'Rumours' and clinical trials: a retrospective examination of a paediatric malnutrition study in Zambia, southern Africa

Kingori, Patricia; Muchimba, Maureen; Sikateyo, Bornwell; Amadi, Beatrice; Kelly, Paul
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p556
Academic Journal
Background: Many public health researchers conducting studies in resource-constrained settings have experienced negative 'rumours' about their work; in some cases they have been reported to create serious challenges and derail studies. However, what may appear superficially as 'gossip' or 'rumours' can also be regarded and understood as metaphors which represent local concerns. For researchers unaccustomed to having concerns expressed from participants in this manner, possible reactions can be to be unduly perturbed or conversely dismissive. This paper represents a retrospective examination of a malnutrition study conducted by an international team of researchers in Zambia, Southern Africa. The fears of mothers whose children were involved in the study and some of the concerns which were expressed as rumours are also presented. This paper argues that there is an underlying logic to these anxieties and to dismiss them simply as 'rumours' or 'gossip' would be to overlook the historic and socio-economic factors which have contributed to their production. Methods: Qualitative interviews were conducted with the mothers whose children were involved in the study and with the research nurses. Twenty five face-to-face interviews and 2 focus group discussions (FGDs) were conducted with mothers. In addition, face-to-face interviews were conducted with research nurses participating in the trial. Results: A prominent anxiety expressed as rumours by the mothers whose children were involved in the study was that recruitment into the trial was an indicator that the child was HIV-infected. Other anxieties included that the trial was a disguise for witchcraft or Satanism and that the children's body parts would be removed and sold. In addition, the liquid, milk-based food given to the children to improve their nutrition was suspected of being insufficiently nutritious, thus worsening their condition. The form which these anxieties took, such as rumours related to the stealing of body parts and other anxieties about a stigmatised condition, provide an insight into the historical, socio-economic and cultural influences in such settings. Conclusions: Employing strategies to understand local concerns should accompany research aims to achieve optimal success. The concerns raised by the participants we interviewed are not unique to this study. They are produced in countries where the historic, socio-economic and cultural settings communicate anxieties in this format. By examining this study we have shown that by contextualizing these 'rumours', the concerns they express can be constructively addressed and in turn result in the successful conduct of research aims.


Related Articles

  • Biochemical Tests for Assessing Subclinical Nutritional Deficiency. Whitehead, R. G. // Clinical Pediatrics;Sep1967, Vol. 6 Issue 9, p516 

    This article discusses biochemical tests for assessing subclinical nutritional deficiency. The severe forms of infantile protein malnutrition and undernutrition are characterized clinically as kwashiorkor and marasmus. But before these topics can be investigated, one must be able to detect with...

  • Longitudinal growth and post-discharge mortality and morbidity among extremely low birth weight neonates. Mukhopadhyay, Kanya; Louis, Deepak; Mahajan, Gagan; Mahajan, Rama // Indian Pediatrics;Sep2014, Vol. 51 Issue 9, p723 

    Objectives: To study post-discharge growth, mortality and morbidity of extremely low birth weight neonates at corrected age of 2 years. Methods: Weight, length and head circumference were compared on WHO growth charts at corrected ages 3 ( n=54), 6, 9, 12 ( n=51) and 24 months ( n=37); rates of...

  • prosopus varus.  // Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary;2005, p1787 

    A definition of the term "prosopus varus" is presented. The term is used to refer to the abnormality of the face. It is a congenital disorder in which the face is crooked or oblique and thus is a defect that occurs at birth. This abnormality of the face is caused by atrophy of one side of the...

  • Use of new World Health Organization child growth standards to assess how infant malnutrition relates to breastfeeding and mortality. Vesel, Linda; Bahl, Rajiv; Martines, Jose; Penny, Mary; Bhandari, Nita; Kirkwood, Betty R. // Bulletin of the World Health Organization;Jan2010, Vol. 88 Issue 1, p39 

    Objective To compare the estimated prevalence of malnutrition using the World Health Organization's (WHO) child growth standards versus the National Center for Health Statistics' (NCHS) growth reference, to examine the relationship between exclusive breastfeeding and malnutrition, and to...

  • Management of acute malnutrition in infants aged under 6 months (MAMI): Current issues and future directions in policy and research. Kerac, Marko; Mwangome, Martha; McGrath, Marie; Haider, Rukhsana; Berkley, James A. // Food & Nutrition Bulletin;Mar2015 Supplement, Vol. 36, pS30 

    Background. Globally, some 4.7 million infants aged under 6 months are moderately wasted and 3.8 million are severely wasted. Traditionally, they have been overlooked by clinicians, nutritionists, and policy makers. Objective. To present evidence and arguments for why treating acute malnutrition...

  • Maternal separation with early weaning: a novel mouse model of early life neglect. George, Elizabeth D.; Bordner, Kelly A.; Elwafi, Hani M.; Simen, Arthur A. // BMC Neuroscience;2010, Vol. 11, p123 

    Background: Childhood adversity is associated with increased risk for mood, anxiety, impulse control, and substance disorders. Although genetic and environmental factors contribute to the development of such disorders, the neurobiological mechanisms involved are poorly understood. A reliable...

  • Fatal flaw in baby formula sparks reform in Israeli ministry. Vikhanski, Luba // Nature Medicine;Jan2004, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p7 

    Reports on the German baby formula that caused severe vitamin deficiency in Israeli infants. Signs and symptoms on hospitalized babies; Essential roles in converting carbohydrates; Laboratory results for a formula's ingredients.

  • Key research on feeding of premature vulnerable babies.  // Infant;May2012, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p97 

    The article reports on the findings of a study published in the journal "Pediatrics" which focuses on the vulnerabilities in feeding premature babies in Great Britain.

  • Nutritional status and growth pattern of urban infants in relation to birth weight. Bisai, Samiran // Current Science (00113891);7/25/2008, Vol. 95 Issue 2, p175 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article on the continuing growth of malnourished infants in the developing countries published in the previous issue.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics