Depression diagnoses following the identification of bipolar disorder: costly incongruent diagnoses

Stensland, Michael D.; Schultz, Jennifer F.; Frytak, Jennifer R.
January 2010
BMC Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 10, p39
Academic Journal
Background: Previous research has documented that the symptoms of bipolar disorder are often mistaken for unipolar depression prior to a patient's first bipolar diagnosis. The assumption has been that once a patient receives a bipolar diagnosis they will no longer be given a misdiagnosis of depression. The objectives of this study were 1) to assess the rate of subsequent unipolar depression diagnosis in individuals with a history of bipolar disorder and 2) to assess the increased cost associated with this potential misdiagnosis. Methods: This study utilized a retrospective cohort design using administrative claims data from 2002 and 2003. Patient inclusion criteria for the study were 1) at least 2 bipolar diagnoses in 2002, 2) continuous enrollment during 2002 and 2003, 3) a pharmacy benefit, and 4) age 18 to 64. Patients with at least 2 unipolar depression diagnoses in 2003 were categorized as having an incongruent diagnosis of unipolar depression. We used propensity scoring to control for selection bias. Utilization was evaluated using negative binomial models. We evaluated cost differences between patient cohorts using generalized linear models. Results: Of the 7981 patients who met all inclusion criteria for the analysis, 17.5% (1400) had an incongruent depression diagnosis (IDD). After controlling for background differences, individuals who received an IDD had higher rates of inpatient and outpatient psychiatric utilization and cost, on average, an additional $1641 per year compared to individuals without an IDD. Conclusions: A strikingly high proportion of bipolar patients are given the differential diagnosis of unipolar depression after being identified as having bipolar disorder. Individuals with an IDD had increased acute psychiatric care services, suggesting higher levels of relapses, and were at risk for inappropriate treatment, as antidepressant therapy without a concomitant mood-stabilizing medication is contraindicated in bipolar disorder. Further prospective research is needed to validate the findings from this retrospective administrative claims-based analysis.


Related Articles

  • LA NOIA NEI DISTURBI DELL'UMORE: ESPERIENZE CLINICHE E DI RICERCA. Lari, Lisa; Gragnani, Andrea; Calugi, Simona; Saettoni, Marco // Cognitivismo Clinico;2013, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p45 

    Objective: This paper has two distinct aims. The first aim is to describe boredom as an antecedent of some behavioral patterns through a clinical comparison of 4 subjects, 2 with Recurrent Major Depression (RMD) and 2 with Bipolar Disorder (BD). The second aim is to investigate any correlations...

  • Influence of season and latitude in a community sample of subjects with bipolar disorder. Schaffer, Ayal; Levitt, Anthony J; Boyle, Michael // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;May2003, Vol. 48 Issue 4, p277 

    Objective: To report on the prevalence of seasonal bipolar disorder (BD) and the impact of latitude in a community sample in the province of Ontario.Method: This study used the telephone-administered Depression and Seasonality Interview. Exact latitude was determined...

  • Espectro del estado de ánimo en el trastorno unipolar y bipolar: argumentos a favor de un enfoque unitario. Cassano, Giovanni B.; Rucci, Paola; Frank, Ellen; Fagiolini, Andrea; Dell'Osso, Liliana; Shear, M. Katherine; Kupfer, David J. // American Journal of Psychiatry - Edición Española;Oct2004, Vol. 7 Issue 9, p549 

    No abstract available.

  • Considering the costs of bipolar depression. Kessler, Ronald C.; Akiskal, Hagop S.; Ames, Minnie; Birnbaum, Howard; Greenberg, Paul E.; Hirschfeld, Robert M.; Wang, Philip S. // Behavioral Healthcare;Jan2007, Vol. 27 Issue 1, p45 

    The article calls for more research on the impact of untreated bipolar depression on society. Employer-purchasers are concerned about this issue because so much of the societal burden associated with depression is related to adverse effects on workplace functioning. Many employers have responded...

  • Uzun Süreli Sürdürümde Lamotrijin Öncesi ve Sonrası bir karşılaÅŸtırma: Kan düzeyinin etkisi. Kesebir, Sermin; Akdeniz, Fisun; Demir, Aysun; Bilici, Mustafa // Journal of Mood Disorders;2013, Vol. 3 Issue 2, p47 

    Objective: The hypothesis of this study is that the efficacy of lamotrigine is related with blood level in bipolar disorder. Our aim is to compare the periods before and after lamotrigine use in cases with bipolar disorder and to investigate whether there has been any relation between...

  • Choroba afektywna dwubiegunowa z szybkÄ…, ultraszybkÄ… lub okoÅ‚odobowÄ… zmianÄ… faz. Kraszewska, Agnieszka; Wójciak, Paweł; Rybakowski, Janusz // Neuropsychiatry & Neuropsychology / Neuropsychiatria i Neuropsyc;2013, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p56 

    The aim of this paper is to review recent literature on rapid, ultra-rapid cycling and ultradian bipolar disorder (BD). The fourth edition of the American diagnostic system (DSM-IV, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual) defines rapid cycling bipolar disorder (RC) as a specific course, including...

  • Managing Every Shade Of Blue. Miller, Michael Craig // Newsweek;Summer2005 Special Edition, Vol. 145 Issue 26A, p34 

    Reports on the efforts to treat the varying degrees of depression. Example of how the same medication can have benefits for one patient and not another; Efforts to target drugs more effectively; Examination of DNA sequences of patients suffering from depression; How biology makes certain people...

  • Is Bipolar Disorder Overdiagnosed? Kuritzky, Louis // OB/GYN Clinical Alert;Sep2008 Clinical Briefs in Primary, Vol. 13 Issue 9, p17 

    The article presents a study on bipolar disorder (BPD), stating that such disease in underdiagnosed and is therefore, sometimes regrettably discovered subsequent to unmasking with treatment instituted for presumed unipolar depression. Methods to Improve Diagnostic Assessment and Services (MIDAS)...

  • GIRL, INTERRUPTED: ONE READER TELLS... Cassimatis, Georgia // Cleo;May2004, Issue 379, p164 

    Presents information on bipolar disorder, a mood disorder. Types of bipolar disorders; Persons affected by the disorder; Characterization of the disorder.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics