Trashing life’s tree

Franklin-Hall, L. R.
September 2010
Biology & Philosophy;Sep2010, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p689
Academic Journal
The Tree of Life has traditionally been understood to represent the history of species lineages. However, recently researchers have suggested that it might be better interpreted as representing the history of cellular lineages, sometimes called the Tree of Cells. This paper examines and evaluates reasons offered against this cellular interpretation of the Tree of Life. It argues that some such reasons are bad reasons, based either on a false attribution of essentialism, on a misunderstanding of the problem of lineage identity, or on a limited view of scientific representation. I suggest that debate about the Tree of Cells and other successors to the traditional Tree of Life should be formulated in terms of the purposes these representations may serve. In pursuing this strategy, we see that the Tree of Cells cannot serve one purpose suggested for it: as an explanation for the hierarchical nature of taxonomy. We then explore whether, instead, the tree may play an important role in the dynamic modeling of evolution. As highly-integrated complex systems, cells may influence which lineage components can successfully transfer into them and how they change once integrated. Only if they do in fact have a substantial role to play in this process might the Tree of Cells have some claim to be the Tree of Life.


Related Articles

  • Lifeness signatures and the roots of the tree of life. Malaterre, Christophe // Biology & Philosophy;Sep2010, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p643 

    Do trees of life have roots? What do these roots look like? In this contribution, I argue that research on the origins of life might offer glimpses on the topology of these very roots. More specifically, I argue (1) that the roots of the tree of life go well below the level of the commonly...

  • The tree of life: introduction to an evolutionary debate. O'Malley, Maureen A.; Martin, William; Dupré, John // Biology & Philosophy;Sep2010, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p441 

    The ‘Tree of Life’ is intended to represent the pattern of evolutionary processes that result in bifurcating species lineages. Often justified in reference to Darwin’s discussions of trees, the Tree of Life has run up against numerous challenges especially in regard to...

  • Evolution and migration history of the Chinese population inferred from Chinese Y-chromosome evidence. Wei Deng; Baochen Shi; Xiaoli He; Zhihua Zhang; Jun Xu; Bioa li; Jian Yang; Lunjiang Ling; Chengping Dai; Boqin Qiang; Yan Shen; Runsheng Chen // Journal of Human Genetics;2004, Vol. 49 Issue 7, p339 

    Y-chromosomes from 76 Chinese men covering 33 ethnical minorities throughout China as well as the Han majority were collected as genetic material for the study of Chinese nonrecombinant Y-chromosome (NRY) phylogeny. Of the accepted worldwide NRY haplogroups, three (haplogroups D, C, O) were...

  • Palpitomonas bilix represents a basal cryptist lineage: insight into the character evolution in Cryptista. Akinori Yabuki; Ryoma Kamikawa; Sohta A. Ishikawa; Martin Kolisko; Eunsoo Kim; Akifumi S. Tanabe; Keitaro Kume; Ken-ichiro Ishida; Yuji Inagki // Scientific Reports;4/11/2014, p1 

    Phylogenetic position of the marine biflagellate Palpitomonas bilix is intriguing, since several ultrastructural characteristics implied its evolutionary connection to Archaeplastida or Hacrobia. The origin and early evolution of these two eukaryotic assemblages have yet to be fully elucidated,...

  • First cell. Zimmer, Carl // Discover;Nov95, Vol. 16 Issue 11, p70 

    Focuses on research findings on the origins of life through cellular evolution by biophysicist David Deamer. Theories, origins and formation of DNA nucleotide patterns; Formation of cell membranes to facilitate the chemical process in the creation of organic compounds; Deamer's experiments and...

  • Pattern Cladism, Homology, and Theory-Neutrality. Pearson, Christopher H. // History & Philosophy of the Life Sciences;2010, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p475 

    Pattern cladists purport to classify biological taxa in a way that is theory-neutral. The idea of a theory-neutral science is, however, philosophically problematic; and, while pattern cladists' commitment to theory-neutrality has been subject to scrutiny by both phylogenetic cladists and some...

  • Evolved RNA Secondary Structure and the Rooting of the Universal Tree of Life. Caetano-Anollés, Gustavo // Journal of Molecular Evolution;Mar2002, Vol. 54 Issue 3, p333 

    The origin and diversification of RNA secondary structure were traced using cladistic methods. Structural components were coded as polarized and ordered multi-state characters, following a model of character state transformation outlined by considerations in statistical mechanics. Several...

  • Can Children Read Evolutionary Trees? Ainsworth, Shaaron; Saffer, Jessica // Merrill-Palmer Quarterly;Apr2013, Vol. 59 Issue 2, p221 

    Representations of the "tree of life" such as cladograms show the history of lineages and their relationships. They are increasingly found in formal and informal learning settings. Unfortunately, there is evidence that these representations can be challenging to interpret correctly. This study...

  • Biomechanical Consequences of Rapid Evolution in the Polar Bear Lineage. Slater, Graham J.; Figueirido, Borja; Louis, Leeann; Yang, Paul; Van Valkenburgh, Blaire // PLoS ONE;2010, Vol. 5 Issue 11, p1 

    The polar bear is the only living ursid with a fully carnivorous diet. Despite a number of well-documented craniodental adaptations for a diet of seal flesh and blubber, molecular and paleontological data indicate that this morphologically distinct species evolved less than a million years ago...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics