Who Is Punished? Regional Intergovernmental Organizations and the Enforcement of Democratic Norms

Donno, Daniela
October 2010
International Organization;Fall2010, Vol. 64 Issue 4, p593
Academic Journal
Scholars have found an association between membership in regional intergovernmental organizations (IGOs) and democracy, and IGO enforcement is often credited as an important factor explaining this link. But empirical evidence reveals great variation in whether these organizations actually respond to violations of democratic norms, even in democratic regions. Why do IGOs punish some norm-violating countries but not others? What does this variation imply for theories about how IGO membership helps states make credible commitments? This article presents a theoretical framework for understanding variation in multilateral norm enforcement. It identifies two obstacles to enforcement—the presence of competing geopolitical interests and uncertainty about the nature and scope of norm violations—and it argues that international monitoring can help mitigate these obstacles by revealing and publicizing information that pressures reluctant member states to support enforcement. An original data set of democracy enforcement in Latin America and postcommunist countries is used to examine regional IGO enforcement in response to one prevalent type of democratic norm violation: electoral misconduct. I find that enforcement is less likely in countries of high geopolitical importance, but the presence of election observers increases the probability of enforcement, and the content of observers' reports influences the type of enforcement that is imposed. These findings suggest that the link between IGO membership, credible commitments, and democracy should be theorized and tested as a conditional relationship, depending on country- and incident-specific factors that influence the likelihood of enforcement.


Related Articles

  • Managed news is bad news.  // Prague Business Journal;4/28/2003, Vol. 8 Issue 16, p10 

    Criticizes the authorities' control of information concerning the issue of the Czech Republic's entry to the European Union. Alleged reason behind the news management policy; Economic benefits of the membership to the country.

  • EU pact brings harmonization crunch. Zegnal, Judit; Csonka, Agnes; Simon, Zoltan // Budapest Business Journal;4/21/2003, Vol. 11 Issue 19, p1 

    Reports on the challenges facing Hungary in relation to the country's European Union (EU) membership. Economic implication of the membership on the nation; Changes that should be made in the country's legal system to fit the EU.

  • Cheerleaders.  // Budapest Business Journal;4/21/2003, Vol. 11 Issue 19, p21 

    Comments on Hungary's European Union (EU) accession. Challenges that will be encountered by the country in relation to the membership; Economic implications of the membership; Steps that should be taken by government officials and the public to maximize the benefits that can be provided by the...

  • Entering the Path of Transformation in Europe: The Federal Legacy of the Schuman Declaration. Burgess, Michael // French Politics, Culture & Society;Summer2011, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p4 

    The purpose of the article is to establish and assess the significance of the federal legacy of the Schuman Declaration (9 May 1950) in the evolution of postwar European integration. To this end it provides a sharp focus upon the political strategy of Jean Monnet and his active role in promoting...

  • AB ile Entegrasyon S�recinin T�rkiye'de Siyasal Sistem �zerindeki Etkileri. Nas, �igdem // Journal of Academic Studies;Nov2004-Jan2005, Vol. 6 Issue 23, p45 

    The process of European integration exerts multi-faceted influences on the concerned countries. Several European countries take part in this process either as members of the EU, candidates for EU membership or in the framework of a more limited relationship such as association. The integration...

  • Yeni Komsuluk Politikasi'nin Avrupa Birligi (AB)-Rusya Iliskilerine Etkisi. Hatipoglu, Esra // Journal of Academic Studies;Nov2004-Jan2005, Vol. 6 Issue 23, p95 

    The New Neighbourhood Policy as it is perceived today is a policy which is developed to help the EU to find this "third way"-not to enlarge further eastwards but at the same time not to close the doors to bordering countries. As for Russia, the EU appears to be facing a thorny dilemma. On the...

  • Foreign Relations. Coleman, Denise Youngblood // Dominica Country Review;2013, p54 

    The article provides information on the foreign relations of Dominica, including its consular mission in several countries and regional organizations in which Dominica holds membership.

  • The world: Euro-mice roar.  // BRW;10/9/2003, Vol. 25 Issue 39, p15 

    Reports on European Union member states' plan to raise the question of the allocation of seats in the European Parliament during the talks that will start on October 4, 2003.

  • Editor's note.  // Diplomatic Insight;Dec2015, Vol. 8 Issue 12, p6 

    The author discusses the role of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), a regional organisation formed during the breakup of the Soviet Union, aimed at being more than a purely symbolic organization, possessing coordinating powers in the realm of trade, finance, lawmaking, and security.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics