Response rates and selection problems, with emphasis on mental health variables and DNA sampling, in large population-based, crosssectional and longitudinal studies of adolescents in Norway

Bjertness, Espen; Sagatun, Åse; Green, Kristian; Lien, Lars; Søgaard, Anne Johanne; Selmer, Randi
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10, p602
Academic Journal
Background: Selection bias is a threat to the internal validity of epidemiological studies. In light of a growing number of studies which aim to provide DNA, as well as a considerable number of invitees who declined to participate, we discuss response rates, predictors of lost to follow-up and failure to provide DNA, and the presence of possible selection bias, based on five samples of adolescents. Methods: We included nearly 7,000 adolescents from two longitudinal studies of 18/19 year olds with two corresponding cross-sectional baseline studies at age 15/16 (10th graders), and one cross-sectional study of 13th graders (18/19 years old). DNA was sampled from the cheek mucosa of 18/19 year olds. Predictors of lost to follow-up and failure to provide DNA were studied by Poisson regression. Selection bias in the follow-up at age 18/19 was estimated through investigation of prevalence ratios (PRs) between selected exposures (physical activity, smoking) and outcome variables (general health, mental distress, externalizing problems) measured at baseline. Results: Out of 5,750 who participated at age 15/16, we lost 42% at follow-up at age 18/19. The percentage of participants who gave their consent to DNA provision was as high as the percentage that consented to a linkage of data with other health registers and surveys, approximately 90%. Significant predictors of lost to follow-up and failure to provide DNA samples in the present genetic epidemiological study were: male gender; non-western ethnicity; postal survey compared with school-based; low educational plans; low education and income of father; low perceived family economy; unmarried parents; poor self-reported health; externalized symptoms and smoking, with some differences in subgroups of ethnicity and gender. The association measures (PRs) were quite similar among participants and all invitees, with some minor discrepancies in subgroups of non-western boys and girls. Conclusions: Lost to follow-up had marginal impact on the estimated prevalence ratios. It is not likely that the invitation to provide DNA influenced the response rates of 18/19 year olds. Non-western ethnicity, male gender and characteristics related to a low social class and general and mental health problems measured at baseline are associated with lost to follow-up and failure to provide DNA.


Related Articles

  • The Designed Environment and How it Affects Brain Morphology and Mental Health. Golembiewski, Jan A. // Health Environments Research & Design Journal (HERD) (Sage Publi;Winter2016, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p161 

    Background: The environment is inextricably related to mental health. Recent research replicates findings of a significant, linear correlation between a childhood exposure to the urban environment and psychosis. Related studies also correlate the urban environment and aberrant brain...

  • Force in mental health services: international user and survivor perspective.  // Mental Health Practice;Feb2004, Vol. 7 Issue 5, p12 

    Addresses the issue of the use of force in mental health services in England. Perspectives of mental health users and survivors on the issue of force; History of user-survivor movements in coastal America and northern Europe; Agreement on the consequences behind the use of force; Culture of...

  • Overcoming Barriers to Collaboration Between Basic Behavioral Scientists and Public Health Scientists in Research on Mental Disorders. Muehrer, Peter R.; Salovey, Peter; Afifi, Abdelmonem A.; Coyne, James C.; Kring, Ann M.; Merson, Michael H.; Prohaska, Thomas R.; Rozensky, Ronald H. // Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings;Dec2002, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p253 

    The behavioral and public health sciences both have a long and rich history supporting basic, translational, and applied research aimed at improving human lives and reducing human suffering. Through the complementary expertise of these disciplines, investigators have contributed to significant,...

  • OPEN FORUM. Begum, Nasa // Community Care;10/13/2005, Issue 1594, p24 

    Focuses on the choices being given by health professionals to mental health patients in Great Britain. Treatment options offered by professionals to patients; Factors that influence professionals to resort to coercion when offering options to patients.

  • outside the box.  // Mental Health Today;Nov2005, p19 

    The article discusses the impact of the tendency among psychiatrists, psychologists and even teachers to believe that there are still large numbers of people with undiagnosed mental illness. It examines the implication of this tendency for public health and patients. The factors contributing to...

  • THE ROAD TO RECOVERY. Whitehouse, Chris // Community Care;1/8/2003, Issue 1453, p24 

    Focuses on the recovery approach to mental illness. Cycle of mental illness; Challenges of the approach for mental health practitioners and service users.

  • Mental Health Policy and Plans. Funk, Michelle; Saraceno, Benedetto; Drew, Natalie; Lund, Crick; Grigg, Margaret // International Journal of Mental Health;Summer2004, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p4 

    The World Health Report 2001 makes a compelling case for addressing the mental health needs of populations around the world. The key messages of the report are that mental disorders account for a significant burden of disease in all societies; effective interventions are available but are not...

  • Telephone Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Subthreshold Depression and Presenteeism in Workplace: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Furukawa, Toshi A.; Horikoshi, Masaru; Kawakami, Norito; Kadota, Masayo; Sasaki, Megumi; Sekiya, Yuki; Hosogoshi, Hiroki; Kashimura, Masami; Asano, Kenichi; Terashima, Hitomi; Iwasa, Kazunori; Nagasaku, Minoru; Grothaus, Louis C. // PLoS ONE;Apr2012, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p1 

    Background: Subthreshold depression is highly prevalent in the general population and causes great loss to society especially in the form of reduced productivity while at work (presenteeism). We developed a highly-structured manualized eight-session cognitive-behavioral program with a focus on...


    The author reflects on the treatment of serious mental illnesses such as schizophrenia, bipolar affective disorder in low and middle income (LAMI) countries. He asserts that the duration of untreated psychosis in LAMI countries, which is associated with poorer response to treatment, disability...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics