Testing for treeness: lateral gene transfer, phylogenetic inference, and model selection

Velasco, Joel D.; Sober, Elliott
September 2010
Biology & Philosophy;Sep2010, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p675
Academic Journal
phylogeny that allows for lateral gene transfer (LGT) can be thought of as a strictly branching tree (all of whose branches are vertical) to which lateral branches have been added. Given that the goal of phylogenetics is to depict evolutionary history, we should look for the best supported phylogenetic network and not restrict ourselves to considering trees. However, the obvious extensions of popular tree-based methods such as maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood face a serious problem—if we judge networks by fit to data alone, networks that have lateral branches will always fit the data at least as well as any network that restricts itself to vertical branches. This is analogous to the well-studied problem of overfitting data in the curve-fitting problem. Analogous problems often have analogous solutions and we propose to treat network inference as a case of model selection and use the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC). Strictly tree-like networks are more parsimonious than those that postulate lateral as well as vertical branches. This leads to the conclusion that we should not always infer LGT events whenever it would improve our fit-to-data, but should do so only when the improved fit is larger than the penalty for adding extra lateral branches.


Related Articles

  • Studies in the tribe Spermacoceae (Rubiaceae-Rubioideae): the circumscriptions of Amphiasma and Pentanopsis and the affinities of Phylohydrax. Thulin, M.; Bremer, B. // Plant Systematics & Evolution;Aug2004, Vol. 247 Issue 3/4, p233 

    Phylogenetic analysis of rbcL cpDNA sequences for 34 members of the tribe Spermacoceae s. lat. indicates that the African genera Amphiasma, Conostomium, Manostachya, Pentanopsis and Phylohydrax form a strongly supported clade, characterised by basal placentation and heterostyly. This is a new...

  • On the Inference of Large Phylogenies with Long Branches: How Long Is Too Long? Mossel, Elchanan; Roch, Sébastien; Sly, Allan // Bulletin of Mathematical Biology;Jul2011, Vol. 73 Issue 7, p1627 

    The accurate reconstruction of phylogenies from short molecular sequences is an important problem in computational biology. Recent work has highlighted deep connections between sequence-length requirements for high-probability phylogeny reconstruction and the related problem of the estimation of...

  • Statistical Properties of Pairwise Distances between Leaves on a Random Yule Tree. Sheinman, Michael; Massip, Florian; Arndt, Peter F. // PLoS ONE;Mar2015, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p1 

    A Yule tree is the result of a branching process with constant birth and death rates. Such a process serves as an instructive null model of many empirical systems, for instance, the evolution of species leading to a phylogenetic tree. However, often in phylogeny the only available information is...

  • On encodings of phylogenetic networks of bounded level. Gambette, Philippe; Huber, Katharina // Journal of Mathematical Biology;Jul2012, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p157 

    Phylogenetic networks have now joined phylogenetic trees in the center of phylogenetics research. Like phylogenetic trees, such networks canonically induce collections of phylogenetic trees, clusters, and triplets, respectively. Thus it is not surprising that many network approaches aim to...

  • Inferring explicit weighted consensus networks to represent alternative evolutionary histories. Layeghifard, Mehdi; Peres-Neto, Pedro R.; Makarenkov, Vladimir // BMC Evolutionary Biology;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background The advent of molecular biology techniques and constant increase in availability of genetic material have triggered the development of many phylogenetic tree inference methods. However, several reticulate evolution processes, such as horizontal gene transfer and hybridization, have...

  • Phylogeny of subtribe Pyrinae (formerly the Maloideae, Rosaceae): Limited resolution of a complex evolutionary history. Campbell, C. S.; Evans, R. C.; Morgan, D. R.; Dickinson, T. A.; Arsenault, M. P. // Plant Systematics & Evolution;Jul2007, Vol. 266 Issue 1/2, p119 

    Generic relationships in the Pyrinae (equivalent to subfamily Maloideae) were assessed with six chloroplast regions and five nuclear regions. We also plotted 12 non-molecular characters onto molecular phylogenies. Chloroplast DNA trees are incongruent with those from nuclear regions, as are most...

  • Estimating a Binary Character's Effect on Speciation and Extinction. Maddison, Wayne P.; Midford, Peter E.; Otto, Sarah P. // Systematic Biology;Oct2007, Vol. 56 Issue 5, p701 

    Determining whether speciation and extinction rates depend on the state of a particular character has been of long-standing interest to evolutionary biologists. To assess the effect of a character on diversification rates using likelihood methods requires that we be able to calculate the...

  • FUNCTION AND EVOLUTION OF THE PLANT MADS-BOX GENE FAMILY. Ng, Medard; Yanofsky, Martin F. // Nature Reviews Genetics;Mar2001, Vol. 2 Issue 3, p186 

    The function of MADS-box genes in flower and fruit development has been uncovered at a rapid pace over the past decade. Evolutionary biologists can now analyse the expression pattern of MADS-box genes during the development of different plant species, and study the homology of body parts and the...

  • 'Lassoing' a phylogenetic tree I: basic properties, shellings, and covers. Dress, Andreas; Huber, Katharina; Steel, Mike // Journal of Mathematical Biology;Jul2012, Vol. 65 Issue 1, p77 

    A classical result, fundamental to evolutionary biology, states that an edge-weighted tree T with leaf set X, positive edge weights, and no vertices of degree 2 can be uniquely reconstructed from the leaf-to-leaf distances between any two elements of X. In biology, X corresponds to a set of taxa...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics