Clinical governance and research ethics as barriers to UK low-risk population-based health research?

van Teijlingen, Edwin R.; Douglas, Flora; Torrance, Nicola
January 2008
BMC Public Health;2008, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p396
Academic Journal
Background: Since the Helsinki Declaration was introduced in 1964 as a code of practice for clinical research, it has generally been agreed that research governance is also needed in the field of public health and health promotion research. Recently, a range of factors led to the development of more stringent bureaucratic procedures, governing the conduct of low-risk population-based health research in the United Kingdom. Methods: Our paper highlights a case study of the application process to medical research ethics committees in the United Kingdom for a study of the promotion of physical activity by health care providers. The case study presented here is an illustration of the challenges in conducting low-risk population-based health research. Results: Our mixed-methods approach involved a questionnaire survey of and semi-structured interviews with health professionals (who were all healthy volunteers). Since our study does not involve the participation of either patients or the general population, one would expect the application to the relevant research ethics committees to be a formality. This proved not to be the case! Conclusion: Research ethics committees could be counter-productive, rather than protecting the vulnerable in the research process, they can stifle low-risk population-based health research. Research ethics in health services research is first and foremost the responsibility of the researcher(s), and we need to learn to trust health service researchers again. The burden of current research governance regulation to address the perceived ethical problems is neither appropriate nor adequate. Senior researchers/ academics need to educate and train students and junior researchers in the area of research ethics, whilst at the same time reducing pressures on them that lead to unethical research, such as commercial funding, inappropriate government interference and the pressure to publish. We propose that non-invasive low-risk population-based health studies such as face-to-face interviews with health and social care professionals or postal questionnaire studies with patients on non-sensitive topics are given a waiver or a light touch review. We suggest that this can be achieved through a two-staged ethics application process. The first stage starts with a one or two-page outline application which ethics committees can use as the basis to grant a waiver or request a full application.


Related Articles

  • Towards translation of environmental determinants of physical activity in children into multi-sector policy measures: study design of a Dutch project. Aarts, Marie-Jeanne; van de Goor, Ien A. M.; van Oers, Hans A. M.; Schuit, Albertine J. // BMC Public Health;2009, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p396 

    Background: Physical inactivity in children is a major health problem in The Netherlands as well as in many other Western countries. In addition to health promotion among parents and children, creating "active" neighbourhoods can contribute to the solution of this health problem. However,...

  • Using Crowdsourcing Technology for Testing Multilingual Public Health Promotion Materials. Turner, Anne M.; Kirchhoff, Katrin; Capurro, Daniel // Journal of Medical Internet Research;May/Jun2012, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p22 

    Background: Effective communication of public health messages is a key strategy for health promotion by public health agencies. Creating effective health promotion materials requires careful message design and feedback from representatives of target populations. This is particularly true when...

  • Characteristics of Physical Activity Programs for Older Adults: Results of a Multisite Survey. Hughes, Susan L.; Williams, Barbara; Molina, Lourdes C.; Bayles, Constance; Bryant, Lucinda L.; Harris, Jeffrey R.; Hunter, Rebecca; Ivey, Susan; Watkins, Ken // Gerontologist;Oct2005, Vol. 45 Issue 5, p667 

    Purpose: Although Increased participation in physical activity by older adults is a major public health goal, little is known about the supply and use of physical activity programs in the United States. Design and Methods: Seven academic centers in diverse geographic areas surveyed physical...

  • Should public health interventions aimed at reducing childhood overweight and obesity be gender-focused? Simen-Kapeu, Aline; Veugelers, Paul J. // BMC Public Health;2010, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p340 

    Background: Overweight in childhood is a major public health concern that calls for immediate preventative action. An increasing number of reports suggest that gender specific approaches to prevention may be more effective. However, there is a paucity of information to guide gender-sensitive...

  • Laguna woods residents answer call to exercise.  // Nation's Health;Jun/Jul2002, Vol. 32 Issue 5, p16 

    Discusses how residents of Laguna Woods, California responded to the city's National Public Health Week physical activity challenge. Goal of the program; Number of residents that took part in the challenge.

  • get slim: skip the gym.  // Cincinnati;Winter2011 Wedding, p30 

    No abstract available.

  • STAND TO SURVIVE. Bradley, Ryan // Fortune International (Asia);7/2/2012, Vol. 166 Issue 1, p21 

    The article reports on a new study which found that too much sitting is killing people faster.

  • Children's Understanding of the Concept of Physical Activity. Trost, Stewart G.; Morgan, Angela M.; Saunders, Ruth; Felton, Gwen; Ward, Dianne S.; Pate, Russell R. // Pediatric Exercise Science;Aug2000, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p293 

    Evaluates the understanding of fourth-grade students on the concept of physical activity in South Carolina. Generic description of physical activity; Promotion of lifelong physical activity among children and adolescents in public health; Need for a well-validated measures of youth physical...

  • Physical activity.  // Primary Health Care;Jun2003, Vol. 13 Issue 5, p8 

    Discusses the factors that may lead to increased physical activity and functioning in community dwelling populations. Health benefits of physical activity; Effectiveness of counseling patients on physical activity in general practice.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics