Mediation and moderation of treatment effects in randomised controlled trials of complex interventions

Emsley, Richard; Dunn, Graham; White, Ian R.
June 2010
Statistical Methods in Medical Research;Jun2010, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p237
Academic Journal
Complex intervention trials should be able to answer both pragmatic and explanatory questions in order to test the theories motivating the intervention and help understand the underlying nature of the clinical problem being tested. Key to this is the estimation of direct effects of treatment and indirect effects acting through intermediate variables which are measured post-randomisation. Using psychological treatment trials as an example of complex interventions, we review statistical methods which crucially evaluate both direct and indirect effects in the presence of hidden confounding between mediator and outcome. We review the historical literature on mediation and moderation of treatment effects. We introduce two methods from within the existing causal inference literature, principal stratification and structural mean models, and demonstrate how these can be applied in a mediation context before discussing approaches and assumptions necessary for attaining identifiability of key parameters of the basic causal model. Assuming that there is modification by baseline covariates of the effect of treatment (i.e. randomisation) on the mediator (i.e. covariate by treatment interactions), but no direct effect on the outcome of these treatment by covariate interactions leads to the use of instrumental variable methods. We describe how moderation can occur through post-randomisation variables, and extend the principal stratification approach to multiple group methods with explanatory models nested within the principal strata. We illustrate the new methodology with motivating examples of randomised trials from the mental health literature.


Related Articles

  • Family-Based Intervention for Schizophrenic Patients in China A Randomised Controlled Trial. Wei Xiong; Phillips, M. R.; Xiong Hu; Ruiwen Wang; Qinqing Dai; Kleinman, J.; Kleinman, A. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Aug94, Vol. 165, p239 

    Background. We developed and evaluated a comprehensive, ongoing intervention for families of schizophrenic patients appropriate for China's complex family relationships and unique social environment, Method. Sixty-three DSM-III-R schizophrenic patients living with family members were enrolled...

  • WHAT'S IN A SERVICE? CONSUMERS' VIEWS OF AUSTRALIAN MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES. Malins, Gillian; Oades, Lindsay; Viney, Linda; Aspden, Sam // Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal;Winter2006, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p197 

    This paper reports on a series of interviews with consumers of mental health services, conducted as part of the Consumer Evaluation of Mental Health Services project (CEO-MHS). With one of our overarching aims being to develop a consumer oriented and consumer directed method of evaluating mental...

  • The concept of space in the context of the therapeutic relationship. Stickley, Theodore; Freshwater, Dawn // Mental Health Practice;Mar2009, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p28 

    The article discusses the concept of therapeutic space of the health care industry in Great Britain. It notes the little consideration given to interpersonal and intrapersonal relations among people in the mental health practice. It also highlights the legitimate authority of the mental health...

  • Adding a nurse-based intervention programme to usual care improves manic symptoms in people with bipolar disorder: Commentary. Sachs, Gary S. // Evidence Based Mental Health;Aug2005, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p81 

    Comments on the research paper "Randomized Trial of a Population-Based Care Program for People With Bipolar Disorder," published in the 2005 issue of the journal Psychological Medicine. Focus on the treatment of bipolar disorder in clinical trials; Importance of tightening up the...

  • Adding a nurse-based intervention programme to usual care improves manic symptoms in people with bipolar disorder. Simon, Gregory // Evidence Based Mental Health;Aug2005, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p81 

    The article focuses on the research paper "Randomized Trial of a Population-Based Care Program for People With Bipolar Disorder," published in the 2005 issue of the journal Psychological Medicine. The paper presents a randomised controlled trial and a follow up study for twelve months. Patients...

  • Diagnostic, Symptom, and Functional Assessments of Hispanic Outpatients in Community Mental Health Practice. Zayas, Luis H.; Torres, Luis R.; Cabassa, Leopoldo J. // Community Mental Health Journal;Apr2009, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p97 

    With increased US Hispanic diversity come diagnostic challenges associated with culture, language, and expression of mental disorders. In a community-based clinic, we compared diagnostic agreement between Hispanic and non-Hispanic clinicians, and a structured diagnostic instrument, in live and...

  • Evaluating the effectiveness of interventions in child psychiatry. Fonagy, Peter; Fonagy, P // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Aug1997 Supplement, Vol. 42 Issue 6, p584 

    Objective: To review the nature of outcome measures used to evaluate psychosocial treatment in children.Method: Recent research findings that highlight the importance of outcome data and justify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are reviewed.Results:...

  • New national network responds to 'crisis' in BME mental health.  // Mental Health Practice;Oct2004, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p5 

    Announces the creation of a national network in Great Britain to press for improvement in the mental health care of people with black and minority ethnic (BME) backgrounds. Launch of the National Black an Minority Ethnic Mental Health Network in Manchester, England, in September 2004; Creation...

  • New program examines psych Rxs for Missouri Medicaid patients. Belden, Heidi // Drug Topics;11/3/2003, Vol. 147 Issue 21, p44 

    Announces the implementation of the program called the Missouri Mental Health Medicaid Pharmacy Partnership Program by the Missouri Department of Mental Health in partnership with Missouri Department of Medicaid. Examination of the prescribing practices of physicians routinely writing...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics