Therapist variation within randomised trials of psychotherapy: implications for precision, internal and external validity

Walwyn, Rebecca; Roberts, Chris
June 2010
Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p291
Academic Journal
Nesting of patients within therapists in psychotherapy trials creates an additional level within the design. The multilevel nature of this design has implications for the precision, internal and external validity of estimates of the treatment effect. Prior to or during a trial, psychotherapies are allocated to therapists and therapists are assigned to patients such that the therapist becomes part of the causal pathway from the intervention to the patient. It is therefore important to consider not only the relationship between interventions and patients but also relationships between interventions and therapists and between therapists and patients. Research designs comparing the effects of therapeutic approaches, therapist characteristics and packages of the two can be unified by viewing therapists as an important source of variability within psychotherapy outcome studies. Methodological considerations arising from therapist variation will be discussed, drawing together and building upon the associated psychotherapy and statistical literatures. Parallels will also be made with related designs and methods of analysis.


Related Articles

  • Directness in Therapy. Davis, Harold B. // Contemporary Psychoanalytic Studies;2009, Vol. 9, p85 

    The author recalls the directness of psychoanalyst Erich Fromm with his colleagues and patients. He first met Fromm at a New School for Social Research lecture in 1957 in which he challenged the way psychotherapy was being done during that time. In therapy, he notes that Fromm adopt the notion...

  • Latent mixture models for multivariate and longitudinal outcomes. Pickles, Andrew; Croudace, Tim // Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p271 

    Repeated measures and multivariate outcomes are an increasingly common feature of trials. Their joint analysis by means of random effects and latent variable models is appealing but patterns of heterogeneity in outcome profile may not conform to standard multivariate normal assumptions. In...

  • Neutrality or Negligence: Interpret or Act? de la Torre, Jorge; Smith, William // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Jul1978, Vol. 32 Issue 3, p440 

    Discusses the need for a psychotherapist to maintain a careful equilibrium between objectivity at the price of empathy and closeness at the expense of the necessary perspective. Ways in which crises in the course of long-term psychotherapy brings about a sudden, unexpected loss of such...

  • The Interlude between Short- and Long-term Psychotherapy. Amada, Gerald // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Jul1983, Vol. 37 Issue 3, p357 

    Discusses the interlude between short- and long-term psychotherapy characterized by three developments. Increase of vagueness with respect to formerly circumscribed psychological goals; Assumption on the part of the therapist of a less active role in the treatment process; Emergence of the...

  • Tarasoff Decision: A Decade Later Dilemma Still Faces Psychotherapy. Kermani, Ebrahim J.; Drob, Sanford L. // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Apr1987, Vol. 41 Issue 2, p271 

    Evaluates the relevance of landmark cases on the duty to warn concept to the psychotherapeutic practice in the United States. Impact of the cases on psychotherapeutic relationships; Interpretation of the duty to warn as applied to situations involving a serious threat to a specific individual;...

  • Supervision of termination in psychotherapy. Robb, Marjorie; Cameron, Paul M.; Robb, M; Cameron, P M // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;May1998, Vol. 43 Issue 4, p397 

    Objective: To propose a model for teaching and supervising the termination process in psychoanalytic psychotherapy.Method: Group supervision of the 12-week termination phase of psychotherapy with a patient who had been in psychotherapy with a senior resident for 2...

  • Interaction in Hospitalized Patient-led and Staff-led Psychotherapy Groups. Gould, Edward; Garrigues, Charles S.; Scheikowitz, Karen // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Jul1975, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p383 

    Explores the interaction between hospitalized-led and staff-led psychotherapy groups. Tendency of psychotic patients to participate more in patient-led group with staff observing versus traditional staff-led group; Clinical setting; Emergence of patient leaders; Capability of patient-led group...

  • A One-year Follow-up of Two Forms of Brief Psychotherapy. Patterson, Virginia; Levene, Howard; Breger, Louis // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Jan1977, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p76 

    Discusses results of a one-year follow-up of two forms of brief psychotherapy based on results of self-assessment and observation of interviewers and independent clinician judges. Patient characteristics; Perception of change by patients; Rating scale criteria; Percent of patients that had...

  • Emotions and Psychotherapies. Hoehn-Saric, Rudolf // American Journal of Psychotherapy;Jan1977, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p83 

    Examines techniques of cognitive-emotional interactions common to all psychotherapies, and their relative importance in various types of psychotherapy. Psychotherapist as modifier of emotional response; Emotional components of psychotherapies.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics