The Eat Smart Study: A randomised controlled trial of a reduced carbohydrate versus a low fat diet for weight loss in obese adolescents

Truby, Helen; Baxter, Kimberley A.; Barrett, Paula; Ware, Robert S.; Cardinal, John C.; Davies, Peter S. W.; Daniels, Lynne A.; Batch, Jennifer A.
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p464
Academic Journal
Background: Despite the recognition of obesity in young people as a key health issue, there is limited evidence to inform health professionals regarding the most appropriate treatment options. The Eat Smart study aims to contribute to the knowledge base of effective dietary strategies for the clinical management of the obese adolescent and examine the cardiometablic effects of a reduced carbohydrate diet versus a low fat diet. Methods and design: Eat Smart is a randomised controlled trial and aims to recruit 100 adolescents over a 2 ½ year period. Families will be invited to participate following referral by their health professional who has recommended weight management. Participants will be overweight as defined by a body mass index (BMI) greater than the 90th percentile, using CDC 2000 growth charts. An accredited 6-week psychological life skills program 'FRIENDS for Life', which is designed to provide behaviour change and coping skills will be undertaken prior to volunteers being randomised to group. The intervention arms include a structured reduced carbohydrate or a structured low fat dietary program based on an individualised energy prescription. The intervention will involve a series of dietetic appointments over 24 weeks. The control group will commence the dietary program of their choice after a 12 week period. Outcome measures will be assessed at baseline, week 12 and week 24. The primary outcome measure will be change in BMI z-score. A range of secondary outcome measures including body composition, lipid fractions, inflammatory markers, social and psychological measures will be measured. Discussion: The chronic and difficult nature of treating the obese adolescent is increasingly recognised by clinicians and has highlighted the need for research aimed at providing effective intervention strategies, particularly for use in the tertiary setting. A structured reduced carbohydrate approach may provide a dietary pattern that some families will find more sustainable and effective than the conventional low fat dietary approach currently advocated. This study aims to investigate the acceptability and effectiveness of a structured reduced dietary carbohydrate intervention and will compare the outcomes of this approach with a structured low fat eating plan. Trial Registration: The protocol for this study is registered with the International Clinical Trials Registry (ISRCTN49438757).


Related Articles

  • Living Well with Diabetes: a randomized controlled trial of a telephone-delivered intervention for maintenance of weight loss, physical activity and glycaemic control in adults with type 2 diabetes. Eakin, Elizabeth G.; Reeves, Marina M.; Marshall, Alison L.; Dunstan, David W.; Graves, Nicholas; Healy, Genevieve N; Bleier, Jonathan; Barnett, Adrian G.; O'Moore-Sullivan, Trisha; Russell, Anthony; Wilkie, Ken // BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p452 

    Background: By 2025, it is estimated that approximately 1.8 million Australian adults (approximately 8.4% of the adult population) will have diabetes, with the majority having type 2 diabetes. Weight management via improved physical activity and diet is the cornerstone of type 2 diabetes...

  • What is the quality of reporting in weight loss intervention studies? A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Thabane, L.; Chu, R.; Cuddy, K.; Douketis, J. // International Journal of Obesity;Oct2007, Vol. 31 Issue 10, p1554 

    Background:Despite the large number of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) assessing weight loss interventions, no study has assessed the quality of reporting in these trials.Purpose:To assess the quality of reporting of RCTs of weight loss interventions and to identify predictors of reporting...

  • Weight Regain Prevention. Ulen, Christina Garcia; Huizinga, Mary Margaret; Beech, Bettina; Elasy, Tom A. // Clinical Diabetes;Summer2008, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p100 

    The article offers information on weight loss maintenance strategies. Systematic reviews of behavioral and diet based weight loss treatments show that continued therapy is essential for minimizing weight regain after weight loss. It analyzes the weight loss maintenance programs and highlights...

  • Recruiting older people to a randomised controlled dietary intervention trial - how hard can it be? Forster, Sarah E.; Jones, Laura; Saxton, John M.; Flower, Daniel J.; Foulds, Gemma; Powers, Hilary J.; Parker, Stuart G.; Pockley, A. Graham; Williams, Elizabeth A. // BMC Medical Research Methodology;2010, Vol. 10, p17 

    Background: The success of a human intervention trial depends upon the ability to recruit eligible volunteers. Many trials fail because of unrealistic recruitment targets and flawed recruitment strategies. In order to predict recruitment rates accurately, researchers need information on the...

  • Relationship Between Treatment Preference and Weight Loss in the Context of a Randomized Controlled Trial. Borradaile, Kelley E.; Halpern, Scott D.; Wyatt, Holly R.; Klein, Samuel; Hill, James O.; Bailer, Brooke; Brill, Carrie; Stein, Richard I.; Miller III, Bernard V.; Foster, Gary D. // Obesity (19307381);Jun2012, Vol. 20 Issue 6, p1218 

    Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are considered the gold standard used to assess the efficacy of treatment. While a well implemented RCT can produce an unbiased estimate of the relative difference between treatment groups, the generalizability of these findings may be limited. Specific...

  • Diet or Exercise, It's Calories That Count.  // Tufts University Health & Nutrition Letter;Apr2007, Vol. 25 Issue 2, p1 

    The article looks at a study which suggests that cutting calories and exercising more are both equally effective for losing weight. According to the article, the study seemed to debunk the notions that you can "spot reduce," or choose where the pounds come off on your body, and that dieting...

  • Commercial weight loss diets meet nutrient requirements in free living adults over 8 weeks: A randomised controlled weight loss trial. Truby, Helen; Hiscutt, Rebecca; Herriot, Anne M.; Stanley, Manana; deLooy, Anne; Fox, Kenneth R.; Baic, Susan; Robson, Paula J.; Macdonald, Ian; Taylor, Moira A.; Ware, Robert; Logan, Catherine; Livingstone, M. B. E. // Nutrition Journal;2008, Vol. 7, Special section p1 

    Objective: To investigate the effect of commercial weight loss programmes on macronutrient composition and micronutrient adequacy over a 2 month period. Design: Adults were randomly allocated to follow the Slim Fast Plan, Weight Watchers Pure Points Programme, Dr Atkins' New Diet Revolution, or...

  • The effect of very low-calorie diets on renal and hepatic outcomes: a systematic review. Rolland, Catherine; Mavroeidi, Alexandra; Johnston, Kelly L.; Broom, John // Diabetes, Metabolic Syndrome & Obesity: Targets & Therapy;2013, Vol. 6, p393 

    Very low-calorie diets (VLCDs) are an effective means by which to induce clinically significant weight loss. However, their acceptance by health care practitioners and the public is generally lower than that for other nonsurgical weight loss methods. Whilst there is currently little evidence to...

  • How much loss to follow-up is acceptable in long-term randomised trials and prospective studies? Fewtrell, Mary S.; Kennedy, Kathy; Singhal, Atul; Martin, Richard M.; Ness, Andy; Hadders-Algra, Mijna; Koletzko, Berthold; Lucas, Alan // Archives of Disease in Childhood;Jun2008, Vol. 93 Issue 6, p458 

    The article presents a research which considers the statistical implications of attrition in both the randomized controlled trials (RCT) and cohort studies to identify the most effective ways of dealing with attrition when analyzing and reporting studies. It discusses the factors influencing...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics