If Psychology Refuses to Police Itself, Then It May Be the Courts That Force an Overhaul of Clinical Psychology

Stein, David B.; Foltz, Robert
July 2010
Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p99
Academic Journal
From its inception, psychology has sought recognition as a science, but, unfortunately, this is not happening, especially in the clinical arena. It is all too often referred to as "junk science." Eloquent arguments are constantly made defending psychology as different because it is dealing with unknowns, such as the mind and the soul. However, the fact remains that psychology is not progressing well, with extremely poor treatment efficacy rates and with its tenacious clinging to psychological tests that are repeatedly shown to be unreliable and invalid. Thus, psychology is not policing itself. However, change and reformation may be forced on it because the federal courts and 33 state courts have based new laws for more rigorous standards for trial testimony, and it appears that the new laws are aimed at cleansing the courts of "junk science," namely, psychological testimony. This article reviews the changes that thus far few psychologists, lawyers, or even judges know about. However, slowly the new laws will permeate the courts and perhaps exert a strong influence for psychology to adapt.


Related Articles

  • Is It Time to Move On?  // Psychology Today;Nov/Dec2006, Vol. 39 Issue 6, p24 

    The article offers advice on when to end sessions with a therapist. It cites the approach that can be taken to measure the progress of the therapy. Patients should end sessions when the conversations are beginning to be repetitive. It is important to take a break to integrate the work that have...

  • Psychiatry for all. Bridges, P. K. // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Nov1984, Vol. 77 Issue 11, p911 

    The article reflects on the controversy about the medical model in the context of psychiatry. It cites the antagonism expressed by two psychologists regarding the model. The medical model is the basis of what can be called psychiatry for all. It states that social and other stresses may...

  • Psychology.  // Science...Non-Fiction;2005, p188 

    The article presents a list of topics about psychology published within the issue. They include notable psychologists and the science of psychology and psychiatry.

  • Response to Cohen, and Steele, Borner, and Roberts. Palermo, Tonya M.; Mullins, Larry L.; Janicke, David M.; McQuaid, Elizabeth L.; Robins, Paul M.; Wu, Yelena P. // Journal of Pediatric Psychology;Oct2014, Vol. 39 Issue 9, p998 

    Two letters to the editor are presented in response to articles in the previous issues including "Competencies in pediatric psychology: polishing Pandora's box" and "Finding the middle bowl: Goldilocks' lessons on professional competencies."

  • Prescription privileges: A dearth of confidence in psychological interventions. Piotrowski, Chris // Psychological Reports;Apr96, Vol. 78 Issue 2, p362 

    Argues that psychologists' lack of self-confidence is the central influence on the perceived efficacy of psychotropic medications relative to psychological interventions. Rating of antipsychotics, antidepressants and tranquilizers in terms of soundness of treatment; Effect of the prescription...

  • GUEST EDITOR. Petzold, Mathias // Chinese Sociology & Anthropology;Winter80/81, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p3 

    The article reports that main activity of Chinese psychologists is investigating child development and educational processes. Of the 800 to 1,000 academically qualified psychologists in the People's Republic of China, about two-thirds are engaged in this psychological specialty. As we have...

  • CAREERS IN PSYCHOLOGY: Which would you choose?  // Monkeyshines on Health & Science;Dec97 Psychology, p27 

    Clinical Psychologist deals with the study, diagnosis, and treatment of abnormal behavior. Some clinical psychologists are trained to diagnose and treat the common crises of life, while others research and investigate more complicated and serious mental conditions. Cognitive Psychologist covers...

  • Counseling and Development: Toward a New Identity for a Profession in Transition. Van Hesteren, Frank; Ivey, Allen E. // Journal of Counseling & Development;May/Jun90, Vol. 68 Issue 5, p524 

    The time has come for counseling and development to claim its space as a first-class profession in its own right--a profession distinct from but incorporating important aspects of the related professional disciplines of counseling psychology, clinical psychology, and social work. In order for...

  • When One Plus One Equals Three: The Role of Relationships and Context in Community Research. Brodsky, Anne E.; Senuta, Kathleen Rogers; Weiss, Catharine L. A.; Marx, Christine M.; Loomis, Colleen; Arteaga, S. Sonia; Moore, Heidi; Benhorin, Rona; Castagnera-Fletcher, Alisha // American Journal of Community Psychology;Jun2004, Vol. 33 Issue 3/4, p229 

    This paper explores the role of relationships within and between the community of the researchers and the community of the research participants, as they relate to qualitative, community psychology research. Although relationships are salient to all research, their role is particularly prominent...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics