Ethnicity and attitudes to deceased kidney donation: a survey in Barbados and comparison with Black Caribbean people in the United Kingdom

Morgan, Myfanwy; Adams, O Peter; Seed, Paul T.; Jones, Roger
January 2010
BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p266
Academic Journal
Background: Black minority ethnic groups in the UK have relatively low rates of deceased donation and report a higher prevalence of beliefs that are regarded as barriers to donation. However there is little data from migrants' countries of origin. This paper examines community attitudes to deceased kidney donation in Barbados and compares the findings with a survey conducted in a disadvantaged multi-ethnic area of south London. Methods: Questionnaires were administered at four public health centres in Barbados and at three private general practices. Adjusted odds ratios were calculated to compare attitudinal responses with a prior survey of 328 Caribbean and 808 White respondents in south London. Results: Questionnaires were completed by 327 respondents in Barbados (93% response); 42% men and 58% women, with a mean age of 40.4 years (SD 12.6). The main religious groups were Anglican (29%) and Pentecostal (24%). Educational levels ranged from 18% not completing 5th form to 12% with university education. Attitudes to the notion of organ donation were favourable, with 73% willing to donate their kidneys after their death and only 5% definitely against this. Most preferred an opt-in system of donation. Responses to nine attitudinal questions identified 18% as having no concerns and 9% as having 4 or more concerns. The highest level of concern (43%) was for lack of confidence that medical teams would try as hard to save the life of a person who has agreed to donate organs. There was no significant association between age, gender, education or religion and attitudinal barriers, but greater knowledge of donation had some positive effect on attitudes. Comparison of attitudes to donation in south London and Barbados (adjusting for gender, age, level of education, employment status) indicated that a significantly higher proportion of the south London Caribbean respondents identified attitudinal barriers to donation. Conclusions: Community attitudes in Barbados are favourable to deceased donation based on a system of informed consent. Comparison with south London data supports the hypothesis that the relatively high prevalence of negative attitudes to deceased donation among disadvantaged ethnic minorities in high income countries may reflect feelings of marginalisation and lack of belonging.


Related Articles

  • Renal function studies after nephrectomy in renal donors. Davison, J.M.; Uldall, P.R.; Walls, J. // British Medical Journal;5/1/1976, Vol. 1 Issue 6017, p1050 

    Examines the renal functions of renal donors after nephrectomy. Comparison of creatinine clearance between male donors and female donors; Impact of dextrose and inulin infusion on the values for inulin clearance of male and female donors; Need of a rigid investigation for the nephrectomy of...

  • Largest kidney swap results in 13 patients receiving new organs.  // Urology Times;Feb2010, Vol. 38 Issue 2, p54 

    The article reports on the record-setting kidney exchange at Georgetown University Hospital, Washington and Washington Hospital Center which resulted in 26 operations for 13 patients waiting for kidneys.

  • Online CME Quiz Questions: Live Kidney Donation: A 36-Year-Old Woman Hoping to Donate a Kidney to Her Mother.  // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;2/9/2011, Vol. 305 Issue 6, p627 

    A quiz about live kidney donation is presented.

  • Journal Club.  // Kidney International;Jul2012, Vol. 82 Issue 1, p3 

    The article offers information on studies and report on kidney diseases and abnormalities in the U.S. A study by Thornton and colleagues confirmed that people who watch video on organ donation among ethnic groups will more to consent to organ donation. A report from Amin and colleagues showed a...

  • Determinants of Willingness to Become Organ Donors among Dialysis Patients' Family Members. Tumin, Makmor; Satar, Nurul Huda Mohd; Zakaria, Roza Hazli; Ariffin, Raja Noriza Raja; Lim Soo-Kun; Ng Kok-Peng; Tafran, Khaled // Urology Journal;Jul/Aug2015, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p2245 

    Purpose: This study explores the factors affecting the willingness of dialysis patients' family members to become involved in living and deceased organ donation. Materials and Methods: We utilize cross sectional data on 350 family members of dialysis patients collected through self-administered...

  • Living kidney donor informed consent practices vary between US and non-US centers. Ami M. Parekh; Elisa J. Gordon; Amit X. Garg; Amy D. Waterman; Sanjay Kulkarni; Chirag R. Parikh // Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation;Oct2008, Vol. 23 Issue 10, p3316 

    Background. Living kidney donation rates are increasing in the United States and internationally. Major consensus statements on the care of living kidney donors recommend communicating all potential health and psychosocial risks to donors. We evaluated the degree of international variation in...

  • Poorer Results with Older Donor Kidneys in Older Recipients.  // Kidney;Nov/Dec99, Vol. 8 Issue 6, p259 

    Analyzes outcomes of renal transplantation (RT) in recipients greater than 60 years old. Overall one- and five-year patient survival in RT recipients; Issue whether to utilize older kidneys preferentially in older recipients despite the overall outcomes of RT in older recipients being reasonable.

  • Kidney Paired Donation � The Next Step. Connolly, Jay S.; Terasaki, Paul I.; Veale, Jeffrey L. // New England Journal of Medicine;9/1/2011, Vol. 365 Issue 9, p868 

    A letter to the editor is presented about kidney paired donation in the U.S.

  • Should Buying Kidneys Be Allowed?  // Renal & Urology News;Nov2012, Vol. 11 Issue 11, p8 

    The article information on the findings of a recent online poll, which asked whether it would be a good idea to offer payments to people to donate a kidney in which 41.6% respondents said yes and 56.41% respondents said no.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics