Understanding discrepancies in parent-child reporting of emotional and behavioural problems: Effects of relational and socio-demographic factors

Van Roy, Betty; Groholt, Berit; Heyerdahl, Sonja; Clench-Aas, Jocelyne
January 2010
BMC Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 10, p56
Academic Journal
Background: Discrepancies between parents and children in their assessment of children's mental health affect the evaluation of need for services and must be taken seriously. This article presents the differences between parents' and children's reports of the children's symptoms and social impairment, based on the results of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ). The interrelationship between relational aspects and socio-demographic factors with patterns of disagreement are explored. Methods: Differences in the prevalence and means of SDQ symptom and impact scores were obtained from 8,154 primary school children, aged between 10 and 13 years, and their parents. Agreement between matched pairs was measured using Pearson's and Spearman's rho correlations. Socio-demographic variables, communication patterns and parental engagement were analysed as possible correlates of informant discrepancies using bivariate and multivariate logistic regression models. Results: In general, although children reported more symptoms, they reported less impact of perceived difficulties than parents. The parents were more consistent in their evaluation of symptoms and impact than were the children. Exploration of highly discrepant subgroups showed that, when children reported the most symptoms and impact, qualitative aspects of the parent-child relationship and family structure seemed to be more powerful predictors of disagreement than were gender of the child and socio-demographic variables. When parents reported the most symptoms and impact, low parental educational level, low income and male gender of the child played an additional role. Conclusions: Our findings underline the importance of paying attention to child reports of emotional-behavioural difficulties, particularly when parents do not identify these problems. Considerations on what meaning parent-child discrepancy might have in the context of the parent-child relationship or the family's psychosocial status should be integrated in the overall understanding of the child's situation and subsequent recommendations.


Related Articles

  • Evocação de termos mentais por pré-escolares: um estudo com narrativa por imagem. Rodrigues, Marisa Cosenza; Ribeiro, Nathalie Nehmy; Cunha, Priscila Campos // Psicologia: Teoria e Prática;2009, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p3 

    This study investigated pre-school children's evocation of mental terms. The children were enrolled on a private school of one of Minas Gerais city. Children had to read a narrative by image storybook. Seventeen 5-year-old children and seventeen 6-year-olds were selected by a convenience...

  • This spring, step forward for kids. Nguyen, Linda // Filipino Post;4/24/2014, pFP23 

    The article informs about the Walk so Kids Can Talk organized by Kids Help Phone, Canada's online counseling service, to make people aware about significance of mental health of kids and also mentions the views of Alisa Simon of counseling service, regarding challenges faced by kids.

  • School transport.  // 14-19 Learning & Skills Bulletin;7/1/2015, Issue 161, p25 

    The article talks about the growing importance of school transport with reference to England. The article states that when schools are separated by large distances from home ,the parents are entitled to anticipate support for transport from local authorities. The article also mentions that...

  • A School-Based Multilevel Preventive Intervention: Issues in Program Development and Evaluation. Lorion, Raymond P.; Work, William C.; Hightower, Alan Dirk // Personnel & Guidance Journal;Apr84, Vol. 62 Issue 8, p479 

    Focuses on the basic academic skills enhancement program, a school-based multilevel preventive intervention program developed to reduce the prevalence of learning and emotional disorders in primary grade children. Concept of prevention; Assessment of primary prevention outcomes; Conceptual basis...

  • Breakfast and Learning: An Updated Review. Murphy, J. M. // Current Nutrition & Food Science;2007, Vol. 3 Issue 1, p3 

    Over the past five years, significant new evidence has documented the link between eating breakfast and learning. Recent studies show that skipping breakfast is relatively common among children in the U.S. and other industrialized nations and is associated with quantifiable negative consequences...

  • Pupils find a place for managing anxiety.  // Children & Young People Now;3/20/2012, p32 

    The article presents information on the project A Quiet Place which works on boosting children's wellbeing in Great Britain by solving their problems psychologically. It informs that schools are funding for this project and also discusses the importance of this project for children's social and...

  • YOUNG BRAINS NEED BREAKFAST. Carey, Dorothy // Nutridate;Mar2008, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p7 

    The article discusses early findings from a study by Curtin University and the Telethon Institute for Child Health Research, which show that what children eat can affect their mental wellbeing, and that the key to good mental health is having a breakfast covering several food groups. The study...

  • Best in Salford takes 'a step back' to intervene later.  // Community Care;8/9/2007, Issue 1685, p17 

    The article features the Best team in Salford, England which is linked to 23 primary schools and four secondary schools. The team has a fast-track route for referring children and young people to the child and adolescent mental health service, but its principal focus is on early intervention....

  • Mental Health Predicts Better Academic Outcomes: A Longitudinal Study of Elementary School Students in Chile. Murphy, J.; Guzmán, Javier; McCarthy, Alyssa; Squicciarini, Ana; George, Myriam; Canenguez, Katia; Dunn, Erin; Baer, Lee; Simonsohn, Ariela; Smoller, Jordan; Jellinek, Michael // Child Psychiatry & Human Development;Apr2015, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p245 

    The world's largest school-based mental health program, Habilidades para la Vida [Skills for Life (SFL)], has been operating on a national scale in Chile for 15 years. SFL's activities include using standardized measures to screen elementary school students and providing preventive workshops to...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics