.Ph.s in free Rx program for needy. Ukens, Carol // Drug Topics;8/22/94, Vol. 138 Issue 16, p24 

    Reports on a demonstration project that will provide free prescription drugs to indigent patients at community health centers nationwide. Sharing the Care program; Drugs contributed by Pfizer Inc.

  • UNDERGOING TRANSFORMATION TO THE PATIENT CENTERED MEDICAL HOME IN SAFETY NET HEALTH CENTERS: PERSPECTIVES FROM THE FRONT LINES. Quinn, Michael T.; Gunter, Kathryn E.; Nocon, Robert S.; Lewis, Sarah E.; Vable, Anusha M.; Hui Tang; Seo-Young Park; Casalino, Lawrence P.; Huang, Elbert S.; Birnberg, Jonathan; Burnet, Deborah L.; Summerfelt, W. Thomas; Chin, Marshall H. // Ethnicity & Disease;Summer2013, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p356 

    Objectives: Safety net health centers (SNHCs), which include federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) provide primary care for underserved, minority and low income patients. SNHCs across the country are in the process of adopting the patient centered medical home (PCMH) model, based on...

  • The Local Option. Buntin, John // Governing;Feb2010, Vol. 23 Issue 5, p26 

    The article reports on the actions taken by the local governments of Montgomery, Alabama to provide solutions to local health-care problems. It states that the city established a health clinic that will serve 25,000 low-income residents each year. It adds that Jackson Hospital donated a parcel...

  • Engaging Communities for Better Health Care Services. Cheriyan, George; Arya, Om Prakash // India Economy Review;Jan2011, Vol. 7, p118 

    The article examines the deficiencies of the medical services in India, most especially to its poor and vulnerable section. An elaboration on the three-tier structure of the Indian primary healthcare system, comprised by the Community Health Center (CHC), Primary Health Center (PHC) and its...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics