Understanding discrepancies in parent-child reporting of emotional and behavioural problems: Effects of relational and socio-demographic factors

Van Roy, Betty; Groholt, Berit; Heyerdahl, Sonja; Clench-Aas, Jocelyne
January 2010
BMC Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 10, p56
Academic Journal
Background: Discrepancies between parents and children in their assessment of children's mental health affect the evaluation of need for services and must be taken seriously. This article presents the differences between parents' and children's reports of the children's symptoms and social impairment, based on the results of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ). The interrelationship between relational aspects and socio-demographic factors with patterns of disagreement are explored. Methods: Differences in the prevalence and means of SDQ symptom and impact scores were obtained from 8,154 primary school children, aged between 10 and 13 years, and their parents. Agreement between matched pairs was measured using Pearson's and Spearman's rho correlations. Socio-demographic variables, communication patterns and parental engagement were analysed as possible correlates of informant discrepancies using bivariate and multivariate logistic regression models. Results: In general, although children reported more symptoms, they reported less impact of perceived difficulties than parents. The parents were more consistent in their evaluation of symptoms and impact than were the children. Exploration of highly discrepant subgroups showed that, when children reported the most symptoms and impact, qualitative aspects of the parent-child relationship and family structure seemed to be more powerful predictors of disagreement than were gender of the child and socio-demographic variables. When parents reported the most symptoms and impact, low parental educational level, low income and male gender of the child played an additional role. Conclusions: Our findings underline the importance of paying attention to child reports of emotional-behavioural difficulties, particularly when parents do not identify these problems. Considerations on what meaning parent-child discrepancy might have in the context of the parent-child relationship or the family's psychosocial status should be integrated in the overall understanding of the child's situation and subsequent recommendations.


Related Articles

  • The Mental Health of Married, Cohabiting, and Non--Coresident Parents With Infants. Deklyen, Michelle; Brooks-Gunn, Jeanne; Mclanahan, Sara; Knab, Jean // American Journal of Public Health;Oct2006, Vol. 96 Issue 10, p1836 

    Objectives. We compared recent parents (married, cohabiting, not cohabiting but romantically involved, and not romantically involved) to examine the association between mental health problems and relationship status. Methods. We analyzed data from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study...

  • Self-reported symptomatology of socially rejected and neglected Italian elementary-school children. Tani, Franca; Schneider, Barry // Child Study Journal;1997, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p301 

    Examines the self-reported symptomatology of socially rejected and neglected Italian elementary-school children. Studies on the association between social incompetence in childhood and later mental disorder; Definition of sociometrically rejected children; Causal paths between sociometric...

  • Snapping to it. German, Amy // Nation (1206-2642);3/21/2014, Vol. 21 Issue 10, p10 

    The article discusses the Mamtunaata Stop Now and Plan (SNAP), a cognitive-behavioural program of Canadian children's mental health agency Child Development Institute introduced in 2011. It states that the program was designed to help children regulate angry feelings through thinking about their...

  • Mental Health.  // Education Journal;Mar2006, Issue 93, p35 

    The article presents the findings of research from Aberdeen University regarding the mental health of Scottish pupils. One in four young people are thought to suffer from mental health problems. It is thought that there is a link between conduct problems in adolescence and problems in adulthood....

  • MENTAL HYGIENE IN THE SCHOOL CHILD. Patry, Frederick L. // Education;Jan1937, Vol. 57 Issue 5, p273 

    The article discusses several objectives, important factors operating in mental health, as well as methods and problem facts concerning the mental well-being of school children in the United States. Key issues examined include efforts to develop the constructive potential assets of children with...

  • Children's Mental Health and School Success. DeSocio, Janiece; Hootman, Janis // Journal of School Nursing;Aug2004, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p189 

    An integrative review of literature was undertaken to examine the impact of children's mental health on their school success. The literature confirmed a confluence of problems associated with school performance and child and adolescent mental health. Poor academic functioning and inconsistent...

  • Electronic Diaries: A Feasible Method of Assessing Emotional Experiences in Youth? Suveg, Cynthia; Payne, Mary; Thomassin, Kristel; Jacob, Marni L. // Journal of Psychopathology & Behavioral Assessment;Mar2010, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p57 

    The primary goal of this study was to examine whether electronic diaries are a feasible method of monitoring transitory emotional states with a school-age, community sample of youth. A second goal was to examine preliminary relations between indices of emotional functioning captured via...


    Social scientists know relatively little about how low-income urban single mothers engage religion in parenting, particularly their rationales for involving children in religious practices and the strategies they use for doing so. This article develops a theoretical model of religion as a...

  • Parent-Child Conflict and Early Childhood Adjustment in Two-Parent Low-Income Families: Parallel Developmental Processes. Weaver, Chelsea; Shaw, Daniel; Crossan, Jennifer; Dishion, Thomas; Wilson, Melvin // Child Psychiatry & Human Development;Feb2015, Vol. 46 Issue 1, p94 

    Parent-child conflict is central to most intervention models focused on reducing child problem behavior, yet few longitudinal studies have examined these processes during early childhood. The current study investigates (1) growth in mother-child and father figure (FF)-child conflict, (2)...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics