Accuracy of General Practitioners' Assessment of Chest Pain Patients for Coronary Heart Disease in Primary Care: Cross-sectional Study with Follow-up

Bösner, Stefan; Haasenritter, Jörg; Hani, Maren Abu; Keller, Heidi; Sönnichsen, Andreas C.; Karatolios, Konstantinos; Schaefer, Juergen R.; Baum, Erika; Donner-Banzhoff, Norbert
June 2010
Croatian Medical Journal;Jun2010, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p243
Academic Journal
Aim To estimate how accurately general practitioners' (GP) assessed the probability of coronary heart disease in patients presenting with chest pain and analyze the patient management decisions taken as a result. Methods During 2005 and 2006, the cross-sectional diagnostic study with a delayed-type reference standard included 74 GPs in the German state of Hesse, who enrolled 1249 consecutive patients presenting with chest pain. GPs recorded symptoms and findings for each patient on a report form. Patients and GPs were contacted 6 weeks and 6 months after the patients' visit to the GP. Data on chest complaints, investigations, hospitalization, and medication were reviewed by an independent panel, with coronary heart disease being the reference condition. Diagnostic properties (sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values) of the GPs' diagnoses were calculated. Results GPs diagnosed coronary heart disease with the sensitivity of 69% (95% confidence interval [CI], 62-75) and specificity of 89% (95% CI, 87-91), and acute coronary syndrome with the sensitivity of 50% (95% CI, 36-64) and specificity of 98% (95% CI, 97-99). They assumed coronary heart disease in 245 patients, 41 (17%) of whom were referred to the hospital, 77 (31%) to a cardiologist, and 162 (66%) to electrocardiogram testing. Conclusions GPs' evaluation of chest pain patients, based on symptoms and signs alone, was not sufficiently accurate for diagnosing or excluding coronary heart disease or acute coronary syndrome.


Related Articles

  • CARDIAC: AMBULATORY ECG RECORDING. Handler, Clive; Coghlan, Gerry // Pulse;12/3/2008, Vol. 68 Issue 42, p32 

    The article reports on the series of tests on ambulatory devices used in primary care done by Cardiologists Dr. Clive Handler and Dr. Gerry Coghlan. Ambulatory devices also record the ST segment, and adopted in the evaluation of patients with coronary heart disease and silent ischaemia....

  • Practices meet CHD targets--but at a price.  // Pulse;11/3/2003, Vol. 63 Issue 44, p8 

    Reports that the Durham Dales Primary Care Trust has managed to meet almost all of the targets for coronary heart disease in the physician contract. Impact on the prescribing budget and other services of the physician trust.

  • Predicting Coronary Heart Disease in Remote Settings: A Prospective, Cross-sectional Observational Study. Dwivedi, J.; Sutcliffe, S.; Easterbrook, L.; Woods, C.; Maguire, G. P. // Heart, Lung & Circulation;Aug2014, Vol. 23 Issue 8, p737 

    Background Coronary heart disease (CHD) places a major burden on the Australian health care system. Determining the likelihood of CHD in a patient presenting with chest pain can be particularly difficult in a remote setting where access to transportation and specialised investigations including...

  • Profound hypokalaemia mimicking acute myocardial infarction. Dalzell, J. R.; Jackson, C. E.; Petrie, M. C. // QJM: An International Journal of Medicine;Nov2009, Vol. 102 Issue 11, p822 

    The article discusses the case of a 70-year-old female who was hospitalized because of chest pain in keeping with myocardial ischaemia. The patient was diagnosed with metastatic rectal carcinoma requiring a de-functioning colostomy. The female was transferred to the regional percutaneous...

  • Differences between patients with chronic widespread pain and chronic local back pain in primary care-a comparative cross-sectional analysis. Viniol, Annika; Jegan, Nikita; Leonhardt, Corinna; Brugger, Markus; Strauch, Konstantin; Barth, Jürgen; Baum, Erika; Becker, Annette // BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders;2013, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Background Chronic pain is a common reason for consultation in general practice. Current research distinguishes between chronic localized pain (CLP) and chronic widespread pain (CWP). The aim of this study was to identify differences between CWP and chronic low back pain (CLBP), a common type of...

  • The strength of primary care in Europe: an international comparative study. Kringos, Dionne; Boerma, Wienke; Bourguei, Yann; Cartier, Thomas; Dedeu, Toni; Hasvold, Toralf; Hutchinson, Allen; Lember, Margus; Oleszczyk, Marek; Pavlic, Danica Rotar; Svab, Igor; Tedeschi, Paolo; Wilm, Stefan; Wilson, Andrew; Windak, Adam; Der Zee, Jouke Van; Groenewegen, Peter // British Journal of General Practice;Nov2013, Vol. 63 Issue 616, pe742 

    Background A suitable definition of primary care to capture the variety of prevailing international organisation and service-delivery models is lacking. Aim Evaluation of strength of primary care in Europe. Design and setting International comparative cross-sectional study performed in...

  • Factors associated with prevalence and types of 'may be fit' advice on fit notes: a cross-sectional primary care analysis. Shiels, Chris; Gabbay, Mark; Hillage, Jim // British Journal of General Practice;Mar2014, Vol. 64 Issue 620, pe137 

    Background The 'fit note', with the opportunity for the GP to advise that a patient 'may be fit' to do some work, was introduced in April 2010. Aim To estimate numbers of fit notes with 'may be fit' advice, the types of advice, and factors associated with any inclusion of such advice in the fit...

  • Patient experience and the role of postgraduate GP training: a cross-sectional analysis of national Patient Survey data in England. Ashworth, Mark; Schofield, Peter; Durbaba, Stevo; Ahluwalia, Sanjiv // British Journal of General Practice;Mar2014, Vol. 64 Issue 620, pe168 

    Background Quality indicators for primary care focus predominantly on the public health model and organisational measures. Patient experience is an important dimension of quality. Accreditation for GP training practices requires demonstration of a series of attributes including patient-centred...

  • Why Did Most French GPs Choose Not to Join the Voluntary National Pay-for-Performance Program? Saint-Lary, Olivier; Bernard, Erik; Sicsic, Jonathan; Plu, Isabelle; François-Purssell, Irène; Franc, Carine // PLoS ONE;Sep2013, Vol. 8 Issue 9, p1 

    Background: In 2009, a voluntary pay for performance (P4P) scheme for primary care physicians was introduced in France through the ‘Contract for Improving Individual Practice’ (CAPI). Although the contract could be interrupted at any time and without any penalty, two-thirds of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics