'Relief of oppression': An organizing principle for researchers' obligations to participants in observational studies in the developing world

Lavery, James V.; Bandewar, Sunita V. S.; Kimani, Joshua; Upshur, Ross E. G.; Plummer, Frances A.; Singer, Peter A.
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p384
Academic Journal
Background: A central question in the debate about exploitation in international research is whether investigators and sponsors from high-income countries (HIC) have obligations to address background conditions of injustice in the communities in which they conduct their research, beyond the healthcare and other research-related needs of participants, to aspects of their basic life circumstances. Discussion: In this paper, we describe the Majengo sexually transmitted disease (STD) Cohort study, a long-term prospective, observational cohort of sex workers in Nairobi, Kenya. Despite important scientific contributions and a wide range of benefits to the women of the cohort, most of the women have remained in the sex trade during their long-standing participation in the cohort, prompting allegations of exploitation. The Majengo STD cohort case extends the debate about justice in international research ethics beyond clinical trials into long-term observational research. We sketch the basic features of a new approach to understanding and operationalizing obligations of observational researchers, which we call 'relief of oppression'. 'Relief of oppression' is an organizing principle, analogous to the principle of harm reduction that is now widely applied in public health practice. Relief of oppression aims to help observational researchers working in conditions of injustice and deprivation to clarify their ethical obligations to participants. It aims to bridge the gap between a narrow, transaction-oriented account of avoiding exploitation and a broad account emphasizing obligations of reparation for historic injustices. We propose that relief of oppression might focus researchers' consideration of benefits on those that have some relevance to background conditions of injustice, and so elevate the priority of these benefits, in relation to others that might be considered and negotiated with participants, according to the degree to which the participating communities are constrained in their realization of fundamental freedoms. Summary: The over-arching aim of relief of oppression is that, within the range of benefits negotiated over time with the local communities and organizations, an increasing proportion reflects a shared interest in improving participants' fundamental freedoms. We describe how harm reduction serves as a useful analogy for how we envision relief of oppression functioning in international research.


Related Articles

  • Acceptability of a Carrageenan-Based Candidate Vaginal Microbicide and Matching Placebo: Findings from a Phase II Safety Trial among Women in Chiang Rai, Thailand. Jones, Heidi E.; Chaikummao, Supaporn; van de Wijgert, Janneke H. H. M.; Friedland, Barbara A.; Manopaiboon, Chomnad; Witwatwongwana, Paisit; Wankrairot, Mayuree; Chantharojwong, Nartlada; Kilmarx, Peter H. // Journal of Women's Health (15409996);Jul2009, Vol. 18 Issue 7, p1003 

    Objective: To evaluate extended acceptability of vaginal use of a carrageenan-based candidate microbicide and placebo in northern Thai women. Methods: As part of a randomized, placebo-controlled, triple-blinded clinical trial, women were asked to insert gel with each vaginal sex act and at least...

  • Carotid Endarterectomy for Women and Men. Kapral, Moira K.; Redelmeier, Donald A. // Journal of Women's Health & Gender-Based Medicine;Nov2000, Vol. 9 Issue 9, p987 

    Carotid endarterectomy is the standard of care for people with severe symptomatic carotid stenosis. We analyzed population administrative data and clinical trial data to determine whether sex differences exist in the use and outcomes of this surgical procedure. We studied patients in Ontario who...

  • Society for Women's Health Research. Dooley, Erin E. // Environmental Health Perspectives;Jan2003, Vol. 111 Issue 1, pA23 

    Presents the web site of the Society for Women's Health Research, formed in the late 1980s to advocate for women's inclusion as subjects in clinical drug trials. Promotion of sex-based biology and lobbying for more women's health research funding; Education of women on the importance of medical...

  • The Pulse on Global Trials. Howes, Matthew // CenterWatch Weekly;4/7/2014, Vol. 18 Issue 14, p6 

    The article offers information on making recruitment and retention goals for clinical trials in developing markets realistic. Due to high literacy rates in developed countries, gathering informed consent using traditional, paper-based systems is not effective. Falguni Sen, director of the Global...

  • Women's health and clinical trials. Schiebinger, Londa // Journal of Clinical Investigation;Oct2003, Vol. 112 Issue 7, p973 

    Women have traditionally been underrepresented in clinical trials. In order to translate recent advances in our understanding of the molecular and physiological bases of sex differences into new therapeutics and health practices, sound sex-specific clinical data are imperative. Since the...

  • EDCTP regional networks of excellence: initial merits for planned clinical trials in Africa. Miiro, George M.; Oukem-Boyer, Odile Ouwe Missi; Sarr, Ousmane; Rahmani, Maerangis; Ntoumi, Francine; Dheda, Keertan; Pym, Alexander; Mboup, Souleymane; Kaleebu, Pontiano // BMC Public Health;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Achieving the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and combating hotspots with escalating but preventable communicable diseases remain major challenges in Africa. The European and Developing Countries Clinical Trials Partnership (EDCTP) intervened to combat poverty-related diseases...

  • Is she doomed to die young?  // Glamour;Nov2005, Vol. 103 Issue 11, p162 

    Examines the prevalence of death in developing countries from preventable diseases. Detection of high risk of malnourished pregnant women to develop these diseases; Inability of these patients to afford treatment; Observation that the situation has worsened due to the lack of funding.

  • Sitting vs Standing During Screening Mammography. Hagen, Suzanne; Goodwin, Eunice; Sinclair, Lesley // Radiologic Technology;Jan/Feb2008, Vol. 79 Issue 3, p214 

    Objective The aim of this randomized controlled trial was to compare outcomes of standing vs seated mammography. Methods Five hundred forty women were assessed for ease of getting into position, comfort and pain using visual analog scales. Blinded, independent assessment of film quality and...

  • The CROWN Initiative: journal editors invite researchers to develop core outcomes in women's health. Khan, Khalid // International Urogynecology Journal;Oct2014, Vol. 25 Issue 10, p1297 

    The article focuses on the CoRe Outcomes in WomeN's Health (CROWN) international initiative led by women's health journal editors to consolidate results of women's health research and clinical trials. Topics discussed include the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) Initiative,...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics