Mancuso, Peter A.
August 2010
Albany Law Review;2010, Vol. 73 Issue 3, p1019
Academic Journal
The article analyzes the dissenting opinions of Judge Robert S. Smith of the New York Court of Appeals. From January 2004 to January 2010, Smith wrote more than 65 dissenting options covering various areas of New York law. It examines Smith's jurisprudential philosophy on specific areas of civil law. Some categories of law covered by Smith in his dissenting opinions are discussed, including workers' rights, tax law and commercial law.


Related Articles

  • THE CALCULUS OF DISSENT: A STUDY OF APPELLATE DIVISION. La Valley III, Joseph C. // Albany Law Review;2001, Vol. 64 Issue 4, p1405 

    Examines New York Appellate Division justices' dissenting opinions on constitutional issues. Analysis on the Appellate Division criminal caseloads from 1990 to 2000; Steps that describe the research plan used to obtain the data for identifying individual justices' voting patterns; Conclusions.

  • When, and when not, to dissent. Keefe, Arthur John // American Bar Association Journal;Jun80, Vol. 66 Issue 6, p795 

    Discusses the report 'Cogitations on Appellate Decision-Making,' by United States judge Hugh R. Jones. Presentation of the report during the 35th annual Benjamin N. Cardozo lecture at the Association of the Bar of the City of New York; Insights on Jones' decision-making style; Views on writing...

  • Dissent Permitted: Texas appellate judge wins lawsuit against colleagues. Hansen, Mark // ABA Journal;Dec92, Vol. 78 Issue 12, p33 

    Reports that Texas appellate judge Michol O'Connor won a lawsuit against her colleagues when the state supreme court ruled that First Court of Appeals in Houston was wrong to prevent O'Connor from filing a dissent in a case the full court refused to hear. Duty of the court of appeals under the...

  • Motherless Child OK'd by Maryland High Court (on Birth Certificate); Neither Gestational Mother nor Egg Donor Need Be Named. Jacobs, Alan J. // Lesbian -- Gay Law Notes;Jun2007, p100 

    The article states that the Maryland Court of Appeals ruled in the case, In re Roberto d. B, that the name of the gestational mother or egg donor is not required on birth certificates and can be omitted according to the mother's wishes. The sections of the state statute regarding parentage on a...

  • Dissenting New York Appellate Judge Continues Campaign Against Judicial Limitation on Emotional Distress Damages in HIV Exposure Cases. Benecke, Chris // Lesbian -- Gay Law Notes;Jun2007, p111 

    The article discusses the award which was given to the plaintiff, Vanessa Sims, for post-traumatic stress disorder and possible HIV infection from a contaminated needle in the case, Sims v. Comprehensive Community Development Corp. Justice Catterson criticized the six-month limit on emotional...

  • . . . Encouraging Crime, Hazards Repugnant to Act--Dissent.  // Labor Law Journal;May73, Vol. 24 Issue 5, p310 

    The article reports on the dissenting opinion of two United States National Labor Relations Board members regarding the discharge of a truck driver for refusing to drive an overweight truck. The two members concluded that the driver was unlawfully discharged on the grounds that such trucks cause...

  • Competing With Employees. Holoubek, Charles; Gordon, Steve // Business NH Magazine;Oct2007, Vol. 24 Issue 10, p17 

    The article discusses the Non-Compete Agreement, particularly in the New Hampshire Law. It is stated that the NCA limits the employees' ability to leave their jobs after being trained and exposed. However, it is found that many NCAs provide false hope to those who rely on its integrity. In NH,...

  • Different Strokes for Different Folks: Balancing the Treatment of Employers and Employees in Employment Discrimination Cases in Courts within the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. Arredondo, Ruben H. // BYU Journal of Public Law;2002, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p261 

    Investigates the treatment of employers and employees in employment discrimination cases in courts within the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. Description of federal anti-discrimination acts; Facts, procedural background, and holdings of three cases within the Tenth Circuit; Argument that the...

  • Comment. Lehman, Walter M.; Hemmings, Charles L.; Avakian, Spurgeon // California Law Review;Jul37, Vol. 25 Issue 5, p565 

    Presents commentaries on various cases in the U.S. Effect of cross-complaint on right to trial jury; Laws applicable in an action for a deficiency judgment outside the state of situs; Range of unfair labor practices involved in Supreme Court cases under the National Labor Relations Act.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics