Temporal trends in misclassification patterns of measured and self-report based body mass index categories -- findings from three population surveys in Ireland

Shiely, Frances; Perry, Ivan J.; Lutomski, Jennifer; Harrington, Janas; Kelleher, C. Cecily; McGee, Hannah; Hayes, Kevin
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p560
Academic Journal
Background: As the use of self-reported data to classify obesity continues, the temporal change in the accuracy of self-report measurement when compared to clinical measurement remains unclear. The objective of this study was to examine temporal trends in misclassification patterns, as well as sensitivity and specificity, of clinically measured versus self-report based body mass index (BMI) from three national lifestyle surveys over a 10-year period. Methods: The Surveys of Lifestyle Attitudes and Nutrition (SLÁN) were interview based cross-sectional survey/ measurements involving nationally representative samples in 1998, 2002 and 2007. Data from a subsample of both self-reported and measured height and weight were available from 66 men and 142 women in 1998, 147 men and 184 women in 2002 and 909 men and 1128 women in 2007. Respondents were classified into the BMI categories normal (< 25 kg m-2), overweight (25- < 30 kg m-2) and obese (= 30 kg m-2). Results: Underreporting of BMI increased across the three surveys (14%→21%→24%; p = 0.002). Sensitivity scores for the normal category exceeded 94% in all three surveys but decreased for the overweight (75%→68%→66%) and obese categories (80%→64%→53%). Simultaneously, specificity levels remained high. Conclusions: BMI values based on self-reported determinations of height and weight in population samples are underestimating the true prevalence of the obesity epidemic and this underestimation is increasing with time. The decreased sensitivity and consistently high specificity scores in the obese category across time, highlights the limitation of self-report based BMI classifications and the need for simple, readily comprehensible indicators of obesity.


Related Articles

  • Obesity: a Review of Current Perspectives.  // Current Medical Literature: GH & Growth Factors;2003, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p53 

    Focuses on obesity perspectives. Definition; Prevalence; Sex prevalence; Co-morbidities; Pathophysiology; Genetic factors; Treatment; Surgical considerations.

  • CHILDHOOD OBESITY ON THE RISE. Reece, Beth // Soldiers;Nov2003, Vol. 58 Issue 11, p39 

    Reports on the incidence of obesity in the United States. Prevalence of obesity; Major causes of obesity; Health hazards associated with obesity.

  • The White Paper offers no choices. Neal, Julian // Medeconomics;Jan2005, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p21 

    This article presents information regarding a white paper issued by British government on health. In the White Paper, obesity is viewed as needing definitive guidance on prevention, identification, management and treatment and a comprehensive care pathway for its prevention and treatment is to...

  • Confronting the Epidemic: The Need for Global Solutions. Rigby, Neville J.; Kumanyika, Shiriki; James, W. Philip T. // Journal of Public Health Policy;2004, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p418 

    The epidemic of obesity is global and legal actions to stem the epidemic must become global. We address the prevalence of overweight and obesity: the scope and size of the epidemic, and how food marketing has aggravated the problem. The metabolic syndrome, a new feature of the epidemic now...

  • Editorial [Hot Topic:Dietary Determinants of the Metabolic Syndrome (Guest Editor: Luc Tappy Co-Editors: Jacques Delarue and Kim-Anne Le)]. Tappy, Luc; Delarue, Jacques; L�, Kim-Anne // Current Nutrition & Food Science;2007, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p109 

    Over the past decades, there has been a tremendous rise in the prevalence of obesity, not only in the westernized countries, but all over the world. Although it is well recognized that genetic factors are involved in obesity, this rapid rise is essentially to be attributed to environmental...

  • OBESITY -- Issues and Implications. Arnhold, Robert W.; Auxter, David A. // Palaestra;Winter2004, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p5 

    Focuses on issues and implications concerning obesity. Annual cost of obesity in the U.S.; Example of a Federal public policy initiative against obesity; Percentage of adults who are considered obese.

  • Pathways to obesity in a developing population: The Guangzhou Biobank Cohort Study. S Kavikondala; CM Schooling; CQ Jiang; WS Zhang; KK Cheng; TH Lam; GM Leung // International Journal of Epidemiology;Feb2009, Vol. 38 Issue 1, p72 

    Background ‘Environmental mismatch’ may contribute to obesity in rapidly developing societies, because poor early life conditions could increase the risk of obesity in a subsequently more socio-economically developed environment. In a recently developing population (from southern...

  • ADIPOQ Gene Variants Associated with Susceptibility to Obesity and Low Serum Adiponectin Levels in Healthy Koreans. Ji Wan Park; Jungyong Park; Sun Ha Jee // Epidemiology & Health;2011, Vol. 33, p1 

    OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to measure the association between the adiponectin, C1Q and collagen domain-containing (ADIPOQ) gene variants and obesity in Koreans. METHODS: Three single nucleotide polymorphisms located in the ADIPOQ gene were genotyped in a population-based cross-sectional study...

  • AUSTRALIA IN GRIP OF DIABETES EPIDEMIC: STUDY.  // New Vegetarian & Natural Health;Winter2006, p38 

    The article cites a study titled "Australian Diabetes, Obesity and Lifestyle Study," conducted by researchers in Australia which found that diabetes is caused by lifestyle factors including obesity and poor diet. The findings revealed that 270 out of 280 cases are developing every day throughout...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics