The Aristocracy of Labour and Working-Class Consciousness Revisited

Foster, John
December 2010
Labour History Review;Dec2010, Vol. 75 Issue 3, p245
Academic Journal
This article seeks to position the debate on the Labour Aristocracy, an important one during the early years of the Society for the Study of Labour History, within the wider controversies of the 1970s and 1980s on the future of the Labour Party and the adoption of post-modernist methodology. Its objective is to return discussion to the usage of the term as originally developed by Marx and Engels. This, it is argued, was not essentially about income differentials. Its central focus was on the active process of working-class formation and fragmentation. It assumed that working-class consciousness in the full sense was a historically rare though socially transformative phenomenon, usually constrained by the apparent inevitability of capitalist relations, and requiring a specific conjunctural analysis of working-class challenge and capitalist crisis and response. The article seeks to re-establish the validity of this approach using recent research on the Chartist movement and its decline. It takes issue with the interventions by Gareth Stedman Jones and argues for the continuing relevance of Marx's cultural analysis, as elaborated by David Harvey, for the understanding of social stereotyping and class fragmentation.


Related Articles

  • The fetishizing subject in Marx's Capital. Knafo, Samuel // Capital & Class;Spring2002, Vol. 26 Issue 76, p145 

    The article examines the subject, subjectivity and fetishism in Karl Marx conception of labor and capital. First, it discussed the economic perspective of Marx's capital and its contradictions. It then argued that fetishism should be viewed as a condition that reduces people to bearers of the...

  • MARXIST CLASS ANALYSIS: A LIVING TRADITION IN AUSTRALIAN SCHOLARSHIP. Barnes, Thomas; Cahill, Damien // Journal of Australian Political Economy;Summer2012/13, Issue 70, p47 

    The article examines the latest trajectory of class analysis in Australia within the context of criticism against the Marxist approach to class and changes within the capitalist economy and society some claim make Marxist class analysis redundant. It contends that these criticisms significantly...

  • Consciousness of Alienation. Woodfin, Rupert // Introducing Marxism;9/ 1/2004, p61 

    The article focuses on the theory of philosopher Karl Marx that workers will become conscious of their own alienation. The working-class proletariat is unaware that they have been alienated throughout the capitalist epoch. It cites the belief of Marx that humans are not in a proper relationship...

  • MARXISM AND INFORMAL LABOUR. Barnes, Thomas // Journal of Australian Political Economy;Summer2012/13, Issue 70, p144 

    The article explores keynote examples of how radical thinkers have tried to update and strengthen Marxist analysis and attempts to synthesise them into a framework for analysing changes to the composition of labour forces. It focuses on Global South where most of the world's workers live and...

  • On Marx's Dialectic of the Genesis of the Money Form. Robles-B�ez, Mario L. // International Journal of Political Economy;Fall97, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p35 

    The author of this article denies that Karl Marx imagined a mode of simple commodity production as a theoretical foil to his theory of capital. Marx's analysis is organized in terms of logical, not historical, categories; it is in part their failure to understand this that has led Carlo Benetti...

  • Marx and Keynes on Money. Campbell, Martha // International Journal of Political Economy;Fall97, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p65 

    The author of this article distinguishes between Karl Marx's argument that 'money as universal equivalent' is 'the necessary counterpart of private ownership' and 'the further specification that owners are divided into wage laborers and capitalists'. One virtue of the author's powerful argument...

  • Critique of Planned Obsolescence: Marx and Freud in Latin America. Bosteels, Bruno // Revista Hispánica Moderna (0034-9593);2011, Vol. 64 Issue 1, p23 

    The article presents an analysis regarding the views of various authors regarding the obsolesce of the Marxist theory in Latin America. It provides an overview of the important text of Álvaro García Linera, Vice-president of Bolivia, which tackles the works and politics of Karl Marx....

  • MARX FOR THE 21st CENTURY A REVIEW ARTICLE. Baksi, Pradip // World Review of Political Economy;Jun2011, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p307 

    Marx for the 21st Century, a collection of 14 essays by Japanese scholars, is not only about the relevance of Marx today, but also about Marx Studies, Marx-reception and Marxology in Japan. The themes, thinkers and texts discussed in this volume include: modernity, socialism, theory of history,...

  • Marx is Back, But Which One? On Knowledge Labour and Media Practice. Mosco, Vincent // TripleC (Cognition, Communication, Co-Operation): Open Access Jo;2012, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p570 

    The global economic crisis has led to a resurgence of interest in the work of Karl Marx. This paper acknowledges this interest, but asks on which of the many shades of Marx, communication scholars should be focusing their research attention. The most general answer is all of Marx, from the early...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics