Channel Pass-Through of Trade Promotions

Nijs, Vincent; Misra, Kanishka; Anderson, Eric T.; Hansen, Karsten; Krishnamurthi, Lakshman
March 2010
Marketing Science;Mar/Apr2010, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p250
Academic Journal
Packaged goods manufacturers spend in excess of $75 billion annually on trade promotions, even though their effectiveness has been hotly debated by academics and practitioners for decades. One reason for this ongoing debate is that empirical research has been limited mostly to case studies, managerial surveys, and data from one or two supermarket chains in a single market. In this paper, we assemble a unique data set containing information on prices, quantities, and promotions throughout the entire channel in a category. Our study extends the empirical literature on pass-through in three important ways. First, we investigate how pass-through varies across more than 1,000 retailers in over 30 states. Second, we study pass-through at multiple levels of the distribution channel. Third, we show how the use of accounting metrics, such as average acquisition cost, rather than transaction cost, yields biased estimates of pass-through and therefore overstates the effectiveness of trade promotions. We find that mean pass-through elasticities are 0.71, 0.59, and 0.41, for the wholesaler, retailer, and total channel, respectively. More importantly, at each level of the channel we observe large variances in pass-through estimates that we explain using various measures of cost and competition. Surprisingly, we find that market structure and competition have a relatively small impact on pass-through. We conclude by showing how the profitability of manufacturer and wholesaler deals can be improved by utilizing detailed effectiveness estimates. For example, a manufacturer using an inclusive trade promotion strategy might offer a 10% off invoice deal to all retailers on every product. This strategy would decrease manufacturer and wholesaler profits for 56% of product/store combinations, whereas retailers experience a profit boost in 96% of cases. Manufacturers and wholesalers can avoid unprofitable trade deals for specific products and retailers by utilizing estimates of pass-through, consumer price elasticity, and margins. Compared to the inclusive strategy, such a selective trade promotion strategy would improve deal profitability by 80% and reduce costs by 40%.


Related Articles

  • Loss leaders and cross-category retailer pass-through: A Bayesian multilevel analysis. Pancras, Joseph; Gauri, Dinesh K.; Talukdar, Debabrata // Journal of Retailing;Jun2013, Vol. 89 Issue 2, p140 

    Abstract: Retail pass-through has been extensively analyzed analytically and empirically, and recent empirical work has stressed the importance of appropriate methodology and data for inferring correct retail pass-through. However the literature on retail pass-through has interpreted...

  • Using the Economics of the Pass-Through in Proving Antitrust Injury in Robinson-Patman Cases. Alexandrov, Alexei; Koulayev, Sergei // Antitrust Bulletin;Dec2015, Vol. 60 Issue 4, p345 

    We analyze and summarize microeconomic theory of pass-through rates. We start by analyzing a monopolist firm in a standard frictionless market, then add more nuances to the model, including, but not limited to, oligopolistic competition, menu costs, price points, endogenous quality and package...

  • Retailer Promotion Pass-Through: A Measure, Its Magnitude, and Its Determinants. Ailawadi, Kusum L.; Harlam, Bari A. // Marketing Science;Jul/Aug2009, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p782 

    We use data on all manufacturer funding and promotion activity by a major U.S. retailer during a two-year period to compute promotion pass-through and assess its magnitude. Then, we estimate a two-tiered probit and lognormal regression model to study drivers of the large variation we observe in...

  • THE ECONOMICS OF PASS-THROUGH WITH PRODUCTION CONSTRAINTS. Rothman, Dov; Tillmann, Philipp; Toniatti, David // Journal of Competition Law & Economics;Jun2016, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p279 

    This article reviews the implications of production constraints for pass-through. We consider production technology that can only be adjusted in discrete intervals and/or is costly to adjust. We show that, because of production constraints, a firm may not be willing to adjust its level of...

  • STEWARDS, AGENTS, AND THE FOUNDER DISCOUNT: EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION IN NEW VENTURES. Wasserman, Noam // Academy of Management Journal;Oct2006, Vol. 49 Issue 5, p960 

    Agency theory suggests that the interests of opportunistic, self-interested agents conflict with those of principals. Stewardship theory suggests instead that executives' interests are aligned with company interests and that executives are thus more intrinsically motivated than agency theory...

  • Correction.  // Contract Management;Sep2015, Vol. 55 Issue 9, p65 

    A correction is presented to the article "DOD, GSA, and NASA Issue Final Rule Requiring Increased Scrutiny of Pass-Through Contracts" in the August 2015 issue.

  • The effect of regulatory scrutiny: Asymmetric cost pass-through in power wholesale and its end. Mokinski, Frieder; W├Âlfing, Nikolas // Journal of Regulatory Economics;Apr2014, Vol. 45 Issue 2, p175 

    We find an asymmetric pass-through of European emission allowance (EUA) prices to wholesale electricity prices in Germany and show that this asymmetry disappeared in response to a report on investigations by the competition authority. The asymmetric pricing pattern, however, was not detected at...

  • Fuel price rises could lead to fall in demand. Dooley, Trevor // Utility Week;10/1/2004, Vol. 22 Issue 11, p11 

    Focuses on the possible effects of fuel price increases on the demand from industrial users and domestic customers in Europe according to Standard & Poor's as of October 2004. Factor that protected most European fuel companies; Basis of the assessment that the ease of pass through is...

  • When is the Price Cost Margin a Safe Way to Measure Changes in Competition? Boone, Jan; Ours, Jan; Wiel, Henry // De Economist (0013-063X);Mar2013, Vol. 161 Issue 1, p45 

    The price cost margin (PCM) is a popular way to measure competition. Although we know that this measure is not without problems, we actually do not know how often and under which conditions a change in PCM points in the wrong direction. We use a newcompetitionmeasure, the profit elasticity,which...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics